Tuesday, November 29, 2016

Who is deplorable now? ... by gimleteye

Sentient America has spent the last two weeks reading, listening, talking; trying to sort out the inexcusable election of Donald Trump to be the next president of the United States.

For Haaretz, writer Chemi Shalev asks the right question, "Who in his right mind hands over the keys to the world to an impulsive, narcissistic know-nothing show-off, just to teach everyone else a lesson?"

Diane Hessen writes in the Boston Globe, "Understanding the undecided voters". A consultant to the Clinton campaign, Hessen's task was to interview undecided voters and communicate back her assessments.
"Last week, I reread all of my notes. There was one moment when I saw more undecided voters shift to Trump than any other, when it all changed, when voters began to speak differently about their choice. It wasn’t FBI Director James Comey, Part One or Part Two; it wasn’t Benghazi or the e-mails or Bill Clinton’s visit with Attorney General Loretta Lynch on the tarmac. No, the conversation shifted the most during the weekend of Sept. 9, after Clinton said, “You can put half of Trump supporters into what I call the basket of deplorables.” All hell broke loose."
When I heard Hillary's jab, it seemed a throwaway line in an otherwise, carefully calibrated campaign. When compared to the litany of insults that flowed like cheap Trump wine, Hillary's seemed innocuous.

In retrospect, I understand how the word "deplorable" registered with Trump voters. She called them a name; and that name called attention to conditions leaving them behind. They are not deplorable. Circumstances beyond their control are deplorable.

For misreading the misfortune and grievances felt by so many Americans, the election made Hillary Clinton wear a scarlet letter on her forehead.

Donald Trump lacks any quality of leadership one would objectively value in a president of the United States. Moreover, since his election, the only unifying theme of his transition is treating the public to a choreographed selection of a Cabinet and top officials that looks exactly like auditions for Celebrity Apprentice.

Trump supporters don't seem to mind: they want a bull in the china shop and they don't care what gets wrecked because everything is already wrecked.

From outside U.S. borders, the national spasm that pushed Trump over all challengers is shocking. Terrifying. As a proud American citizen, I only offer: we have not all lost our minds. By a margin of nearly two and a half million votes, Hillary Clinton won the popular election. More than half the electorate in the United States is disconsolate by the result and profound changes it portends for the future.

Haaretz - Israel News
The Unbearable Stupidity of Donald Trump's Election
Monday, November 28, 2016
By Chemi Shalev

Who in his right mind hands over the keys to the world to an impulsive, narcissistic know-nothing show-off, just to teach everyone else a lesson?

Hillary Clinton was a bad candidate with tons of excess baggage; Barack Obama ignored white middle class America; coastal liberal elites lost touch with America’s heartland; the media ignored white men’s rage; the Obama coalition didn’t show up at the polls; Americans are tired of being pushed around; Donald Trump is a populist genius; Clinton never recovered from the 9/11 memorial ceremony; the Russians hacked, the FBI intervened, Wikileaks never let go; social media; reality show culture; Bernie Sanders.

These and many other reasons have been posited in the three weeks since Trump’s to explain his astounding victory, and they’re all probably valid to one degree or another. But there is one overarching factor that everyone knows contributed most of all to the Trump sensation. There is one sine qua non without which none of this would have been possible. There is one standalone reason that, like a big dodo in the room, no one dares mention, ironically, because of political correctness. You know what I’m talking about: Stupidity. Dumbness. Idiocy. Whatever you want to call it: Dufusness Supreme.

It’s the principle of Occam’s Razor, which, freely put, means that the simplest answer is usually correct. So, yes, there are a lot of economic, sociological and psychological elements in play, but if it sounds stupid, looks stupid and seems stupid any way you look at it, that’s probably what it is: stupid. It’s the thought that goes through the minds of all the Americans who didn’t vote for Trump when they look at themselves nowadays in the mirror: How could we be so stupid?

Many readers are up in arms now: how dare you. How arrogant. How condescending. How can you call so many millions of voters stupid? If it was the other way around you’d be outraged, etc. etc. But if you ignore the insult for a moment and don’t mention voters and only relate to the bottom line itself, which is that in seven weeks Donald Trump will be inaugurated as President and Commander in Chief and Holder of the Nuclear Codes, most people would agree that it’s just about one of the dumbest, and therefore most dangerous things America has done. Ever.

Of course, Trump might surprise us, though thus far he hasn’t given any indication that he intends to do so. And of course he didn’t get to where he got by being stupid. Far from it. I’m not even claiming that everyone who voted for Trump is stupid, though it’s tempting. But even if you acknowledge the hurt, the grievances, the neglect, the legitimate conservative ideology and the less legitimate hatred for Barack Obama, you have to ask yourself what kind of people choose to cut off their own noses to spite their faces. How can one explain the fact that so many people ignored Trump’s lies, his ignorance, his insults, his incitement, his shady business practices, his refusal to release tax returns, his perverse and unexplained relationship with Vladimir Putin? Who in his right mind hands over the keys to the world to an impulsive narcissistic misogynist know-nothing show-off just for the hell of it, to teach everyone else a lesson? What is the logic of getting back at snobby elitists by burning down the house they live in, but so do you?

