The very term, “traffic calming measure” as applied to traffic circles makes our little hamster wheel break into pieces.
Most of the time, we’re on the same side of the road as Herald “Streetwise” columnist Larry Lebowitz. It is good that someone at the Miami Herald is paying attention to traffic. But yesterday’s “Traffic circles on the rise” was street-ready as a Ford Pinto.
We have had a beef with traffic circles since they started becoming as ubiquitous as “tattoos on twentysomethings.” That much we agree on.
But the column veers off the road shoulder when we read that “local governments are turning to circles to combat speeding and cut down on high volumes of cut-through traffic in residential areas.”
That is not what local governments are “turning to”.
What local government is turning to are developer impact fees, paid as a condition of building permits for malls and high rises to address traffic impacts. It is called "mitigation". And it is worthless.
Many if not all of the traffic circles popping up are paid for as traffic “mitigation” by developers. They mitigate nothing.
Traffic circles are “calming” to traffic as pepper spray is calming to an elephant.
Developers and compliant city and county commissioners have shifted the cost of development to taxpayers and residents in a way that is unsustainable in Miami.
Infrastructure like roadways and mass transit are so inadequate in Miami that businesses increasingly view our region as an inhospitable place to work.
So you would think that the Chamber of Commerce and Miami Herald would be on our side in calling for a drastic reduction in building permits until basic infrastructure problems are worked out, funded, and constructed.
We’re sitting on $7 billion of unfunded infrastructure deficits! So here’s our suggestion: that the next “Sand in our Shoes” award given by the Chamber to a land use lobbyist, lawyer, or developer should be a traffic circle.
Come to think of it: the mayor, the city and county commissioners who blessed every single construction crane towering over the City of Miami, indifferent to whether people living here now, or living here in the future, will even be able to get out of their condominium garages, should all have traffic circles named after them.
Long after they are gone and forgotten, future generations of car owners will wonder—wtf is this traffic circle doing here?
That is why we’re leaning on the horn with respect to Lebowitz’s piece, because you have to read all the way to the bottom of the article before you get to the meat of the matter, “It’s always easier for politicians to satisfy short-term, micro-local problems, a block at a time, with quick, relatively inexpensive fixes. But who’s looking out for the impact on the transportation network as a whole?”
That IS the question about the inane purpose of traffic “calming” measures. We know that Larry Lebowitz understands—so why isn’t the focus of his column the inadequacy of traffic mitigation fees, paid by developers?
We’re waiting for an answer…
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query traffic. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query traffic. Sort by date Show all posts
Tuesday, April 03, 2007
Thursday, February 01, 2018
Developers Pay For Traffic Studies? The Corrupt Sham and Shame of It. Guest Blog by Stuckintraffic
The reality of traffic studies: You can make the numbers work for whomever is paying you and it is almost always the developer.
There is corruption rampant in Traffic Impact Studies. I had trouble sleeping last night because I was planning on writing this. So, here are a few words. There was a time even not too long ago when I was naive enough to believe that the system could be fixed:
A basic life lesson that we learned at an early age (or, that most of us learned) is that we have to clean up after ourselves, that we must “mitigate” problems caused by our actions. Supposedly, developers are required to mitigate the impact that their developments have on the traffic infrastructure by either improving the infrastructure or paying for needed improvements to the infrastructure.
This is widely accepted and universally addressed in Comprehensive Plans at the municipal, county, and state levels. Governmental agencies require the submission of a Traffic Impact Study before approving any development. And, these studies must show that the impact of a proposed development does not degrade the Level of Service (LOS) below minimum levels.
It all sounds great, doesn’t it?
But in truth, its all a sham, an imposture, a fraud. The system has been corrupted.
The legislatures – municipal, county, and state - have abdicated to the developers the responsibility and the right to perform these impact studies, and the right to choose the method of measuring LOS. So, the developers choose a methodology that grossly misrepresents LOS on roadways that are already severely congested. (In fact, the State of Florida actually recommends this inaccurate method – the count based methodology - in their “QLOS Handbook”.)
So, no matter how congested a roadway is, the developer’s impact study shows that the LOS is acceptable, even with the additional traffic that their development will generate. And, municipalities must, as required by their own laws, and by both county and state laws, accept this bullshit and approve the development.
So, traffic continues to get worse and worse.
The truth of these statements is obvious to anyone that drives on the roadways anywhere in the state of Florida.
The system is corrupt – top to bottom.
How did this happen?
The developers are major campaign donors for candidates running for public office. In fact, many of our elected officials are actually developers themselves. As a result of their money, the developers have corrupted and now control the legislature.
It is so bad, even the traffic study
And traffic engineers know what side of the bread is buttered. They know that if they generate a study that shows impact, they will be blacklisted – they will never work for a developer again. And those traffic engineers that work (or contract) for a governmental agency know that if they object to blatantly dishonest traffic studies, they will never get a plum job with a traffic engineering company. And realistically, even if they did object to a dishonest study, the study will be upheld in the courts because to allow use of blatantly dishonest studies is written into law. So, engineers issue blatantly dishonest studies and professional opinions in violation of their professional code of ethics.
Both our government and professional engineering in the state of Florida have been corrupted by developers’ money. This sham really sucks and I am stuck in traffic daily because of it.
Join with Pinecrest, Palmetto Bay, Cutler Bay and County Commissioner Levine Cava (our host) for Traffic Solutions Summit - This Saturday, 9 AM to Noon, Cutler Bay Town Hall, Penthouse, 10720 Caribbean Blvd. Space is limited - register here.
(Geniusofdespair - we wrote about this in 2015 even posting a picture of the Traffic Engineer most popular with developers.)
Monday, November 24, 2014
Ferocious Traffic: what comes next? … by gimleteye
In Miami during the summer, traffic is a breeze compared to what comes next. As schools return and the fall weather improves, traffic turns titanic.
What is happening downtown, these days, at rush hour and beyond defies elaboration. There is only one word for the blaring horns, lane restrictions, the gridlock at successive street lights: ferocious.
The traffic is ferocious for a reason.
When you are stuck in Miami traffic this December, remember: you voted for the elected officials -- in the city of Miami, the city of Miami Beach, in Miami-Dade county, the state legislature and Governor's Mansion who made this happen.
Many of these public officials are still in office. Many are looking for a way back in.
Will voters ever hold them accountable for the destruction of quality of life that goes along with community-stifling, business-deadening traffic? Not yet.
There is every indication (Ludlam Trail, anyone?) that our elected officials will continue to vote for "compromises" that impose even greater traffic burdens on taxpayers and residents.
Massive construction and development of downtown corridors preceded any response by elected officials to estimate, plan and build infrastructure adequate to the need.
Sure every zoning and permitting hearing is clogged with expert consultants, using charts and graphs to show how their client's project will not increase traffic.
Complainers -- civic activists for better transit, for public parks and the environment -- are derided, dismissed, marginalized or otherwise politely pushed away by technicalities.
Builders during the boom and even after the bust are glorified. Their names get put on buildings, while the mess they helped created is absorbed as the natural order of things. Jorge Perez, for example. Mayor Manny Diaz, for example.
When you want "growth at any cost", the way the Chamber of Commerce or Club for Growth or Associated Industries or the South Florida Builders do, taxpayers are left with exactly this: ferocious traffic.
These days one begins to hear voices from the business sector in advertiser-sponsored media, lamenting we "could" kill the goose that lays the golden egg. Ex-cuse me?
For distant investors -- that describes the vast majority of owners in downtown Miami -- all that matters is that their assets are safe and secure. The rest of us -- the commuters, the downtown residents imagining they are moving into a sophisticated city -- are fuel pellets for growth.
You could ask, wouldn't it be a good idea to make traffic improvements concurrent at the same time or in advance of construction and development?
At the state level, the idea of comprehensive land use planning was destroyed by the Republican legislature after more than thirty years of work and bipartisan consensus. Was Gov. Scott held accountable for putting the Florida DCA, the agency once charged with reviewing traffic concurrency, into a capital broom closet?
As all the Miami condo canyons were being created and making mortgage investors, insurers, banks and their shareholders very wealthy on Brickell and downtown, of course they knew that the roadways would not be able to hold the traffic.
We've been planning badly for transit to accommodate growth for so long that, now, there is no elasticity whatsoever in car movement along Miami's roadways and interstates. At rush hour, any -- and I mean, ANY -- glitch in traffic flow causes a massive logjam that can easily double or triple normal transit times.
The other evening, trying to find the fastest route downtown -- imagining to be on the far side of rush hour -- I looked at my Google map and every road and artery downtown was a solid red line. It was a representation of cardiac arrest.
Ferocious traffic is not destiny. It is what we chose at the ballot box.
What is happening downtown, these days, at rush hour and beyond defies elaboration. There is only one word for the blaring horns, lane restrictions, the gridlock at successive street lights: ferocious.
The traffic is ferocious for a reason.
| image at 8:21 AM |
When you are stuck in Miami traffic this December, remember: you voted for the elected officials -- in the city of Miami, the city of Miami Beach, in Miami-Dade county, the state legislature and Governor's Mansion who made this happen.
Many of these public officials are still in office. Many are looking for a way back in.
Will voters ever hold them accountable for the destruction of quality of life that goes along with community-stifling, business-deadening traffic? Not yet.
There is every indication (Ludlam Trail, anyone?) that our elected officials will continue to vote for "compromises" that impose even greater traffic burdens on taxpayers and residents.
Sure every zoning and permitting hearing is clogged with expert consultants, using charts and graphs to show how their client's project will not increase traffic.
Complainers -- civic activists for better transit, for public parks and the environment -- are derided, dismissed, marginalized or otherwise politely pushed away by technicalities.
Builders during the boom and even after the bust are glorified. Their names get put on buildings, while the mess they helped created is absorbed as the natural order of things. Jorge Perez, for example. Mayor Manny Diaz, for example.
When you want "growth at any cost", the way the Chamber of Commerce or Club for Growth or Associated Industries or the South Florida Builders do, taxpayers are left with exactly this: ferocious traffic.
