Showing posts sorted by date for query dca. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query dca. Sort by relevance Show all posts

Wednesday, September 26, 2018

What is wrong with the massive highway extension is our political status quo ... by gimleteye

Never mind what Mayor Carlos Gimenez promised. As the Herald reports, there is no precise place for the location of the massive SR 836 extension into the wetlands, last remaining farmland, and open space of Miami-Dade. Yet, tomorrow the Miami-Dade county commission may give this black hole its blessing to move forward.

How did it happen that the county commission is set to a final vote, tomorrow, on a plan for a roadway whose precise location no one has seen?

Before answering, rest assured that MDX and its spokespersons and advocates have covered their bases well; they've done the bare minimum (with costly powerpoint studies and robo calls to Kendall residents) to plausibly claim the time for voting is now.

But, as any citizen who pays attention to civic affairs, the devil is always in the detail and when the detail goes AWOL, you don't have to stray far from the story-line of our political status quo.

Here is the rub: once upon a time, before the governorship of Rick Scott, there was a state planning agency whose legitimate and important purpose was to reconcile economic growth with laws to protect the environment. The big builders, big agriculture, Florida's utilities all despised the Florida Department of Community Affairs. They claimed it represented "burdensome regulation", a "drag on growth and jobs". DCA, over time, rotted from within; dominated by special interests.

For many years, both political parties took pot shots at the Department, staffed by top ranked planners who did their level best to protect the agency's mandate.

Gov. Rick Scott and the Republicans, though, finished the job started by earlier leadership including Lawton Chiles in the 1980's: he killed the one state agency whose mission was to dive into the details where the devil lives.

So there is no state agency, today, with the budget, staff and power to counter Miami-Dade's transportation plan, including the extension of SR 836 into the last developable private property in the county. There is nothing new in politics following cash, but the vote on the extension of SR 836 shows what happens, exactly, when there is no countervailing force of common sense and expertise.

The death of DCA (it exists as a shell of its former self, advisory and in name only) allowed Florida's counties free reign so long as they generally adhered to growth plans approved by the state. To informed civic observers, this did not bode well and it hasn't. Jockeying by the lobbyist class delivered the shipwreck that DCA meant to protect taxpayers from.

The political status quo in Miami-Dade pats itself on the back for digging a very deep hole for taxpayers in respect to transit deficits. Many of the incumbent county commissioners are part of the Unreformable Majority that Eye On Miami has ranted about, for more than a decade.

Unless the county commission votes, tomorrow, to defer pending further study and evaluation, it will have just dug that hole a lot deeper for every resident and visitor; everyone except rock miners, property owners, and land speculators at the proposed new highway's exit and entrance ramps.

Saturday, May 12, 2018

America Dream Mall: A Totally Predictable Nightmare ... by gimleteye


Next week the Miami-Dade County Commission will vote on the America Dream Mall; one of the largest, if not the largest, malls in the United States, to be built in the northwest corner of Miami-Dade County. From the point of view of traffic and infrastructure burdens on taxpayers, it is a predictable nightmare.

Before Gov. Rick Scott, citizens had a place -- state administrative court -- and a roadmap, through the Florida Department of Community Affairs, to challenge development schemes that were manifestly against the public interest. A good example, from the 1990's, Wayne's World: the dream child of the late Wayne Huizinga. Blockbuster Park, its formal name, was planned just across the county line in Broward -- not far from the America Dream Mall site. It speaks worlds that an ill-conceived regional development could be halted in the mid 1990s but not in 2017. Some call that progress.

Gov. Scott delivered the coup de grace to the DCA, consigning the agency and its mission to a Tallahassee broom closet. At the same time, developers gained the upper hand by imposing massive costs on citizens with the temerity to challenge local zoning decisions. And, the USSC Citizens United decision opened the door to unlimited campaign contributions by corporations and provided further energy to the dark money pools that are making a mockery of democracy.

