Thursday, March 04, 2010

Bilked: another story from South Florida ... by gimleteye

"Miami's little Madoff" is how one Cuban American investor described a prominent businessman and his wife, Gaston and Teresita Cantens (Trust turns to crisis for older investors, Miami Herald, March 4, 2010) . The Cantenses, a politically influential family, were charged with a $135 million real estate related investment fraud, or, Ponzi scheme.

It is inevitable the housing boom and crash, whose political origins were in Miami, would reach into the ranks of elderly Cuban and Latin American investors. This one is particularly redolent: "The Cantenses, said SEC officials, told investors that Jesuit priests and other well-known leaders in the Cuban American community had invested with Royal West. They 'targeted' investors at charitable and religious gatherings and at parties at their Miami home." According to the Herald, the Cantenses also exploited their relationship with members of the prominent Cuban American bastion and feeder of political leadership, Belen Jesuit Prep.

Of the master-strokes facilitating the housing boom, one was a new law passed by the Florida legislature in 2002. It was sponsored by then state representative Gaston I. Cantens, a rising star in the Growth Machine. The measure, called the Everglades Bill or HB 813, helped also to divide and conquer the environmental community. The bill provided $100 million for the Everglades at the same time as eroding citizen rights to protest ill-advised developments, such as those promoted in West Dade suburbs. (Audubon supported the bill, and many other environmental groups blasted it, leading to mistrust in Florida that continues to this day.)

The Cantens bill helped along the process of so much crappy, fetid overdevelopment that fit the needs of Wall Street finance -- and continuous pressure by big, special interests. Today's sad news about "Miami's Little Madoff" is just another blip on a radar screen filled with the static of trillion dollar bailouts by taxpayers and concessions to the flattened homebuilders. In the 2002, the bill Cantens, the son, pushed through raised the threshold for community groups to challenge changes to growth plans. It was a delightful resume builder: eventually Cantens left to the legislature to take on the job as vice president for public relations for Fanjul family sugar barons.) The Herald notes that the son is not named in the SEC complaint.

In 2002, the St. Pete Times editorial board, along with every editorial board in the state, weighed in against the Cantens measure, calling it an "unwarranted assault" against citizen standing: "Now, if a developer seeks a permit on a project that threatens to degrade the environment, Florida residents have a reasonable opportunity to oppose the permit. There is no indication that the right is being abused or that developers are thwarted if their projects are responsible. Yet a fair hearing for the environment is too much to ask of some legislators." (April 3, 2002)

The housing boom in West Dade farmland and wetlands minted South Florida millionaires by the barrel full. The SEC charges that the Cantenses used "$20 million from investors to pay themselves exorbitant salaries, to invest in other projects and to divert some $1 million to their children and grandchildren in the form of alleged 'consulting fees'. The website, Condo Vultures, paints the background of crashed real estate empires: "Delinquent real estate loans at Florida-based banks spiked by 47 percent in 2009 compared to a year earlier as the number of financial institutions in the state decreased by 21, according to a new report from CondoVultures.com."

The Miami Herald doesn't specify what investments, exactly, comprise the failed Cantenses' portfolio called Royal West Properties, but Condo Vultures provides context to the overall market for suburban sprawl that was triggered by the housing boom and its political origins in West Dade suburbs: ""Residential real estate prices have tumbled significantly since the peak of the market in the fourth quarter of 2005," said Peter Zalewski, a principal with the Bal Harbour, Fla.-based real estate consultancy Condo Vultures® LLC. "The challenge for many buyers is the under-$250,000 properties are increasingly located west of Interstate 95 in the suburban areas of South Florida."

Those ghost suburbs aren't filling with happy and gullible new buyers any time soon. Still the stories of personal devastation, of families ripped apart, and dreams dashed are only just beginning to be told. How it all ties back to "The Ownership Society" and its political origins in Miami is still nowhere to be found in the mainstream media.

10 comments:

CATO said...

Yes Comrade Gimleteeye the Cuban's in Miami are solely and single handidly responsible for the great recession.
The problem with the "ownership" society wasn't that it encouraged ownership but that the government subsidized it.
This all will pale in comparison to the pension and government debt tsunami headed our way, this will be more difficult to solve because in the private sector when you go bust, you go bust.BUT in the gubment you just squeze those itty bitty taxpayers problem is them itty bitty taxpayers ain't got notin left so something gotta give.

TIMBER!!!!!!

Gimleteye said...

This story concerns documented abuses by the politically powerful and influential. It is not about the Anglo 'snatch and grab' that was responsible for the first rings of sprawl or the troubled development patterns favored by Greenberg Traurig a la carte zoning change menus. You misread me, for your own reasons.

http://eyeonmiami.blogspot.com/2008/01/miami-latin-builders-association-and.html

CATO said...

"How it all ties back to "The Ownership Society" and its political origins in Miami is still nowhere to be found in the mainstream media."

So the LBA is the root of all evil?] Truly Burton, Carlo Ponzi, Bernie Madoff, Greenspan and stanford are all Cuban's in disguise?

Come on Alan spread the blame like it should be spread nice and evenly

Gimleteye said...

http://eyeonmiami.blogspot.com/2009/03/dear-vice-president-biden-dont-support.html

CATO said...

I have never itched my ass in public, scratched it maybe but never itced it, how about you Gimspierre?
I know Gaston Cantens Jr and his family and doubt that everything in the complaint happened as it is stated, I'm not saying the Cantenses are totally blameless (lets see how it plays out before we send them to the scaffold, OK Gimspierre) but I seriously doubt this rises to the level of the Madoff ponzi scandal NOT EVEN CLOSE. Makes for good qoutes and headlines though.

Anonymous said...

So how many Belen alumni and friends were ripped off by these thieves?

How ironic the criminals son was an elected official who now works to pollute the Everglades on behalf of Big Sugar? Florida Crystals.

Anonymous said...

Why?

Anonymous said...

Because he or she is calling the couple of 75 year olds whose company and everything they worked for in life crumbled with the real estate collapse, thieves and criminals. Let the system work and they will have their day in court...Innocent until proven guilty is our system. Greed had a lot to do with the investors.
I also fail to see the irony of the son being an ex legislator who now works for Fl Crystals. It is what it is. One has nothing to do with the other.....Do you not put sugar in your coffee?

bheartlib said...

So, Cato...does the Ponzi have to reach the billions before it counts? Does the fact that a bill was introduced by the son of the schemer in the Florida Leg. somehow not count either? Must we forget these facts because you know the Cantens family? Alrighty then!!!

CATO said...

NO YOU MORON, First the bill described by gimspierre actually went against the parents business interest since they were condo converters not developers of new product, and BTW he probably introduced DOZENS of bills (I think thats what legislators do).
As for the the Elder Cantenses I suspect that bad judgement and the RE collapse has more to do with their investors financial demise than anything resembling Madoffs total fraud. The company actually owned RE.
This blog seems to be populated by holier than though types, like a mirror of the Christian Coalition.