These days one begins to hear voices from the business sector in advertiser-sponsored media, lamenting we "could" kill the goose that lays the golden egg. Ex-cuse me?
For distant investors -- that describes the vast majority of owners in downtown Miami -- all that matters is that their assets are safe and secure. The rest of us -- the commuters, the downtown residents imagining they are moving into a sophisticated city -- are fuel pellets for growth.
You could ask, wouldn't it be a good idea to make traffic improvements concurrent at the same time or in advance of construction and development?
At the state level, the idea of comprehensive land use planning was destroyed by the Republican legislature after more than thirty years of work and bipartisan consensus. Was Gov. Scott held accountable for putting the Florida DCA, the agency once charged with reviewing traffic concurrency, into a capital broom closet?
As all the Miami condo canyons were being created and making mortgage investors, insurers, banks and their shareholders very wealthy on Brickell and downtown, of course they knew that the roadways would not be able to hold the traffic.
We've been planning badly for transit to accommodate growth for so long that, now, there is no elasticity whatsoever in car movement along Miami's roadways and interstates. At rush hour, any -- and I mean, ANY -- glitch in traffic flow causes a massive logjam that can easily double or triple normal transit times.
The other evening, trying to find the fastest route downtown -- imagining to be on the far side of rush hour -- I looked at my Google map and every road and artery downtown was a solid red line. It was a representation of cardiac arrest.
Ferocious traffic is not destiny. It is what we chose at the ballot box.
Monday, September 19, 2011
Traffic congestion: who wins?... by gimleteye
It was no surprise to read in the Miami Herald that according to red light camera statistics, I live a stone's throw from the "worst overall intersection" in South Florida: Coral Gables’ northbound South Dixie Highway and Jefferson Street.
Drivers get ticketed there, on average, 30 times a day. There is a reason. Drivers heading north have just fumed at even more clogged traffic intersections at LeJeune and Ponce. These intersections were already over-congested a decade ago, when the City of Coral Gables permitted the "Village" of Merrick Park over the objection of nimbys. I was among a handful of residents who objected to the Rouse Project because, I was already an expert in these over-saturated intersections.
But what is the complaint of commuters next to the imperative to build more and more and more? I'm guessing, notwithstanding the Great Recession, that lobbyists and politicians are itching to do it all over again. Isn't that where tax base comes from: more development? Increased tax base covers municipal infrastructure costs. But wait, if development paid its own way, how come we have staggering municipal deficits? Perhaps we hired too many traffic counters who were paid not to count. Anyhow, here is who wins.
Rouse Company won. So did its phalanx of lobbyists, local yo-yo's, and politicians including former Mayor Raul Valdez Fauli. Get a traffic ticket at US 1 and Jefferson: you might try sending it to Valdez Fauli. Here's who else won: the flippers at General Growth Properties who purchased Merrick Park then took the whole company through bankruptcy in 2009. There were a lot of losers. Stockholders, for one. But the biggest losers are the commuters who use US 1, or at least, the most aggravated.
It is useful to go back and review the historical record. It doesn't do much good to point out that "we told you so", not when the red traffic camera lights are flashing on your license plate. Here is an excerpt from a 1999 editorial of mine, published on the topic, in the Miami Herald:
Drivers get ticketed there, on average, 30 times a day. There is a reason. Drivers heading north have just fumed at even more clogged traffic intersections at LeJeune and Ponce. These intersections were already over-congested a decade ago, when the City of Coral Gables permitted the "Village" of Merrick Park over the objection of nimbys. I was among a handful of residents who objected to the Rouse Project because, I was already an expert in these over-saturated intersections.
But what is the complaint of commuters next to the imperative to build more and more and more? I'm guessing, notwithstanding the Great Recession, that lobbyists and politicians are itching to do it all over again. Isn't that where tax base comes from: more development? Increased tax base covers municipal infrastructure costs. But wait, if development paid its own way, how come we have staggering municipal deficits? Perhaps we hired too many traffic counters who were paid not to count. Anyhow, here is who wins.
Rouse Company won. So did its phalanx of lobbyists, local yo-yo's, and politicians including former Mayor Raul Valdez Fauli. Get a traffic ticket at US 1 and Jefferson: you might try sending it to Valdez Fauli. Here's who else won: the flippers at General Growth Properties who purchased Merrick Park then took the whole company through bankruptcy in 2009. There were a lot of losers. Stockholders, for one. But the biggest losers are the commuters who use US 1, or at least, the most aggravated.
It is useful to go back and review the historical record. It doesn't do much good to point out that "we told you so", not when the red traffic camera lights are flashing on your license plate. Here is an excerpt from a 1999 editorial of mine, published on the topic, in the Miami Herald:
Wednesday, April 13, 2016
Teeth grinding traffic: the Miami-Dade County Commission aren't the only ones responsible ... by gimleteye
Commissioner Juan Zapata made news recently calling for a building moratorium in West Dade, pushed by constituents -- and his own experience -- being stuck in teeth grinding traffic.
To know who is responsible for allowing the over-development and job-killing traffic, count the members of the Board of County Commissioners who have been in office for many, many years: Bruno Barreiro, Pepe Diaz and Javier Souto. They are not alone, but they have been reliable and consistent votes for more sprawl. They are charter members of the Unreformable Majority. The traffic jam you are stuck in, is their doing.
My first foray into the politics of sprawl and traffic was in 1993, when Javier Souto was the deciding vote -- against the wishes of the Latin Builders Association -- on the requirement for a 2/3rds supermajority of the county commission to changes zoning in the county master development plan. I marshaled a civic coalition under the umbrella -- Alliance for Sustainable Communities -- and counted among the strongest supporters the same neighborhood associations that Commissioner Zapata represents today. That was more than twenty years ago.
Citizens won that battle, but they lost the war on sprawl and traffic. Time after time at the county commission, zoning approvals were accompanied by solemn traffic engineering reports: everything was fine, they said. No need to worry or panic.
More than ten years ago, there was a chance to hold the line on development affecting the wellfield protection zone and the fresh water supply serving more than 2 million residents and visitors. The issue, then, was the "transmissivity" of the Biscayne aquifer and the "travel time" of water flowing from the margin of the zone to the wells.
The Board of County Commissioners allowed major new developments in the West Dade region on the premise -- contested by environmentalists -- that the wellfield zone had sufficient boundaries to be protective of water quality. Instead of erring on the side of caution, the Unreformable Majority was relentless in pushing for exactly the forms of development that, absent good mass transit, incubate traffic nightmares.
Look no further than the influence of lobbyists -- Greenberg Traurig, first and foremost, but also including a roster of lesser players -- who for all intents and purposes owned the county commission. Rodney Barreto. Chris Korge. The big farmers in South Dade? They cheered enthusiastically as Kendall metastasized south and west to Krome Avenue.
What is really teeth grinding about today's traffic: it is exactly the collateral damage of what Miami-Dade's business community wanted. We've been writing about this for a long time at Eye On Miami. Do a quick archive search, under "traffic" or just type "traffic" in the search bar.
Why do voters keep returning Barreiro, Souto, and Diaz to elected office? Judging by their near-permanent incumbencies, apparently teeth grinding traffic is what voters want, too.
To know who is responsible for allowing the over-development and job-killing traffic, count the members of the Board of County Commissioners who have been in office for many, many years: Bruno Barreiro, Pepe Diaz and Javier Souto. They are not alone, but they have been reliable and consistent votes for more sprawl. They are charter members of the Unreformable Majority. The traffic jam you are stuck in, is their doing.
My first foray into the politics of sprawl and traffic was in 1993, when Javier Souto was the deciding vote -- against the wishes of the Latin Builders Association -- on the requirement for a 2/3rds supermajority of the county commission to changes zoning in the county master development plan. I marshaled a civic coalition under the umbrella -- Alliance for Sustainable Communities -- and counted among the strongest supporters the same neighborhood associations that Commissioner Zapata represents today. That was more than twenty years ago.
Citizens won that battle, but they lost the war on sprawl and traffic. Time after time at the county commission, zoning approvals were accompanied by solemn traffic engineering reports: everything was fine, they said. No need to worry or panic.
More than ten years ago, there was a chance to hold the line on development affecting the wellfield protection zone and the fresh water supply serving more than 2 million residents and visitors. The issue, then, was the "transmissivity" of the Biscayne aquifer and the "travel time" of water flowing from the margin of the zone to the wells.
The Board of County Commissioners allowed major new developments in the West Dade region on the premise -- contested by environmentalists -- that the wellfield zone had sufficient boundaries to be protective of water quality. Instead of erring on the side of caution, the Unreformable Majority was relentless in pushing for exactly the forms of development that, absent good mass transit, incubate traffic nightmares.
Look no further than the influence of lobbyists -- Greenberg Traurig, first and foremost, but also including a roster of lesser players -- who for all intents and purposes owned the county commission. Rodney Barreto. Chris Korge. The big farmers in South Dade? They cheered enthusiastically as Kendall metastasized south and west to Krome Avenue.
What is really teeth grinding about today's traffic: it is exactly the collateral damage of what Miami-Dade's business community wanted. We've been writing about this for a long time at Eye On Miami. Do a quick archive search, under "traffic" or just type "traffic" in the search bar.
Why do voters keep returning Barreiro, Souto, and Diaz to elected office? Judging by their near-permanent incumbencies, apparently teeth grinding traffic is what voters want, too.
Wednesday, February 18, 2015
The Miami Herald Editorial Board and Traffic: NOW you ask us? … by gimleteye
NOW, the editorial board of the Miami Herald is soliciting readers' opinions on what to do about our area's massive traffic congestion. We've written on this topic for years. (In the upper left search bar, type "traffic", and see a sampling like "If traffic so calm, why is the Miami Herald spinning in circles" from 2007.) A question: WHERE was the Miami Herald editorial board on this issue when all the unsustainable growth occurred in suburbs and downtown? The answer: AWOL. Nowhere. Absent.