In other words, a lot of stuff had to be broken for a plan like the America Dream Mall to make it through. Behind it, in the pipeline, more predictable nightmares: the extension of SR 836 into the last remaining farmland and open space in Miami Dade, the construction of another Walmart in the county's last remaining pine rocklands, and further attempts to move the Urban Development Boundary.

The Florida Department of Community of Affairs, through its development of regional impact programming, was never completely aligned with the public interest in sound development and growth. It was born, however, out of a bipartisan consensus in the state legislature in the 1980's; a time when an older generation of electeds agreed that a system of checks and balances was needed to stop the profit motive from wrecking what Floridians held of value and in trust for future generations.

The development supply chain, industry trade associations like the Florida Chamber of Commerce and Associated Industries, and Big Agriculture fought DCA from the start. Gov. Jeb Bush, through establishment figures like Al Hoffman and the Council of 100, used DCA for target practice. For citizens, and the few civic organizations that plunged into the turbid waters of the state's overdevelopment, challenging developments of regional impacts offered a ray of hope.

Gov. Rick Scott squashed that hope; a fact voters might want to remember this November as if the land clearing, bulldozers, and site development of America Dream Mall will not be enough.

Wednesday, April 18, 2018

Florida's Environmental Failure: could voters put a state agency into "receivership"? ... by gimleteye

Today, claims of "FAKE NEWS" envelop us, but here is one undeniable truth in Florida: our waters -- which belong to the people -- are dissolving in a toxic soup of pollution. This, despite decades of environmental rules and regulations and billions invested.

Florida's Everglades, held in the public trust for future generations, is on life support after huge taxpayer investments and billions more promised to come. And people are suffering. Highly toxic algae blooms coated both Florida coasts in 2016 and persist in ecological treasures like Florida Bay; more billions lost in a state economy that depends on tourism. Some of that algae can trigger incurable brain disease.

Everything we have tried, in terms of protecting Florida's water quality, is on the order of half-measures or worse. Take North Florida's springs: once as clear as plain air and now clogged and coated with algae. Or Apalachicola Bay, where the historic shellfish industry has disappeared.

Elected officials and decision-makers tell us: there are no silver bullets. It is always someone else's fault. Georgia. Municipal waste. The shrugging platitudes are excuses. The solutions are always the same: bury the pollution in deep wells. Shift it somewhere else.

The regulatory structure within which the public frames its hopes for clean water and a safe environment for people, for the economy, and for habitats is bankrupt, overwhelmed by external costs and internal conflicts.

This set of interlocking phenomena did not happen all at once, although there are manifest examples of contributing factors like Gov. Rick Scott's decision to eliminate the powers of the Florida Department of Community Affairs -- the single state agency with a mission to balance the needs of economic development with the environment. To conservationists, DCA was never a panacea. The agency and its mission grew out of a bi-partisan consensus in the early 1980's that the state needed to take a strong role in balancing economic development with environmental protection.

DCA was hacked to death, piece by piece, by politics steered by unregulated campaign contributions and dark money pools from industry associations, Big Agriculture, and the development supply chain that minted billions from construction at the shoreline and through the conversion of low-cost farmland and wetlands into suburban sprawl.

With DCA, though, at least civic activists had a platform; a legal framework to challenge political decisions. They could petition in state court when they believed local government permitting violated the intent and spirit of state growth management laws.

Now, there is no platform and growth management is a hollow shell.

The hollowing out of government agency and missions is a successful tactic of the anti-government AltR. Its apotheosis at the federal level is President Trump, blithely ignorant of facts and dismissive of science. Trump and his agents like EPA chief Scott Pruitt are torching federal authority to protect the nation's air and water. For instance, Trump has said that he can't wait to dismantle the Clean Water Act.

The states can do a better job, he says, without apparently understanding that Florida can't. Hasn't. Won't. In Florida, the life rafts are designed to sink.