“Vox Populi vox Dei” you will say: The voice of the people is like the voice of God, and should always be respected. This may be the contemporary reading of the saying, but go back to the original, and it sounds completely different. As the learned cleric Alcuin of York wrote to Emperor Charlemagne in 798 “And those people should not be listened to who keep saying the voice of the people is the voice of God, since the riotousness of the crowd is always very close to madness.” Meaning, as a quote probably misattributed to HL Mencken notes: “Nobody ever went broke underestimating the intelligence of the American people.”

Similar sentiments were voiced by one of Israel’s socialist founding fathers, Yitzhak Ben Aharon, who supposedly said after Menachem Begin’s victory in 1977 that “if this is the people’s decision, we should replace the people” and has been held up by the right wing as an example of intolerable Ashkenazi haughtiness ever since.

What Ben Aharon actually said was “With all the respect that we are supposed to accord the people’s decision, if this is the people’s decision, I am not willing to respect it.” Even this authentic version of Ben Aharon’s words may be deemed inappropriate, but don’t forget that he and many other historic Labor leaders viewed Begin and his Herut party, precursor to the Likud, as illegitimate fascists who would change the country’s values and undo Israeli democracy. As kibbutz leader Avishai Grossman said in June 1977, “the good old Land of Israel that we represent is going to hell.” He may have been condescending and elitist as many have since alleged, but one can’t deny that he was entirely accurate.

And let’s not get carried away with the infinite wisdom of the masses, even without mentioning you-know-who, who received a plurality of German votes in 1932 and legitimately rose to power. How about Abdalá Jaime Bucaram Ortiz, aptly known as “El Loco” who won 20 of 21 provinces in the Ecuadorian elections of 1996? After celebrating his victory by singing Jailhouse Rock with a group of scantily clad dancers, he appointed his business friends to high positions in government and packed his cabinet with family members, including his 18-year-old son who was put in charge of taxes? Sound familiar?

What about Ferdinand Marcos, freely elected in 1965, who, together with his shoe-fetishist wife stole close to $10 billion from the Philippine people? What do you think of Francisco Macías Nguema, democratically elected in 1968, who murdered or exiled a third of Equatorial Guinea’s population before he was deposed in 1979? Silvio Berlusconi? Valdimir Putin? Tayip Erdogan? Richard Nixon, who gave us Watergate? James Buchanan, whose ineptness spurred the Civil War? Warren Harding, whose corruption defied imagination? Andrew Johnson who botched up Reconstruction and, as one historian wrote, “suffered from serious defects of mind and character”? Dare we mention George W Bush?

Whatever one thinks of Hillary Clinton, of abandoned Rust Belt counties, of culture wars and liberal elitism, putting Donald Trump in charge of everything is a reckless gamble, until proven otherwise. One can hope against hope to be proven wrong, but judging from what we know, Trump doesn’t have the minimal experience, knowledge, temperament, judgment, or values to carry out his job of President. Of course we all pray for his success, because the alternative is too unthinkable, but in the meantime, despite the risk that one will be accused of exhibiting the same kind of arrogant condescension that got us here in the first place, there is no other choice but to describe Trump’s election for what it is: stupid. Just plain stupid.

Chemi Shalev
Haaretz Correspondent


Anonymous said...

There is no question in my mind that the people who voted for Trump are deplorable. We must not fool ourselves, We live in a county with many deplorable people. Many of the deplorables are going to be hurt severely by actions and policies of their choice for President. When Medicare and Social Security are privatized and benefits reduced; when disability is eliminated; when they lose their jobs; lose their homes and everything they own; and when their children die in foreign wars; we must remind them they chose this reality for themselves.

Anonymous said...

"Chemi Shalev
Haaretz Correspondent"

It's always foreigners that see the situation clearer. And are not afraid to spit it out!!!!!!
Tats why, to be truly informed about domestic issues, one has to read the foreign press too.

Anonymous said...

There is a certain irony knowing that people who were so wrong about everything that transpired in the election are so certain how the future will turn out.

Since we live in a somewhat free country [exception-FB-Twitter-Google-Snopes-Politifact] perhaps these thoughts will be classified as "Fake News" by those who classify opinions, writings and commentary in the future.

Anonymous said...

We weren't so wrong. . . God has a way of letting you know how he feels about things. Tennessee voted for Trump. Today 1,000 people are running for their lives, and their homes being burnt up by the unusual fire. . . Let's watch all the areas that voted for Trump. Thankfully Miami- Dade county did not vote for Trump, so the coming hurricanes should pass us by for northern FL.

Anonymous said...

Billionaires, including one who made his fortune scavenging industrial enterprises -- Wilber Ross --, are going to solve the problems of working class men and women? LOL!