And not just the editorial board: journalists at the Herald were discouraged from pursuing stories that tied traffic congestion and environmental harm to growth.
Where the Herald editorial board writes, "We want to be part of the solution", we can only rub our eyes in disbelief. "The Board will hold local, state and federal officials accountable." Gimleteye to Miami Herald: that train left the station a long time ago, thanks in no small part to your looking the other way, when you could have elevated readers' awareness about the costs of poorly planned growth.
It's happening right now, again!, in South Dade farmland with the 826 Extension. Why don't you start right there!?
Here is today's missive from the city's only daily newspaper:
And not just the editorial board: journalists at the Herald were discouraged from pursuing stories that tied traffic congestion and environmental harm to growth.
Where the Herald editorial board writes, "We want to be part of the solution", we can only rub our eyes in disbelief. "The Board will hold local, state and federal officials accountable." Gimleteye to Miami Herald: that train left the station a long time ago, thanks in no small part to your looking the other way, when you could have elevated readers' awareness about the costs of poorly planned growth.
It's happening right now, again!, in South Dade farmland with the 826 Extension. Why don't you start right there!?
"MDX has commenced the SR 836/Dolphin Expressway Southwest Extension Project Development and Environment Study (PD&E). The Public Kick-Off Meeting took place on September 4, 2014. As part of the scope of work, MDX incorporated the scheduling of an Environmental Forum, the purpose of which is to bring together specific key groups focused on environmental interests, elicit their input and comment, and provide a special venue for future dialogue.""Public kick-off"? How about public-kick-in-the-transportation-ass?
Here is today's missive from the city's only daily newspaper:
There are few issues Miami-Dade residents agree upon, but here’s one: Traffic gridlock and frustrated drivers are killing us. Figuratively and, yes, literally.
We all must deal with this new reality: Weekday rush hour in South Florida in the good ol’ days extended from 7 a.m. to 9 a.m. and then again from 3 p.m. to 6 p.m., Monday through Friday. But these days, almost every hour is rush hour.
The Editorial Board receives scores of letters every week from local residents who struggle to get from Point A to Point B — be it in a car, on a bus or a bike, on foot, or on rail.
We want to be part of the solution. We are asking our readers to use our page to tell community leaders where the problems exist and what ideas they have to solve them. We’re calling the Editorial Board’s traffic initiative, H*ll on Wheels. Join us, we’ll post your complaints.
After all, who better than readers know the most dangerous intersection to cross on foot?
Or where a street light is out of sync, clogging traffic flow? Or bus routes where it takes three transfers to get there?
What are some routes to avoid bumper-to-bumper traffic on Interstate 95 or the Palmetto Expressway?
We are now the third most populous state in the country, with 19 million residents and 16 million registered vehicles. Enough said.
Traffic congestion is making timely mobility in our community nearly impossible and is negatively affecting too many lives. The issue deserves as much attention as any other in our community.
▪ Bicyclists and pedestrians are being struck and killed by vehicles at an alarming rate. This must stop.
▪ A shocking number of drivers who hit pedestrians flee the scene, even when they’re not to blame. Where’s the sense of personal responsibility?
▪ Our to-and-from-work commutes are eating up our time and damaging our quality of life. This is simply unfair.
▪ Expressway tolls are eating into our wallets, but offer little tangible relief.
▪ Despite new tentacles, Metrorail still doesn’t go where many of us need to go.
And don’t get us started on the speeders, lane weavers and tailgaters.
To his credit, Miami-Dade Mayor Carlos Gimenez realizes we have a serious traffic problem, but how to fund projects for the fixes is a big obstacle, he said at the recent Citizens’ Independent Transportation Summit, where pamphlets addressing the problems flew like confetti.
The Board will hold local, state and federal officials accountable. And we’ll find it who’s tracking down the worst of the drivers.
What else? You tell us. HeraldEd@MiamiHerald.com.
Wednesday, May 16, 2007
More, on road rage by gimleteye

Some interesting comments to yesterday's post... so here's more rubber for the road.
I don't think road rage correlates with culture, per se. The more time people spend stuck in cars in traffic, the less tolerant they become. The less tolerant, the more prone to sparks and road rage.
Why should our lives be dictated by traffic patterns in cars? You think traffic can't get any worse in Miami, and it does. Have you seen how traffic jams out of the city, north and south, keep edging earlier into the afternoon? Leaving Miami, going northbound on 95, has turned into a nightmare at 3:30 in the afternoon.
It's the feeling of being hostage to traffic that drives people to road rage. A high percentage of people in Miami-Dade want to organize their lives around avoiding traffic. The responses vary, from choosing where to work (the lucky ones), to taking every short cut imaginable, and a few--to taking mass transit.
I know someone who lives in West Kendall and works in South Miami, less than fifteen miles away. She told me, she usually leaves her house around 7 AM and arrives at work half an hour later, then waits for an hour before the doors open. She waits, because when she leaves her house at 7:30 AM, it takes her at least an hour to travel the same distance and, often, even longer. But she'd rather leave earlier, because she hates the anxiety of not getting to work on time.
Think of the stress this puts on families. I love how conservatives love to talk about "family values", but you never hear any talk about limiting development--no, that would restrict property rights-- or investing in mass transit--no, that means increasing taxes-- so people can actually spend time with their families instead of stuck in traffic.
Remember how demographics used to talk about the 2 car family? Now, EVERY family member has to have a car, because not only is mass transit miserable, but there are very few places you can safely travel in the course of daily chores by bicycle.
So Miamians are literally stuck on the Palmetto. It's the feeling of being helpless, especially during commutes that can be hellish, that sets some people off at the slightest provocation.
Our region has poorly adapted to growth, and we're paying for it.
Take Miami International Airport as an example. It was built for a small city, and now it is costing billions (not to mention the opportunistic public corruption) to expand the facilities while operating an ongoing business. Because of the inefficiencies, Miami has lost significant business to other airports in the region like Fort Lauderdale.
By postponing infrastructure investment instead of investing as we go along (which involves accounting for the costs of development as they are incurred: cf. Miami Dade Water and Sewer Department, not), Miami was a cheap place for development. It's no longer cheap, but it's also no longer livable: bad transportation infrastructure, pathetic public parks and recreational facilities, inadequate wastewater treatment, and a power elite constantly scrambling around the conversion of farmland to zero lot line development, or more condos in level of service "F" transit corridors through manipulation of local legislatures.
This is costing Miami in terms of economic potential, which should be setting alarm bells off at the chamber of commerce but apparently it's mainly resulting in a lot of hand-wringing. "Oh we can't criticize builders." "Oh we can't do anything about protecting more open space, or, advocating more taxes to protect our water quality." Add traffic circles!
In many cases, businesses can't attract high skilled workers because they come to Miami and get stuck in traffic. There are some bright spots: the University of Miami is building housing for scientists and doctors associated with its ambitious medical and science technology programs, but still: the new arrivals will be stuck in traffic.
The growth machine in Miami is sputtering. Road rage is only one of the symptoms.
Tuesday, December 20, 2016
Traffic, traffic, traffic ... by gimleteye
An interesting Letter to the Editor in the Herald this morning on traffic related to the MEGA MALL planned in Northwest Dade made me do a U-turn on my morning rounds. It's worth a brief look at our archive on traffic. We sure spend enough time there.
Judging from the hard right turn of state and national politics, we are all about to spend ALOT more time in traffic, especially those who live in the western, southern, and less developed sections of the county.
Once upon a time, citizens had a platform to protest unreasonable development. It was called the Growth Management Act. I'm not even sure that voters are aware that Republicans in the state legislature, under Gov. Rick Scott, put Growth Management -- and hopes of citizens to protect their quality of life -- in a broom closet in the state capitol.
That happened. Fact, not fake.
Cautionary tale warns of mega mall traffic
The mega mall that is being considered by the Miami-Dade County Commission ignores residents’ quality of life. This fact is overshadowed by the dollar signs the county envisions.
I live off of Ives Dairy Road in North Dade. We are the pathway to Aventura Mall. From 7-10 a.m. and 1:45-8 p.m. or later, there is complete gridlock. You might think, “Big deal.” Well, it is when 4,000 cars enter our neighborhood to avoid Ives Dairy Road every day. Lucky for us that WAZE re-directs motorists that way.
These unwanted visitors speed through our streets, regardless of stop signs, pass other motorists on two-lane roads — even around curves — just to get to I-95 five seconds earlier. And we are not allowed to keep them out because these are public streets. Our desire for speed bumps or humps has been rejected several times because they would slow down emergency vehicles. Aventura Mall is in the midst of a major expansion. Yet, there is no plan to address the increased volume of traffic. When questioned, we are told there is no way to ease traffic.
The neighbors to be affected by the proposed mega mall will, for sure, have their quality of life severely compromised. Their concerns should supersede monetary greed.
As our neighborhood has learned, once the go-ahead is given, all promises by the builder are null and void. No one from the county ever checks up on promises made, and the residents suffer.
Regardless of how terrific a major attraction, hotel and a mall could be, they do not belong in a residential neighborhood. Comparison to Disney World does not work here. Disney was built in an uninhabited area.
I totally sympathize with our western neighbors. No one is listening to them because none of those who will benefit from this monstrosity live in their neighborhood.
TRUDY LECHNER, MIAMI
Read more here: http://www.miamiherald.com/opinion/letters-to-the-editor/article121884408.html#storylink=cpy
Judging from the hard right turn of state and national politics, we are all about to spend ALOT more time in traffic, especially those who live in the western, southern, and less developed sections of the county.
Once upon a time, citizens had a platform to protest unreasonable development. It was called the Growth Management Act. I'm not even sure that voters are aware that Republicans in the state legislature, under Gov. Rick Scott, put Growth Management -- and hopes of citizens to protect their quality of life -- in a broom closet in the state capitol.
That happened. Fact, not fake.
Cautionary tale warns of mega mall traffic
The mega mall that is being considered by the Miami-Dade County Commission ignores residents’ quality of life. This fact is overshadowed by the dollar signs the county envisions.