A lawsuit filed yesterday against the State of Florida by a group of children, alleging that the state has failed its responsibilities under the public trust doctrine and constitution to proactively address climate change and its impacts points in the same direction. In that case, Delaney et al. v. Florida, we know that the solution is based in sound science; we must stop and reverse the combustion of global-warming emissions as soon as possible.

Isn't that the same case in Everglades restoration, and isn't the injury by state government in the case of climate change denial the same as the denial of science embedded in the state legislation that emerged, after two years of controversy, to place a huge man-made reservoir south of sugar plantations and Lake Okeechobee? Carl Hiaasen described it this way in a recent OPED:
At 10,500 acres, the reservoir will be relatively small and so deep (23 feet) that some scientists don’t think it can do the job. The design was chosen over better options by the board of the South Florida Water Management District, which under Gov. Rick Scott functions as a policy arm of Big Sugar.
As one example, TCPalm reporters exposed how the water district in 2015 allowed a U.S. Sugar lobbyist named Irene Quincey to “edit” and weaken planned regulations on harmful phosphorous pouring out of Lake O.

Among her contributions to the final draft was deleting the word “enforceable” from three key passages.

So it’s no shock that the water district bowed to the corporate cane growers this year, too. The original reservoir proposal by Sen. Joe Negron, a Stuart Republican whose tourism-dependent district gets slimed hard by the green algae blooms, called for a 60,000-acre project.

That would have been big and shallow enough to deal with much of the fouled lake discharges. However, sugar producers didn’t want a larger reservoir because they opposed taking any cane acreage out of production, even if the state paid them for it.
Just like a corporation, a state agency should be held to be bankrupt when it fails to uphold its mission to protect individual liberties and rights. In the case of the Everglades reservoir, the Florida Department of Environmental Protection claims it is following law and the balance of taxpayer interest and property rights, but it has manifestly ignored the parts of the law that inconveniently conflict with the aims of the state's powerful campaign contributors: Big Sugar. FDEP does the bare minimum. But the bare minimum has the further effect of allowing mission creep and the goal posts to shift further and further away from protecting people and the environment. Surely, the Florida constitution is being violated.

When a corporation goes bankrupt, its business is put into receivership. Why shouldn't receivership apply to state agencies like FDEP, as well? Who would "receive" a failed state agency? It could be a special master of the court, supervising the work and recommendations of a science panel comprised of experts who are independent of Florida's regulated communities. They wouldn't be able to legislate of course, but if the state legislature refused its recommendations at least the destruction would be more highly visible. A special master, moreover, could be a brake on further agency backsliding.

The status quo cannot hold, because if it does, the verge we are on will reveal even more nasty surprises.

Monday, March 13, 2017

Dead Fish, Bad Air, Trump and the EPA ... by gimleteye


Follow me on Twitter: @gimleteyemiami


In a recent Miami Herald OPED, Carl Hiaasen quoted Trump’s EPA chief Scott Pruitt, the former Attorney General of Oklahoma, “I think people across the country look at the EPA the way they look at the IRS”. When Pruitt made that statement a few weeks ago, my antennae caught the idiocy straight away.

Pruitt makes clear "the sort of people he’s listening to and aims to serve. Corporate polluters look at the EPA the same way corporate tax cheats look at the IRS — as the enemy”.  But I have some clarifying observations.

Most Americans have no idea what the EPA does — or is supposed to do — beyond right-wing talking points through media channels bought and paid for by polluters.  Every wage earner and family in the country knows the IRS, but for the most part it is the regulated community — and within the regulated community primarily polluters who comprise the largest share of campaign contributions across the politcial spectrum — who know the EPA.

Environmentalists on the other hand know the EPA. They know its mission has been steadily compromised by corporations more powerful than people.

EPA has never been “over-funded”; a key talking point of the extreme right. The agency just never did its job particularly well because it was hobbled by politics, irrespective of party controlling the White House. The phenomenon is a familiar in Florida: let the regulated community gradually weaken a regulatory system it despises then invest the masses in "outrage" against government.

Here, citizens relied for a quarter century on an agency called the Florida Department of Community Affairs. Like the federal Clean Water Act that provides citizens with an avenue to challenge the EPA in federal court, Florida law provided an avenue for citizens to sue the Florida DCA.

Simply put, the job of the DCA was to balance environmental and quality of life concerns with developers and Big Agriculture whose goal is maximum profit from whatever economic activity they can profitably finance. Florida corporations involved in land development hated the DCA.

Most Floridians were clueless about DCA. Most Floridians had forgotten that past generations of Florida leadership struggled to build bipartisan consensus to the most vexing problem facing one of the nation’s key electoral states.

Over time,  lobbyists, lawyers, and politicians drove nails into the feet of the state agency. Finally, Gov. Rick Scott and state legislators pulled the beast out of the water and shot it on the shore. Today, the EPA is facing the same fate.

Rick Scott is relevant for a reason. The governor of Florida is one of Donald Trump's few natural allies. Like Scott, Trump made a fortune playing the arbitrage between the intent of protective laws and profitable, regulated businesses. You can make more money if you have the power to force the spread wider, and even more money still if you eliminate “onerous” and “job killing” regulations. That, in a nutshell, is the plan.

Here is the crucial point about corporate polluters or those otherwise regulated by the EPA: if you want to make money, the lowest hanging fruit is through the reduction or elimination of costly regulations. It’s a whole lot harder to build a business or innovate a new product, bring it to market, and eventually reap the financial rewards than making existing products more profitable by eliminating the costs associated with regulatory compliance.

If you can reduce regulation by a dollar, that saved dollar goes straight to the bottom line, executives and shareholders. Polluters hate the EPA because regulations deny them profits. The public? Not so much.

If you ask Americans whether they value the air they breathe, the water they drink, the natural resources where they recreate, or the quality of food that they eat, the vast majority say, yes of course. If you ask Americans whether it is important to protect children against cancer and against disease, it would be hard to find a single person who objects to a vigorous federal role.

What most observers miss, in the tumult over the role of the EPA as the federal regulator of polluting corporations is this: to environmentalists, the EPA never fulfilled the promise of its mission. I know, because like Scott Pruitt, I also sued the EPA but not because it “over-reached” its authority, as Pruitt claimed, but because the EPA did too little.

Here are two examples. In the early 2000’s, the Bush EPA resolved — despite massive public opposition — to weaken the Safe Drinking Water Act. It turned out that fracking, and the entire natural gas industry depended on the injection of fluids that could fracture and move between geologic layers deep underground. Sierra Club (I was a volunteer leader at the time) sued the EPA under federal law. We objected to the fact that the state of Florida and Miami-Dade County was injecting partially treated sewage underground and it was leaking upward toward drinking water. We lost.

The second example is Florida's Everglades, which most Americans assume have been “saved”. Friends of the Everglades and the Miccosukee Tribe of Indians sued the EPA because the federal agency failed to hold the state of Florida accountable for following legal, binding agreements it had made to resolve an earlier generation of lawsuits. We won, but the state of Florida is vigorously contesting — at the urging of Big Sugar — the federal court decision.

Although most readers are unaware of these cases, the same kinds of stories can be told in every region of the nation. The EPA and federal regulatory authority ought to be improved, not axed. The counter argument by polluters is that the best regulation is located in the states. If that were true, Florida wouldn’t be violating underground aquifers to accommodate cheap growth and the Everglades and Florida Bay would have been saved a long time ago.

Once upon a time, right wing think tanks made an effort to argue that economic activities should “internalize” all their costs. That is true conservatism. But GOP legislators are not loyal to principle. They paved the way for Trump who cares even less. Why? Because “externalizing” costs — that is to say, shifting costs to others — is how to make really big money.