I live off of Ives Dairy Road in North Dade. We are the pathway to Aventura Mall. From 7-10 a.m. and 1:45-8 p.m. or later, there is complete gridlock. You might think, “Big deal.” Well, it is when 4,000 cars enter our neighborhood to avoid Ives Dairy Road every day. Lucky for us that WAZE re-directs motorists that way.
These unwanted visitors speed through our streets, regardless of stop signs, pass other motorists on two-lane roads — even around curves — just to get to I-95 five seconds earlier. And we are not allowed to keep them out because these are public streets. Our desire for speed bumps or humps has been rejected several times because they would slow down emergency vehicles. Aventura Mall is in the midst of a major expansion. Yet, there is no plan to address the increased volume of traffic. When questioned, we are told there is no way to ease traffic.
The neighbors to be affected by the proposed mega mall will, for sure, have their quality of life severely compromised. Their concerns should supersede monetary greed.
As our neighborhood has learned, once the go-ahead is given, all promises by the builder are null and void. No one from the county ever checks up on promises made, and the residents suffer.
Regardless of how terrific a major attraction, hotel and a mall could be, they do not belong in a residential neighborhood. Comparison to Disney World does not work here. Disney was built in an uninhabited area.
I totally sympathize with our western neighbors. No one is listening to them because none of those who will benefit from this monstrosity live in their neighborhood.
TRUDY LECHNER, MIAMI
Read more here: http://www.miamiherald.com/opinion/letters-to-the-editor/article121884408.html#storylink=cpy
Friday, July 24, 2015
Traffic and Roadways: Miami's Achilles Heel ... by gimleteye
A recent Miami Herald poll by Bendixen & Amandi International identified "traffic congestion" as the second most important issue identified by voters, after "jobs and the economy". No wonder.
Borrowing a term used in economics, transit supply is inelastic. Although we have maxed out on capacity to absorb automobiles, elected officials continue to permit new developments across the county. The tipping point was breached a long time ago. Traffic congestion not only diminishes quality of life for current residents, it is a real drag on job creation in South Florida.
The answer to traffic congestion, at least in the minds of Miami-Dade county commissioners, has been to dump more cars into commutes from the western suburbs and in the minds of Miami City commissioners, more permits for condos to rise vertically in concrete canyons.
Elected officials should be held accountable, but they are not. Only a few years ago, Gov. Rick Scott and the state legislature eliminated state planning mandates intended to regulated traffic by requiring concurrency, or, a clear picture how transportation infrastructure would accommodate new population growth. That concurrency never worked in Florida is a testament; not to the willingness of elected officials to turn a blind eye so much as the talent of transportation planners and lobbyists to rationalize irrational behavior. At the same time, voters whose lives are turned upside down by traffic believe elected officials are just doing their jobs when they permit traffic-inducing construction and development to overwhelm capacity.
To this list of transit debacles that are crowding out people, you may add your own:
1) Brickell Avenue at any rush hour.
2) Access to Miami Beach via Alton Road.
3) Commuting to and from Bird Road or any of the east/west corridors.
4) US 1 at Ponce and LeJeune Rd. in Coral Gables.
5) Any cultural or sports event in downtown Miami.
Still, in the Bendixen & Amandi poll, 67 percent of respondents glided past traffic while favoring the creation of the largest mall in the United States in northwest Miami-Dade.
At Politico, Miami-based writer Michael Grunwald recently published an investigative report on a related issue: "Overpasses: A love story ... With American transportation in crisis, why are we spending our money on massive new roads? An investigation of one city’s addiction to megahighways." For those further interested, our archive under "traffic" looks at how this issue plays out over time in Miami-Dade.
Well worth your time, to read.
Borrowing a term used in economics, transit supply is inelastic. Although we have maxed out on capacity to absorb automobiles, elected officials continue to permit new developments across the county. The tipping point was breached a long time ago. Traffic congestion not only diminishes quality of life for current residents, it is a real drag on job creation in South Florida.
The answer to traffic congestion, at least in the minds of Miami-Dade county commissioners, has been to dump more cars into commutes from the western suburbs and in the minds of Miami City commissioners, more permits for condos to rise vertically in concrete canyons.
Elected officials should be held accountable, but they are not. Only a few years ago, Gov. Rick Scott and the state legislature eliminated state planning mandates intended to regulated traffic by requiring concurrency, or, a clear picture how transportation infrastructure would accommodate new population growth. That concurrency never worked in Florida is a testament; not to the willingness of elected officials to turn a blind eye so much as the talent of transportation planners and lobbyists to rationalize irrational behavior. At the same time, voters whose lives are turned upside down by traffic believe elected officials are just doing their jobs when they permit traffic-inducing construction and development to overwhelm capacity.
To this list of transit debacles that are crowding out people, you may add your own:
1) Brickell Avenue at any rush hour.
2) Access to Miami Beach via Alton Road.
3) Commuting to and from Bird Road or any of the east/west corridors.
4) US 1 at Ponce and LeJeune Rd. in Coral Gables.
5) Any cultural or sports event in downtown Miami.
Still, in the Bendixen & Amandi poll, 67 percent of respondents glided past traffic while favoring the creation of the largest mall in the United States in northwest Miami-Dade.
At Politico, Miami-based writer Michael Grunwald recently published an investigative report on a related issue: "Overpasses: A love story ... With American transportation in crisis, why are we spending our money on massive new roads? An investigation of one city’s addiction to megahighways." For those further interested, our archive under "traffic" looks at how this issue plays out over time in Miami-Dade.
Well worth your time, to read.
Monday, June 29, 2015
Remember the Epicure! how the story of US 1 and LeJeune Road, Coral Gables illuminates the struggle for Ludlum Trail ... by gimleteye
So here is the thing about the closing of the Coral Gables branch of the Miami Beach fixture, Epicure Market: it was a death foretold. Epicure opened its store in the ground floor of a Jeffrey Berkowitz development in 2013, a stone's throw from the Village of Merrick Park.
I've lived nearby -- roughly defined as the intersection of US 1 and Lejeune Road -- for more than twenty years.
Fifteen years ago, I was civically involved in trying to keep the Rouse company from converting the old Coral Gables bus maintenance depot into a major mall. That mall, the Village of Merrick Park, has never found its footing, through some unbalanced combination of high rental rates and low consumer demand.
On August 24th, 1998 at the Omni Collonade in Coral Gables, the Rouse Company offered a public view of its project. The controversial development pitted then Mayor Raul Valdez Fauli, the Latin Builders Association lobby, and the Rouse Company against many, many Gables citizens who mounted a Coral Gables referendum to block the project. When I got up to the podium, lobbyists booed and hissed. Rouse won the referendum in November and measured by cost per vote it was the most expensive in Florida history.
The Miami Herald printed an OPED I wrote in September 1999. I know, it seems a century ago. "There is no hope for improving traffic because the scale of the development absolutely will worsen traffic in adjacent neighborhoods and U.S. 1 intersections."
The whole of South Gables empties out onto US 1 at LeJeune, so from a purely demographic point of view -- which is what retailers and their consultants look at -- the intersection ought to be a winner.
Except that it is defeated by single driver, traffic-driven density.
This is, naturally, the same observation why the FEC railroad right of way must be converted, in its entirety, to a linear public park: because of existing traffic congestion, there is no place to fit commercial building without destroying economic opportunities already in place.
I kept my notes from the 1998 public meeting. "David Plummer, the project’s traffic consultant, began his presentation by describing a “series of meetings held by the developer” which none of the objectors in the audience had received invitations to. Traffic is the Achilles Heel of the Rouse Mall—whose ramifications were ignored by city commissioners last year when Mayor Valdez Fauli bulldozed approvals through the local permitting process without requiring the developer to disclose the devastating traffic impacts. The August 24th meeting verified points raised by citizens a year ago, although it scarcely matters since necessary approvals were issued before the facts were in. The Rouse Mall will worsen, absolutely, traffic in neighborhoods and the intersections on US Route 1 that are already the worst in the area."
Way back in 2013, an owner of Epicure, Jason Starkman, said he wanted to expand to Coral Gables for a long time. "We always knew the Gables was the place for us for year-round business. And I know people in the neighborhood will enjoy shopping here." They did, except for the traffic and that is the best argument for local public officials to deny commercial building permits for what should become Ludlum Trail.
Remember the Epicure!
I've lived nearby -- roughly defined as the intersection of US 1 and Lejeune Road -- for more than twenty years.
Fifteen years ago, I was civically involved in trying to keep the Rouse company from converting the old Coral Gables bus maintenance depot into a major mall. That mall, the Village of Merrick Park, has never found its footing, through some unbalanced combination of high rental rates and low consumer demand.
On August 24th, 1998 at the Omni Collonade in Coral Gables, the Rouse Company offered a public view of its project. The controversial development pitted then Mayor Raul Valdez Fauli, the Latin Builders Association lobby, and the Rouse Company against many, many Gables citizens who mounted a Coral Gables referendum to block the project. When I got up to the podium, lobbyists booed and hissed. Rouse won the referendum in November and measured by cost per vote it was the most expensive in Florida history.
The Miami Herald printed an OPED I wrote in September 1999. I know, it seems a century ago. "There is no hope for improving traffic because the scale of the development absolutely will worsen traffic in adjacent neighborhoods and U.S. 1 intersections."
The whole of South Gables empties out onto US 1 at LeJeune, so from a purely demographic point of view -- which is what retailers and their consultants look at -- the intersection ought to be a winner.
Except that it is defeated by single driver, traffic-driven density.
This is, naturally, the same observation why the FEC railroad right of way must be converted, in its entirety, to a linear public park: because of existing traffic congestion, there is no place to fit commercial building without destroying economic opportunities already in place.
I kept my notes from the 1998 public meeting. "David Plummer, the project’s traffic consultant, began his presentation by describing a “series of meetings held by the developer” which none of the objectors in the audience had received invitations to. Traffic is the Achilles Heel of the Rouse Mall—whose ramifications were ignored by city commissioners last year when Mayor Valdez Fauli bulldozed approvals through the local permitting process without requiring the developer to disclose the devastating traffic impacts. The August 24th meeting verified points raised by citizens a year ago, although it scarcely matters since necessary approvals were issued before the facts were in. The Rouse Mall will worsen, absolutely, traffic in neighborhoods and the intersections on US Route 1 that are already the worst in the area."
Way back in 2013, an owner of Epicure, Jason Starkman, said he wanted to expand to Coral Gables for a long time. "We always knew the Gables was the place for us for year-round business. And I know people in the neighborhood will enjoy shopping here." They did, except for the traffic and that is the best argument for local public officials to deny commercial building permits for what should become Ludlum Trail.
Remember the Epicure!
Tuesday, June 06, 2017
Move the Urban Development Boundary (AGAIN)? ... by gimleteye
Today is the first Town Hall meeting to consider a massive change to Miami-Dade County: the extension of SR 836 and sprawl beyond the Urban Development Boundary. Once upon a time, Miami Dade county commissioners wisely decided to discourage development that involves moving the UDB. The state of Florida supported its efforts.
Six meetings will be discussing the County Evaluation and Appraisal Report (EAR) 2018. Every seven years, the Comprehensive Development Master Plan (CDMP) is reviewed and updated as required per Chapter 163 of the Florida Statutes, a process known as an Evaluation and Appraisal Report (EAR). The EAR includes an evaluation of the progress the County has made in implementing the goals, objectives, policies, maps and text of the CDMP and also recommends changes.
There is a meeting TODAY in Kendall. For those of you who can attend please ask questions and voice your concerns. If you can't attend please encourage others to do so. If you want to read some history on the UDB, involving old battles fought along the same line, click here.
The Miami Dade Expressway Authority (MDX)-SR 836 extension project plans to extend the Dolphin expressway beyond the Urban Development Boundary (UDB), which serves as a buffer to agricultural lands and adjacent Everglades National Park.
Allowing development outside the UDB will jeopardize in a significant way our water quality. It would reduce wellfield recharge and speed salt water intrusion into the aquifer, leading to increased vulnerability of the region to sea level rise as the location is sitting on the most low lying areas in the County.
Although an extension of the expressway sounds attractive to lessen the congested traffic for people living in the southern and western parts of the County, it has been proven that building more roads does not decrease traffic but the opposite. We need to encourage massive public transit projects if Miami wants to lead in smart growth and sustainability targeting infill areas. Changing our CDMP in the midst of what is the crisis of our lifetime- climate change- is exactly the reason we have CDMP and a UDB line, to protect us from additional sprawl that will not serve this County and our future needs.
Although an extension of the expressway sounds attractive to lessen the congested traffic for people living in the southern and western parts of the County, it has been proven that building more roads does not decrease traffic but the opposite. We need to encourage massive public transit projects if Miami wants to lead in smart growth and sustainability targeting infill areas. Changing our CDMP in the midst of what is the crisis of our lifetime- climate change- is exactly the reason we have CDMP and a UDB line, to protect us from additional sprawl that will not serve this County and our future needs.
Although an extension of the expressway sounds attractive to lessen the congested traffic for people living in the southern and western parts of the County, it has been proven that building more roads does not decrease traffic but the opposite. We need to encourage massive public transit projects if Miami wants to lead in smart growth and sustainability targeting infill areas. Changing our CDMP in the midst of what is the crisis of our lifetime- climate change- is exactly the reason we have CDMP and a UDB line, to protect us from additional sprawl that will not serve this County and our future needs.
Although an extension of the expressway sounds attractive to lessen the congested traffic for people living in the southern and western parts of the County, it has been proven that building more roads does not decrease traffic. More roads inevitably increase traffic!
Changing our CDMP in the midst of what is the crisis of our lifetime- climate change- is exactly the reason we have CDMP and a UDB line, to protect us from additional sprawl that will not serve this County and our future needs.
Get Involved
Help shape the future of Miami-Dade County! Your vision can make an impact on the future of the County. You are invited to attend a workshop, take the EAR2018 Survey or email your comments.
Opportunities for public participation are as follows:
Survey:
Take the EAR2018 survey.
Town Hall Workshops:
Town Hall Workshops will be held in six locations throughout the County to inform the public about the Evaluation and Appraisal Report process and obtain feedback. Below are the dates and locations for the Town Hall Workshops:
Take the EAR2018 survey.
Town Hall Workshops:
Town Hall Workshops will be held in six locations throughout the County to inform the public about the Evaluation and Appraisal Report process and obtain feedback. Below are the dates and locations for the Town Hall Workshops:
- Tuesday, June 6 (6:00 to 8:30 p.m.)
- Kendall Village Center-Civic Pavilion 8625 SW 124 Ave, Miami, FL 33183
- Wednesday, June 7 (6:00 to 8:30 p.m.)
- Ruben Dario Middle School 350 NW 97 Ave, Miami, FL 33172
- Thursday, June 8 (6:00 to 8:30 p.m.)
- African Heritage Cultural Arts Center 6161 NW 22 Ave, Miami, FL 33142
- Saturday, June 10 (10:00 am to noon)
- Norman and Jean Reach Park 7895 NW 176 St, Miami, FL 33015
- Tuesday, June 13 (6:30 to 9:00 p.m.)
- Highland Oaks Park 20300 NE 24 Ave, Miami, FL 33180
- Saturday, June 17 (10:00 am to noon)
- South Dade Regional Library 10750 SW 211 St, Cutler Bay, FL 33189
- QUESTIONS:
- Why are we building in low lying areas?
- Why don't we concentrate our tax dollars within the county we already have.
- Fund public transit!
- What are we really doing about sea level rise?
Saturday, March 22, 2014
The Traffic, Mr. Beckham. The Traffic … by gimleteye
The other day I was listening to a UK radio program on football (soccer version) and the commentators were speculating on why Miami is such a fickle city when it comes to support for professional teams. The context was the David Beckham initiative to put a MLS franchise here.I was tempted to respond as a twenty year Miami resident and sports fan who will not attend a professional sports event in Miami for one reason: traffic.
I was reminded last night, when I made the error of crossing from Miami Beach at 10 PM from the Venetian Causeway to get home in Coral Gables. The reason I took the Venetian is that the traffic on Miami Beach north/south axis is like a war zone.
I'd just spent half an hour looping along a few blocks of Miami Beach to show visitors from out of town, dropped them off near Lincoln Road. Rather than braving the congestion back south along West End, I decided to take the Venetian Causeway.
Big Mistake.
On the other side of the Causeway, the venues at the Performing Arsht Center were letting out. It took another forty minutes to get from west end of the causeway, across the exiting flow of concert go'ers and traffic, back onto 95 South.
The Miami police "guiding" the traffic appeared to have no sense or logic about the traffic flow.

The police aren't to blame for the traffic. The responsibility rests solely on the shoulders of the decision makers who zoned and permitted the mess of Biscayne Boulevard, the condo canyons, and -- hence -- the traffic. Start with the Miami City Commission and the unreformable majority of the Miami Dade County Commission.
Miami hosts some of the best known, most skilled urban planners in the world. Decision makers, the builders and Great Destroyers decided long ago to ignore them. Hubris.
When you create a place as hostile as Miami to getting from here to there, then put people in cars for a significant fraction of their waking hours in a city that is among the least affordable for middle class sports lovers, why would you then expect them to be fans of professional sports teams?
Wednesday, December 04, 2013
Art Basel: The Traffic … by gimleteye
It is inevitable that the take-away from the world's most sophisticated and wealthy visitors will be Miami's traffic. Guaranteed that when the cocktail party chatter veers from art, it will veer toward traffic. It is easier putting toothpaste back in a dispenser than finding an easy way through, during Art Basel.
Last night, a car ride from the Gables to Miami Beach -- one that normally takes half an hour -- took more than an hour at 8PM. I'm tensing for today, when the venues have all opened. Our trip last night to the beach included evasive maneuvers including a scenic detour from the interstate west toward the airport on SR 112 -- the opposite direction from our destination -- then looping back on city streets, over the Venetian Causeway, to Miami Beach. With today's demolition of the Herald -- in addition to Eye On Miami's -- the traffic over the Venetian Causeway will rely on a backup generator for bridge operation.
Visitors, understand this about the developers and boosters who spent vast sums to elect officials who permitted the traffic logjam to build in Miami to gargantuan forms: one of our county commissioners, Lynda Bell, not only voted to permit residences to be surrounded by chain link fences, she also secretly owned a chain link fence company when she proposed the ordinance.
Why does this have to do with the traffic nightmare you will be experiencing? Because self-dealing on infrastructure by elected officials, the revolving door between the regulators and regulated, and campaign contributors -- like those tied to cement, lime rock, roadways and water management -- has denied taxpayers and voters any degree of organization and order except for building more and more and more.
What city builds an art museum that is either a dangerous, uncomfortable walk along and across multi-lane traffic or a half hour ride away from a parking lot on substandard public transportation?
Lately the Miami Herald has been gushing -- (in the purple prose department, editors have all taken a paid week-off …) -- about Museum Park. Trying to drive through the area last night (the Performing Arsht Center was dark) was enlivened by panhandlers.
Visitors, understand that Museum Park is an area with only one lane of access from the interstate and no parking within comfortable walking distance. Period. A view of Biscayne Bay is an incidental luxury from plate glass windows once you have run the gauntlet of traffic, parking and admission fees. So what's the bottom line on this dystopian view?
Because of traffic, Art Basel Miami may turn out to be a bubble that Miami's elite popped all by themselves.
Last night, a car ride from the Gables to Miami Beach -- one that normally takes half an hour -- took more than an hour at 8PM. I'm tensing for today, when the venues have all opened. Our trip last night to the beach included evasive maneuvers including a scenic detour from the interstate west toward the airport on SR 112 -- the opposite direction from our destination -- then looping back on city streets, over the Venetian Causeway, to Miami Beach. With today's demolition of the Herald -- in addition to Eye On Miami's -- the traffic over the Venetian Causeway will rely on a backup generator for bridge operation.