Whether you agree or disagree, the American people now face the undoing of fifty years of hard-won progress on the environment. Federal authority provides a necessary and check and balance to powerful corporations who dominate state legislatures.

CARL HIAASEN
Miami Herald
MARCH 10, 2017 9:13 PM

Like phosphorus in your water? You’re in luck!

As far back as 1996, phosphorus has been blamed for damaging the Everglades. More than 20 years later, it’s still an issue.Jon Kral Miami Herald file
BY CARL HIAASEN
chiaasen@miamiherald.com
•

Soon after being confirmed as the new chief of the Environmental Protection Agency, Scott Pruitt said this to a conference of conservative activists:

Tuesday, June 28, 2016

How Florida Republican Voters Became Losers ... by gimleteye

Massive toxic algae blooming around the southern half of the Florida peninsula, coating with dangerous scum the prospects for public health, tourism, business and real estate on both Florida coasts is the real consequence to taxpayers and voters of losing their bet on Republican leadership: Gov. Scott, Senate President Joe Negron, Attorney General Pam Bondi, Agriculture Secretary Adam Putnam, state representative Matt Caldwell, US Senator Marco Rubio, and all the insiders and cronies they corralled to serve on boards like the water management districts and Public Service Commission. This isn't hyperbole. A real bet was made by voters. A real bet was lost.

It wasn't too long ago -- although it seems like ages -- that sober minds in both political parties, Republican and Democrat, understood that whatever their differences, attention must be paid to the public interest. In time, however, the GOP's lock on both houses of the legislature and the executive mansion boiled down to a myopic confidence that the best way to protect people was allowing corporate interests to take over the functions of government.

In Florida, Republican voters, persuaded that "enlightened self-interest of the profit motive" was real and not trickery, crystallized their preferences by electing a businessman with no government experience, Rick Scott, to be governor.

Although Rick Scott has a couple of years left on his final term, for voters the Rick Scott experiment is already coming to an end. Gaming legal protections turns out to be a very poor way to improve the quality of life of taxpayers and voters, whether Republican or not.

One of Gov. Rick Scott's first acts as governor was to axe the science budget and staff at the state agency charged with protecting fresh water resources in Florida. By eliminating scientists at the South Florida Water Management District, Scott erased the institutional memory of an agency nominally charged with balancing the needs of people and the environment with the needs of industry. Specifically, Big Sugar.

Scott appointed members of the governing board of the South Florida Water Management District who had no experience whatsoever or compassion for the environment. The Scott way distilled to a simple formula: cede regulatory control to special interests who had the most to earn by limiting the impact of regulation on their profit models.

One of Rick Scott's other first steps was to deal the death blow to the state agency that had managed to survive successive, serial assaults by the Republican leaders: the Florida Department of Community Affairs. By the time Rick Scott was elected in 2010, DCA shakily stood on the foundation of a bipartisan consensus forged by earlier generations of Republican and Democratic state leaders.

Gov. Scott was supremely uninterested in the history of DCA. He didn't care to learn or to understand a government model in decision-making for communities because it included citizen input. Scott took his self-funded victory for the governor's mansion in Florida to be a mandate for entrepreneurship over treading water with the people: put government in the hands of businessmen most impacted by outcomes or simply do away with regulatory functions of government that inhibit economic activities and "jobs".

Florida's shadow government, exemplified by Big Sugar, could not have been more pleased. Scott, as a newbie, needed training. He came to Tallahassee without a game plan or qualified staff. He would need to be brought up-to-speed and who better to bring him up-to-speed than the shadow government comprised of lobbyists and insiders who populated the state capitol, Tallahassee, and reported back to employers in Palm Beach, Tampa, Jacksonville, Naples and Miami. Scott was, fortuitously, exactly what the shadow government had been looking for all along: a smart guy perfectly in sync to streamline their profits by eliminating government regulatory functions to the maximum practical extent.

Prisons, public education, health care, and public safety: from one perspective, what Republican leaders have done is to unleash corporate freedom to create a model GOP state. From another perspective, Florida's Republican leadership is leading a race to the bottom, challenging Alabama and Mississippi as the most corrupt and polluted state in the nation.

Another of Gov. Scott's first acts was to cast aside a bargain made by his predecessor and US Sugar Corporation, the largest producer of sugarcane and one of the biggest landowners in Florida. The deal would have put into state ownership, over time, enough land -- 187,000 acres -- to begin the process of fixing what the US Army Corps of Engineers and Florida agencies like the South Florida Water Management had destroyed: the elasticity of the infrastructure system whose goal was to manage water resources for all taxpayers and for the benefit of economic interests that depend on a healthy environment.

Today's ecological collapse in the St. Lucie River, connected estuaries, in the Caloosahatchee River, along both Florida coasts and stretching down through the Everglades to Florida Bay is a neon sign flashing in front of taxpayers and voters. When Gov. Rick Scott, Marco Rubio and Adam Putnam killed the US Sugar deal, they ignored the history and science of Lake Okeechobee. Of course, Scott had already eliminated the science capacity of the state water district. By allowing political science to trump fact and the imperative for government intervention, Florida's GOP created political conditions for deadly cyanobacteria to destroy the treasures of South Florida, including public health and personal real estate.

Toxic Algae
In recent weeks, the silence of the state has been deafening. Social media sites like Facebook are filling with grim photos and videos of waterways clogged with toxic algae. The mainstream media, late to the story, has followed. Toxic blue-green algae, linked to brain disease in humans, turns out to make eye-capturing video too. Meanwhile, state agencies charged with protecting public health and measuring toxins aren't even picking up their phones because state offices for holding polluters to account for pollution are now broom closets.

If Democratic voters are furious, what is the word to describe Republican voters in Florida? Losers. Losers, because over a long period of time, they elected Republicans who turned their back on history, on bipartisan consensus and the lessons of the past. They did so with the confidence that insiders and special interests could protect the public better than regulations and enforcement because they get paid when customers are happy.

Gov. Scott Adam Putnam, Marco Rubio, and state Senate president Joe Negron can do nothing about the blight coating Florida's coastlines except to hold a few meetings, fund a few more planning studies, while cramming as much money from special interests into their campaign accountants as they can before November. It is, after all, a bet they won in the past.

Wednesday, March 18, 2015

Wet dreams - You can't go back on them, Miami Dade County Commissioners. By Geniusofdespair

 It was moved by Commissioner Seijas that all applicants requesting to develop outside the UDB line be instructed to meet with the Miami-Dade Water & Sewer Department prior to CDMP meeting scheduled for April 2006 to develop a specific, alternative water supply plan for their projects and that the proposal be included in the applicant’s final application. This motion was seconded by Commissioner Heyman; and upon being put to a vote, the motion passed by a unanimous vote of 13-0.

(Special Item Number 2 was adopted on November 30, 2005.)

 Both of us were at the County Commission during the 2005 CDMP cyle hearings. They said they would allow the Urban Development Boundary to be moved for Application No. 5, ONLY if they could find a water source for the application. It was agreed in a settlement agreement that the Hialeah and the County would build a desalination plant for the application so they would have their own water source for the plan.

Today, according to water and sewer, we are flush with water because of conservation. At the County Commission meeting today the question was what would be the water source for the American (wet) Dream Mall Miami.  Think about it, snow for the slope, water park etc. They will be using a lot of water. Stupid idiot Lester Sola, now the department head, said the County could give them water. Well, stupid idiot Lester Sola, once you give them water you can't go back. It is a one way street and we already had a bargain that they would not get aquifer water. Why would you get up there and make such a promise? Because you are a stupid idiot. We the public had our promise this wouldn't happen. The commission goes back on promises to us all the time - remember the 20 year deed restriction in Kendall they lifted in less than 5 years? We don't sue like this little guy will sue you. He was the most obnoxious of developers. He warned, don't give me a hard time. All the Commissioners giggled and passed the land deal with no caveats 11 to 2. Marlins all over again. Eskandar Ghermezian wasn't being funny, he was serious. Seriously scary. If you go back on a promise to this guy the County will be in lawsuits forever. He made no concessions at all.