Visitors, understand this about the developers and boosters who spent vast sums to elect officials who permitted the traffic logjam to build in Miami to gargantuan forms: one of our county commissioners, Lynda Bell, not only voted to permit residences to be surrounded by chain link fences, she also secretly owned a chain link fence company when she proposed the ordinance.
Why does this have to do with the traffic nightmare you will be experiencing? Because self-dealing on infrastructure by elected officials, the revolving door between the regulators and regulated, and campaign contributors -- like those tied to cement, lime rock, roadways and water management -- has denied taxpayers and voters any degree of organization and order except for building more and more and more.
What city builds an art museum that is either a dangerous, uncomfortable walk along and across multi-lane traffic or a half hour ride away from a parking lot on substandard public transportation?
Lately the Miami Herald has been gushing -- (in the purple prose department, editors have all taken a paid week-off …) -- about Museum Park. Trying to drive through the area last night (the Performing Arsht Center was dark) was enlivened by panhandlers.
Visitors, understand that Museum Park is an area with only one lane of access from the interstate and no parking within comfortable walking distance. Period. A view of Biscayne Bay is an incidental luxury from plate glass windows once you have run the gauntlet of traffic, parking and admission fees. So what's the bottom line on this dystopian view?
Because of traffic, Art Basel Miami may turn out to be a bubble that Miami's elite popped all by themselves.
Monday, May 05, 2014
On Miami Today's Economic Enemy #1: Traffic … by gimleteye
Michael Lewis, publisher of Miami Today, agrees with the point we have made at EOM since we started this blog: that traffic is the number one enemy of our economy and quality of life. EOM, though, has never shied, unlike Miami Today, from identifying the source of traffic: decision makers and elected officials who never turn down a permit or zoning change that could interfere with the profit motives of the Great Destroyers.
We do, moreover, contest Mr. Lewis' point that traffic has only recently "exploded". During all the years when the building boom acquired momentum -- in the late 1990's straight into the early 2000's -- not a single county commissioner with the exception of Katy Sorenson was willing to hold up a zoning decision allowing more housing or commercial space based on traffic. Miami Today was mostly silent.
Finally, even Commissioner Sorenson was swayed against the requirements of traffic concurrency as a guiding principle of state growth management planning. Well so much for that: Gov. Rick Scott axed growth management as a foundation for planning.
Who bears responsibility for mitigating traffic? If you can find any elected official willing to bear responsibility, let us know. Please raise your hand.
We do agree with Mr. Lewis that "variability" in travel time dominates the traffic scene. You literally have no idea whether a 20 minute drive will become a 30 or 40 minute drive. This is crippling not just for business, but puts significant additional strains on families.
Mr. Lewis and I share the same amazement -- as I am sure many of our readers do -- at the sheer impossibility of navigating across Biscayne Boulevard from ANY direction when the Performing Arsht Center and the Heat Arena are in action. And the Museum of Jorge Perez? Who can get there? (And when did the Miami Herald ever editorialize about this facet of our torpedo'd civic life?)
Lewis writes, "we need to get priorities, and get them straight". But hasn't Miami Today been part of the media aristocracy that incessantly highlights the good work of job boosters like the Greater Miami Chamber of Commerce, or Neisen Kasdin/ Latin Builders, and the relentless optimism of pro-growth policies?
Perhaps Mr. Lewis anticipates our criticism by noting, "in the past eight years, Miami Today has written about "gridlock" 58 times. We've written about "traffic congestion" even more."
That very well could be the case. However, there comes a time when staying inside the circle of Miami's status quo is no longer a viable option for a critic. In our opinion, we crossed that threshold a long, long, long time ago.
We do, moreover, contest Mr. Lewis' point that traffic has only recently "exploded". During all the years when the building boom acquired momentum -- in the late 1990's straight into the early 2000's -- not a single county commissioner with the exception of Katy Sorenson was willing to hold up a zoning decision allowing more housing or commercial space based on traffic. Miami Today was mostly silent.
Finally, even Commissioner Sorenson was swayed against the requirements of traffic concurrency as a guiding principle of state growth management planning. Well so much for that: Gov. Rick Scott axed growth management as a foundation for planning.
Who bears responsibility for mitigating traffic? If you can find any elected official willing to bear responsibility, let us know. Please raise your hand.
We do agree with Mr. Lewis that "variability" in travel time dominates the traffic scene. You literally have no idea whether a 20 minute drive will become a 30 or 40 minute drive. This is crippling not just for business, but puts significant additional strains on families.
Mr. Lewis and I share the same amazement -- as I am sure many of our readers do -- at the sheer impossibility of navigating across Biscayne Boulevard from ANY direction when the Performing Arsht Center and the Heat Arena are in action. And the Museum of Jorge Perez? Who can get there? (And when did the Miami Herald ever editorialize about this facet of our torpedo'd civic life?)
Lewis writes, "we need to get priorities, and get them straight". But hasn't Miami Today been part of the media aristocracy that incessantly highlights the good work of job boosters like the Greater Miami Chamber of Commerce, or Neisen Kasdin/ Latin Builders, and the relentless optimism of pro-growth policies?
Perhaps Mr. Lewis anticipates our criticism by noting, "in the past eight years, Miami Today has written about "gridlock" 58 times. We've written about "traffic congestion" even more."
That very well could be the case. However, there comes a time when staying inside the circle of Miami's status quo is no longer a viable option for a critic. In our opinion, we crossed that threshold a long, long, long time ago.
Thursday, November 10, 2011
Art Basel Miami Red Traffic Alert ... by gimleteye
Art Basel Miami. 2,000 artists, 33 countries, 250 galleries. 40,000 attendees, including wealthy art buyers whose influence substantially contributes to Miami's cachet. $500 million in revenue; a provable statistic that dwarfs the Superbowl.
And this year, a traffic nightmare indescribable for its effects on visitors to the Art Fair, scattered in locations from Wynwood, to Mid-Town, to downtown and Miami Beach.
We went out last night to check the ride. US 1 northbound from Coral Gables to US 95 was a disaster. A few years ago, highway construction crews erected a sound barrier on US 1 from below SW 17th St. to SW 22nd, I marveled at the use of shrubs between the pillars holding concrete barrier slabs. No way anything would grow there, and indeed not much did. It looks like crap. The way Miami, Miami-Dade County and FDOT is solving the problem is to remove the shrubs (who knows how much that cost and who benefited) and put poured concrete barriers up against the Romaneque Wall (who knows how much that cost and who benefited).
In any case, last night it took 30 minutes to traverse northbound, from Bird Road to US 95 at 6:30PM. (And there were NO WORKERS when we finally passed the obstruction narrowing three lanes to two! Just traffic cones, LOL!) Well, so much for Gables and Pinecrest getting to Art Basel. Call it "Britto's Revenge".
But let's say you want to take 395 eastbound to Miami Beach. Last night, the traffic jam caused by the Miami TUNNEL BORE HOLE project was mind-boggling, with east-bound traffic jammed nearly to the intersection with 95. Hello? What's the alternative route? The Venetian Causeway. The Biscayne Boulevard exit was no better. It took 20 minutes to get off the ramp onto the Boulevard. And then the Venetian Causeway: OMG! Who knew that big water and paving projects are going on at the same time on the Venetian Islands! Traffic to the causeway toll, mushed off 95 for a faster way to the Beach, was backed up to the Herald intersection near Biscayne Boulevard.
On 195, the eastbound North Miami exit is still closed. We wrote about the nightmare of traffic funneling entirely onto Biscayne Boulevard, the only exit serving Mid-Town and Wynwood, a week ago. There is no polite way to put this: the impending shit storm for Miami is gargantuan. The traffic nightmare WILL BE the Art Basel Miami story. "Art Basel Miami: all dressed up with nowhere to go". Call it the Greater Miami Chamber of Traffic Horrors.
One solution: for all those well-heeled, 1 percent'er spenders from Europe and the Americas, as they are given cards for passport control at MIA or Opalacka, hand out the following: "We are sorry for the inconvenience our roadway improvements are causing this year. To help cushion the discomfort of $200 taxi cab rides from one venue to the next, we offer you an admission coupon to Parrot Jungle that you may use within one year, provided you include your airline ticket receipt as proof of purchase. Enjoy Miami-Dade County and come back soon!"
And this year, a traffic nightmare indescribable for its effects on visitors to the Art Fair, scattered in locations from Wynwood, to Mid-Town, to downtown and Miami Beach.
We went out last night to check the ride. US 1 northbound from Coral Gables to US 95 was a disaster. A few years ago, highway construction crews erected a sound barrier on US 1 from below SW 17th St. to SW 22nd, I marveled at the use of shrubs between the pillars holding concrete barrier slabs. No way anything would grow there, and indeed not much did. It looks like crap. The way Miami, Miami-Dade County and FDOT is solving the problem is to remove the shrubs (who knows how much that cost and who benefited) and put poured concrete barriers up against the Romaneque Wall (who knows how much that cost and who benefited).
In any case, last night it took 30 minutes to traverse northbound, from Bird Road to US 95 at 6:30PM. (And there were NO WORKERS when we finally passed the obstruction narrowing three lanes to two! Just traffic cones, LOL!) Well, so much for Gables and Pinecrest getting to Art Basel. Call it "Britto's Revenge".
But let's say you want to take 395 eastbound to Miami Beach. Last night, the traffic jam caused by the Miami TUNNEL BORE HOLE project was mind-boggling, with east-bound traffic jammed nearly to the intersection with 95. Hello? What's the alternative route? The Venetian Causeway. The Biscayne Boulevard exit was no better. It took 20 minutes to get off the ramp onto the Boulevard. And then the Venetian Causeway: OMG! Who knew that big water and paving projects are going on at the same time on the Venetian Islands! Traffic to the causeway toll, mushed off 95 for a faster way to the Beach, was backed up to the Herald intersection near Biscayne Boulevard.
On 195, the eastbound North Miami exit is still closed. We wrote about the nightmare of traffic funneling entirely onto Biscayne Boulevard, the only exit serving Mid-Town and Wynwood, a week ago. There is no polite way to put this: the impending shit storm for Miami is gargantuan. The traffic nightmare WILL BE the Art Basel Miami story. "Art Basel Miami: all dressed up with nowhere to go". Call it the Greater Miami Chamber of Traffic Horrors.
One solution: for all those well-heeled, 1 percent'er spenders from Europe and the Americas, as they are given cards for passport control at MIA or Opalacka, hand out the following: "We are sorry for the inconvenience our roadway improvements are causing this year. To help cushion the discomfort of $200 taxi cab rides from one venue to the next, we offer you an admission coupon to Parrot Jungle that you may use within one year, provided you include your airline ticket receipt as proof of purchase. Enjoy Miami-Dade County and come back soon!"
Monday, February 18, 2008
Guest Blog: A Storm is Brewing in Palmetto Bay by Miamigal. (Do we care?) Geniusofdespair
I am printing this because I am curious about readers reactions. To me, this is a nimby issue, I say that by my lack of interest. The writer begs to differ. She calls it: "A community gone wild." NOPE-- I STAND CORRECTED SHE SAID: "This is NOT about a community gone wild. This is a community that is fighting to preserve the integrity of a residential area." Your view? Am I narrow minded, (I guess so, I couldn't even quote it right)? Tell me why I should care. Warning: If you tell me in more than 4 sentences that is too long - I won't read it. Following is her unedited guest blog:It’s All About Quality of Life…
Our Quality of Life is definitely related to our life circumstances and expectations. It is a tangible notion that reflects the situation in which one lives; including those things that come along to threaten your perception of well-being. The funny thing about Quality of Life, one man’s feast may certainly be another man’s famine. Just when you think it is safe to assume you are living just fine, along comes the zoning notices, land-use attorneys and of course, the stress.
Deep in the happy little village of Palmetto Bay a storm is brewing:
The zoning notices are out. That tiny white post card is sending neighbors scurrying to defeat the seemingly innocuous request to expand a church sponsored private school. Those horrible selfish neighbors…those NIMBY maniacs! Equally as frantic are the hundreds of outsiders from the school bent on imposing their glorious plans on the unfriendly neighbors. All the elements of a great television pilot are right there; rich folks, angry folks, greed, passion, deception, carpet baggers, lobbyists, politicians in an election year and the usual array of shenanigans such as yard signs being stolen and phone calls being made.
If Palmer Trinity Private School manages to win the zoning hearing on February 25, 2008, this will be the future: The school will go from a reported 600 students and 58 teachers to an astonishing size of 1400 students and 240 staff members. It will add 33 acres of buildings, playing fields, and what every residential neighborhood needs, a football stadium. Forget about the impact on the lucky homeowners located on four sides of the project. Forget about the 15 years of construction dust in the houses. Forget about the noise pollution and sleeping-in as the school comes alive with 1700 people. Forget about all of this and look at the big picture.
This is not about a community gone wild. This is a community that is fighting to preserve the integrity of a residential area. This is a community that is seeking to prevent grid-lock that will impact South Dade traffic for years to come. It will impact traffic from Coral Gables south all the way to Naranja near the Homestead Air Reserve Base. Whatever Gulliver School has not managed to entirely do to Old Cutler Road during the morning and evening traffic rush, Palmer Trinity will finish.
As many of you know, this county is very limited in north-south traffic routes. The roads just are not there. Other than US1, Old Cutler Road is the only north-south artery that goes from deep South Dade through Cutler Bay, Palmetto Bay, Pinecrest, South Miami and further into the Grove. It is grid- locked in early morning and late evening. Over the years, as build-out occurred in the potato fields of South Dade, the line of cars idling in traffic has crept further and further south. Now, you drive north at 10 miles per hour from as far south as Eureka Drive all the way into the urban areas. More importantly, this current state of affairs on Old Cutler Road and Eureka Drive doesn’t include future traffic from The Palmetto Bay Village Center (Old Burger King Headquarters), which is 88 acres of business zoning on growth hormones. Nor does it include the Palmetto Bay library under construction next to it, or the Palmer Trinity proposal.
Palmer Trinity is a very wealthy school (tuition and fees start at over $21,000 a year). The unfortunate reality is that the new students will come from areas north of Palmetto Bay. The additional 900 cars (no rattle-trap yellow school buses here) will be coming and going back to Coral Gables, Pinecrest, and the very northern edge of Palmetto Bay. The only direct route to the school is by driving down Old Cutler or down though the heart of Palmetto Bay and doubling back to Old Cutler Road.
Traffic counts along the Old Cutler corridor have gone from C’s to F’s over the years. A “C” grade being "a bit congested" and “F” meaning "standing gridlock". What will 3000+ new car trips a day (plus the service and construction vehicles) do to South Dade’s traffic pattern? It forces Eureka Drive to be widened to four lanes encroaching on the residential area. It will back-up the east-west arteries that empty onto Old Cutler Road and cause those intersections to be redesigned. Residential areas will be denied easy egress onto the crowded roadway. The accident rate will go up as drivers take insane chances at making left and right hand turns on both Old Cutler Road and Eureka Drive. South Dade County will see no relief by widening Old Cutler Road. It is a state designated Historic Highway and cannot be widened.
To quote Norman Mineta, former U.S. Secretary of Transportation:
“Congestion is one of the single largest threats to our economic prosperity. Each year, Americans lose 3.7 billion hours and 2.3 billion gallons of fuel sitting in traffic jams. Worse, congestion is affecting the quality of American’s lives by robbing them of the time that could be spent with families and friends. Congestion is not a fact of life. It is not a scientific mystery, nor is it an uncontrollable force. Congestion results from poor policy choices and a failure to separate solutions that are effective from those that are not."
Secretary Mineta’s quote illustrates Miami-Dade County’s situation. Every community must find strength and resources from its own people to improve livability and quality of life.
Conversely, the Palmer Trinity Board of Directors, in their mad rush to grow and enhance their standing in the private school sector, will deny their part time next door neighbors the right to have a tranquil, livable community without the added burden of grid-lock. Their self-indulgence will let them star in the development handbook for private schools everywhere. They will wrap their mission in the goodness of their non-profit status; they will irresponsibly change the urban landscape and then go home to their neighborhoods leaving behind the traffic congestion and changed lives. I never thought I would see the day that I would prefer 66 houses on 33 acres to a school. But, times have changed. Traffic has changed. We can’t continue to pave our way out of congestion caused by bad planning.
Urban sprawl is bad. Urban congestion is equally as bad. Good urban planning comes with solutions. Despite the prevailing assumption in Miami-Dade County, owning a piece of land doesn’t mean one is entitled to a greater zoning use than what sits on it. Urban planning does not necessarily mean widening every roadway to accommodate every property owner’s desire to up-zone the value of his or her land. Good urban design may require saying NO. It means government leaders need to step up to the plate and make their review of proposed projects truly cognizant of a community’s health, safety and general welfare.
Palmer Trinity’s project is a test for the Palmetto Bay Village Council. The proposed project is a test of their abilities and skills as urban planners. The hearing is not just about a Palmetto Bay neighborhood. This hearing is also about the people in Cutler Bay living across the street from the proposed project (who have had no formal notice from Palmetto Bay since they don’t live there). At a minimum, it is about the deciding future for South Dade citizens far beyond the Council’s legislative boundaries. However, in the very end, the hearing is about you, me and our Quality of Life as we sit fuming in traffic wondering what went wrong with county and local governmental planning oversight. For our sake, I sure hope the Village Council doesn’t flunk their final exam.
The hearing is February 25, 2008, at 6:30 pm, on the Southwood Middle School Campus, 16301 south west 80th Avenue, Palmetto Bay, Florida. More information
Wednesday, May 04, 2016
Bizarro Politics in Palmetto Bay. By Geniusofdespair
Not to be outdone by Hudstead, Palmetto Bay vies for first place:
Now you have to remember this issue was a quasi-Judicial item on the Agenda May 2nd.
Somehow the Vice Mayor of Palmetto Bay, who lives near the project, wrote to residents before the vote and even quotes himself in his release, never saw that before.
Regarding the project in question, I toured the swapped property on Old Cuttler Road and saw Dade County Pines for the first time. I did think they didn't exist anymore. I was pleased with the swap because of the quality of the developer owned lands being swapped. I do not know about zoning changes made by the council in 2008 or the circumstances of how the developer got the property. I am just commenting on the property I toured. However, I would rather see the development back further from the road anyway.
The item passed except for Vice Mayor John Dubois, who did a reversal on recusing himself (He lives very close to this property) and Councilwoman Karen Cunningham, Dubois' best bud on the Council. She is also eyeing the Mayor seat of Mayor Eugene Flinn. Speaking of friends, Dubois temporarily housed an accused sex offender of young girls in his home for his friend.
Here is the Dubois email to residents, sent out looking like a press release, before the quasi-Judicial vote:
If I had it my way, I would draft Erica Watts, an incredible woman (sitting next to Al Sunshine) to be the next Vice Mayor of Palmetto Bay. Erica You Must Run!
BTW wetlands are not really as protected by Government regulation as Dubois said. If they were, we wouldn't have half the development in Florida that we have. The Developer is able to do mitigation somewhere else (there are very lucrative mitigation banks) for destroying wetlands and bingo, he or she has their development.
Mayor Flinn said of his vote:
Mayor Eugene Flinn responds.
Now you have to remember this issue was a quasi-Judicial item on the Agenda May 2nd.
Somehow the Vice Mayor of Palmetto Bay, who lives near the project, wrote to residents before the vote and even quotes himself in his release, never saw that before.
| Dade County Pine |
Regarding the project in question, I toured the swapped property on Old Cuttler Road and saw Dade County Pines for the first time. I did think they didn't exist anymore. I was pleased with the swap because of the quality of the developer owned lands being swapped. I do not know about zoning changes made by the council in 2008 or the circumstances of how the developer got the property. I am just commenting on the property I toured. However, I would rather see the development back further from the road anyway.