Triple 5 Group - Ghermezian family
Watch on YouTube
What if we have a drought? A lot more development? What if we have more saltwater intrusion? Why would we offer our precious water as if were endless? I was playing good citizen conserving water for this? Most of the Commissioners did such a good job groveling. Commissioner Moss, this isn't going to help your theme park. Commissioner Sally Heyman was the only one who wanted to add water source to the agreement. You can't go back on your promises....Source was important as Sally said.

Here is a timeline for the 2005 cycle:
City of Hialeah applied to amend the County’s Comprehensive Development Master Plan (CDMP), in the April 2005 Cycle, to:
• Move the 2015 Urban Development Boundary (UDB)
• Change designation from “open lands” to “industrial and office”
• Application included 1,140 gross acres (between NW 97th Ave and the Turnpike and between NW 154 St and NW 186 St (the Annexation Area)
• April 19, 2006, the BCC approved application and transmitted to the State of Florida.
• June 22, 2006, the State issued Notice of Intent to find the amendment “not in compliance”. The main objection to the application was “non-availability of potable water supply”.
• July 6, 2006, the BCC approved resolution (R-847-06), authorizing execution of a Settlement Agreement, which required the adoption of a “Remedial Plan Amendment” within 75 days.
• August 24, 2006, the BCC adopted Ordinance (Ord-06-116) providing disposition of Remedial Amendment, which included “a funded commitment for a new reverse osmosis water facility, the Floridan Aquifer Water Treatment Plant, in the Capital Improvements Element”.
• July 24, 2007, the BCC approved resolution (R-918-07) entering into a Joint Participation Agreement (JPA), between the City and the County, to provide for a reverse osmosis water treatment plant to meet future water supply needs in northern Miami-Dade County.

Here are the minutes 8/24/2006 (they always do important things in the summer);

Chairman Martinez called the meeting to order at 11:40 a.m. He noted the purpose of today’s meeting was to take final action on the remedial amendment application to amend the Comprehensive Development Master Plan (CDMP). The remedial amendment application, he noted, was filed by the Department of Planning and Zoning (DPZ) on behalf of the County Manager as directed by this Board in Resolution Number R-847-06; and approved the settlement agreement with the Florida Department of Community Affairs (DCA), which resolved a pending dispute relating to Application Number 5, (AKA the “Hialeah Application”) of the April 2005 CDMP amendment cycle. Chairman Martinez noted the remedial amendment application was consistent with the remedial plan amendment described in Exhibit B of the executed settlement agreement, and was the subject of today’s public hearing as it pertained to Application Number 5 only. The Board was scheduled to take final action today on Substitute Special Item No. 1, by either adopting, adopting with change, or not adopting the amendment application. Chairman Martinez noted the procedure for the hearing would be as follows: Department of Planning and Zoning (DPZ) staff would summarize the content of the remedial amendment application; speakers, if any, would be called in order of signing in; written statements would be accepted, summarized and submitted for the record. Assistant County Attorney Joni Armstrong-Coffey read the foregoing proposed ordinance, Substitute Special Item No. 1 into the record. Chairman Martinez relinquished the chair to Vice Chairman Moss. DPZ Director Diane O’Quinn Williams introduced herself and noted that Mr. Mark Woerner had distributed a summary of the remedial amendment. Mr. Mark Woerner, Metropolitan Planning - Long Range Planning Section Chief, Department of Planning and Zoning, advised that the Board would be taking action on the Substitute Special Item No. 1, Legislative File No. 062315. He noted the DPZ Director’s remedial amendments application; the stipulated settlement agreement executed between the County and the Department of Community Affairs (DCA); the Resolution Number R-847-06 enacted by the Board on July 6, 2006, and pertaining to the proposed settlement agreement; and the June 21, 2006 Interlocal agreement between the City of Hialeah and the County regarding the operation and maintenance responsibilities of the proposed plant, have been provided for today’s hearing. Mr. Woerner indicated the reason the remedial amendments were before the Board was because the DCA found the amendments to be in non-compliance during their final review process of the Board’s final actions on the comprehensive plan amendments. He noted the primary issue was that the County did not demonstrate it was able to provide adequate water supply to serve the demand created by those Land Use Plan (LUP) map amendments, therefore, today’s remedial amendment only addressed Application No. 5. Mr. Woerner proceeded to provide an overview of the settlement agreement and the requested changes outlined in the “2006 Remedial Amendments Application Requesting Amendments to the Comprehensive Development Master Plan.”