The item passed except for Vice Mayor John Dubois, who did a reversal on recusing himself (He lives very close to this property) and Councilwoman Karen Cunningham, Dubois' best bud on the Council. She is also eyeing the Mayor seat of Mayor Eugene Flinn. Speaking of friends, Dubois temporarily housed an accused sex offender of young girls in his home for his friend.
Here is the Dubois email to residents, sent out looking like a press release, before the quasi-Judicial vote:
For Immediate Release - May 1st, 2016
PALMETTO BAY MAYOR CONTINUES TO SUPPORT A MASSIVE DEVELOPMENT PROJECT THAT COULD TURN OLD CUTLER ROAD INTO A PARKING LOT
(Palmetto Bay, FL) - The Village of Palmetto Bay, long renowned as a quiet, picturesque, and environmentally responsible bedroom community is on the brink of becoming just another over-developed, traffic congested municipality in Miami-Dade County - if the Village's Mayor, Eugene Flinn, and his developer friend get their way.
While serving as Mayor during his inaugural term in February of 2005, Eugene Flinn and his developer friend began increasing the residential development density of the old Burger King Corporate property, now known as the "Palmetto Bay Village Center" on Old Cutler Road, despite strong development opposition by the community for decades. On June 9th, 2008, Flinn voted to "Up-Zone" the property from exclusive use for office space to allow an additional 100 townhomes and 300 bedrooms/units for elderly housing. At the time, the developer stated - "this [elderly housing] type of facility would lessen traffic flow."
Palmetto Bay Vice Mayor John DuBois, who lives a few properties to the North, believes that if the proposed ordinances recently presented to the Village Council and supported by Mayor Flinn are approved, there will be a major traffic crisis in Palmetto Bay. The traffic generated by 100 homes Flinn initially approved in 2008 along with traffic from the additional 385 homes he is trying to approve now could increase car traffic by a factor of 5 on a road that already resembles a parking lot during morning and evening rush hours. This act would destroy the quality of life for residents of Palmetto Bay and Cutler Bay.
To justify this 5-fold increase in residential traffic flow, Mayor Flinn and his developer friend are now claiming that "it is a good deal for the Village because Palmetto Bay is getting 40 acres of new park land." This is an expertly crafted deception that has even pulled the wool over the eyes of the environmental community. The reality is that these 40 acres include environmentally sensitive lands that cannot be developed for residential purposes. These 40 acres are divided into 2 sections - first is a 22-acre section which already has a land use designation of "Parks and Recreation" the second are 18-acres of mangroves and wetlands that are environmentally protected by government regulation.
"The Mayor's actions could result in a traffic disaster to already gridlocked roads used by residents of Palmetto Bay and Cutler Bay that would only benefit Flinn's developer friend." - Said Vice Mayor John Dubois. - Added DuboisDisclosure: This news release is purely the opinion of John DuBois
If I had it my way, I would draft Erica Watts, an incredible woman (sitting next to Al Sunshine) to be the next Vice Mayor of Palmetto Bay. Erica You Must Run!
BTW wetlands are not really as protected by Government regulation as Dubois said. If they were, we wouldn't have half the development in Florida that we have. The Developer is able to do mitigation somewhere else (there are very lucrative mitigation banks) for destroying wetlands and bingo, he or she has their development.
Mayor Flinn said of his vote:
I received no donations from Scott Silver the owner of the Palmetto Bay Village Center. He is an acquaintance, not a friend.
My vote was based upon the law as presented by our village attorney, the facts, the traffic study which showed no impact from the existing plan, as well as the fact that I was able to preserve 40 acres of land. I am looking forward to preserving and beginning a similar effort to what is going on on the Cutler Bay side with their restoration along Old Cutler Road.
Mayor Eugene Flinn responds.
Monday, May 02, 2011
Should We Widen SW 157th Avenue? Guest Blog by Ted Wilde
Below is my recent citizen’s comment to the Citizen's Independent Transportation Trust. On April 25, the CITT approved its 5-year plan, including the SW 157th Ave. widening, with two dissenting votes. Implementation of the SW 157th Ave. project will require two votes on specific contracts later this year, after the mandated further traffic study. One contract will be for moving the power lines and other utilities; the second will be the contract for the actual construction. This project Is not only a further waste of $11 million, it can readily be used in the near future to support moving the UDB with the argument: “the infrastructure is already in place." (Genius: Lennar/Ed Easton's Parkland Development of Regional Impact is in this area as well as other mega developments like Horton Homes).
An expensive, unnecessary planned project: widening from two to four lanes with raised median the road segment of SW 157th Ave. from SW 152nd St. to SW 184th St.;
Summary. This lane-doubling project at this time is an ill-advised use of a further $11 million of CITT funds. Benefits claimed for this project, like the provision of north-south connectivity, are already available now, with no investment at all. Traffic moves without congestion the whole day, including during morning and afternoon rush hours, as can be verified by site visits. This project is in the 5-year plan presented for CITT approval today. The CITT should amend the plan to remove this project.
The Public Works Department [PWD] plans to conclude contracts this year for utility relocation and for construction. The CITT memo accompanying the 5-year plan recommends for this project, “that traffic studies be updated prior to immediate commencement of construction.” This is not a promising step. It sounds like the decision is already made and the traffic study is window dressing for starting as soon as possible. In reality, the 2006 traffic study specifically indicated comfortable traffic levels far below capacity, but that did not deter Public Works, the County Administration, and Commissioner Moss from advocating this expensive road expansion. None of the official presentations of this project to the CITT communicated that the whole west side of this road segment is agricultural land outside the Urban Development Boundary [UDB]. This bordering on the UDB makes this segment different from the already improved segments of SW 157th Ave. to the north, which pass through populated areas on both sides of the road. By omitting this information on the UDB, the presentations withhold information needed for an intelligent decision by the CITT.
An expensive, unnecessary planned project: widening from two to four lanes with raised median the road segment of SW 157th Ave. from SW 152nd St. to SW 184th St.;
Summary. This lane-doubling project at this time is an ill-advised use of a further $11 million of CITT funds. Benefits claimed for this project, like the provision of north-south connectivity, are already available now, with no investment at all. Traffic moves without congestion the whole day, including during morning and afternoon rush hours, as can be verified by site visits. This project is in the 5-year plan presented for CITT approval today. The CITT should amend the plan to remove this project.
The Public Works Department [PWD] plans to conclude contracts this year for utility relocation and for construction. The CITT memo accompanying the 5-year plan recommends for this project, “that traffic studies be updated prior to immediate commencement of construction.” This is not a promising step. It sounds like the decision is already made and the traffic study is window dressing for starting as soon as possible. In reality, the 2006 traffic study specifically indicated comfortable traffic levels far below capacity, but that did not deter Public Works, the County Administration, and Commissioner Moss from advocating this expensive road expansion. None of the official presentations of this project to the CITT communicated that the whole west side of this road segment is agricultural land outside the Urban Development Boundary [UDB]. This bordering on the UDB makes this segment different from the already improved segments of SW 157th Ave. to the north, which pass through populated areas on both sides of the road. By omitting this information on the UDB, the presentations withhold information needed for an intelligent decision by the CITT.
Sunday, October 20, 2013
Merrick Park: Gables name change shows Idiocracy at work ... by gimleteye
Back when I cared, I made fun of the name "Village of Merrick Park" to describe the upscale mall across US 1 from my neighborhood. It was 1999 and an OPED I wrote (when I still had a relationship with the Miami Herald) included the following:
Traffic is the Achilles' heel of the Rouse mall, but city commissioners last year ignored the ramifications as the developer and Mayor Valdes-Fauli proceeded with approvals. Now points raised by opponents are acknowledged to be true: There is no hope for improving traffic because the scale of the development absolutely will worsen traffic in adjacent neighborhoods and U.S. 1 intersections.Oh well ... The applicants at the time for the proposed mall were "sensitive" to community complaints about a mall disturbing traffic patterns in their midst. Along with their marketing mavens and other sand-in-your-shoes types, they included "Village" to help connote sensitivity of design and planning. As in, "we are only a village."
Le Jeune Road, Ponce de Leon and Bird Road intersections already have level-of-service ratings of F. This is the designation awarded by the Florida Department of Transportation for roadways that are, essentially, hopeless. Common sense would dictate that state law should provide for no additional development approvals that would increase traffic. But that is not the case.
Since that time, the shopping center has struggled to find its footing among clients who prefer not to brave the worst traffic access anywhere along US 1. And that is saying a lot! It was all predictable, and at the time I cared enough to take a stopwatch and walk to the corner with LeJeune and measure precisely how few cars make it across the intersection at rush hour. Now I am waiting for FPL to lay high tension distribution lines across my forehead. Just kidding.
Since that time, millions of cars have flowed through the worst traffic intersection in Miami-Dade and the mall, predictably, has struggled. Eye On Miami has followed its progress, if that word can be applied.
Now the mall owners think a more direct approach is needed with consumers. Uh-huh.
The Herald reports, "Coral Gables commissioners touted the city’s recognition in an international United Nations-sanctioned contest that looks for the most livable cities in the world. But first the five-member group agreed that the Village of Merrick Park, the city’s large, open-air mall, could better brand itself with a new name. “Village,” the mall’s general manager Chris Molho said, can lead to confusion among non-locals. “Is it a town?” The new name will be Shops at Merrick Park. “With this name change, it will help us capture those who might not be familiar with Merrick Park. I know Bal Harbour Shops is a shopping center, or Dadeland Mall.” The mall’s studies revealed that only 38 percent of respondents could similarly identify that the Village of Merrick Park contained a shopping component. “Those coming from out of town, South America, Brazil, when they see ‘Shops’ they will know who we are. We don’t want to lose the equity of ‘Merrick Park,’” Molho said.
Whatever. I'll do my shopping at Amazon and imagine I'm floating through a jungle where there are no idiots swinging through the trees. Only monkeys.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)