Monday, November 24, 2014

Ferocious Traffic: what comes next? … by gimleteye

In Miami during the summer, traffic is a breeze compared to what comes next. As schools return and the fall weather improves, traffic turns titanic.

What is happening downtown, these days, at rush hour and beyond defies elaboration. There is only one word for the blaring horns, lane restrictions, the gridlock at successive street lights: ferocious.

The traffic is ferocious for a reason.
image at 8:21 AM

When you are stuck in Miami traffic this December, remember: you voted for the elected officials -- in the city of Miami, the city of Miami Beach, in Miami-Dade county, the state legislature and Governor's Mansion who made this happen.

Many of these public officials are still in office. Many are looking for a way back in.

Will voters ever hold them accountable for the destruction of quality of life that goes along with community-stifling, business-deadening traffic? Not yet.

There is every indication (Ludlam Trail, anyone?) that our elected officials will continue to vote for "compromises" that impose even greater traffic burdens on taxpayers and residents.

Massive construction and development of downtown corridors preceded any response by elected officials to estimate, plan and build infrastructure adequate to the need.

Sure every zoning and permitting hearing is clogged with expert consultants, using charts and graphs to show how their client's project will not increase traffic.

Complainers -- civic activists for better transit, for public parks and the environment -- are derided, dismissed, marginalized or otherwise politely pushed away by technicalities.

Builders during the boom and even after the bust are glorified. Their names get put on buildings, while the mess they helped created is absorbed as the natural order of things. Jorge Perez, for example. Mayor Manny Diaz, for example.

When you want "growth at any cost", the way the Chamber of Commerce or Club for Growth or Associated Industries or the South Florida Builders do, taxpayers are left with exactly this: ferocious traffic.

These days one begins to hear voices from the business sector in advertiser-sponsored media, lamenting we "could" kill the goose that lays the golden egg. Ex-cuse me?

For distant investors -- that describes the vast majority of owners in downtown Miami -- all that matters is that their assets are safe and secure. The rest of us -- the commuters, the downtown residents imagining they are moving into a sophisticated city -- are fuel pellets for growth.

You could ask, wouldn't it be a good idea to make traffic improvements concurrent at the same time or in advance of construction and development?

At the state level, the idea of comprehensive land use planning was destroyed by the Republican legislature after more than thirty years of work and bipartisan consensus. Was Gov. Scott held accountable for putting the Florida DCA, the agency once charged with reviewing traffic concurrency, into a capital broom closet?

As all the Miami condo canyons were being created and making mortgage investors, insurers, banks and their shareholders very wealthy on Brickell and downtown, of course they knew that the roadways would not be able to hold the traffic.

We've been planning badly for transit to accommodate growth for so long that, now, there is no elasticity whatsoever in car movement along Miami's roadways and interstates. At rush hour, any -- and I mean, ANY -- glitch in traffic flow causes a massive logjam that can easily double or triple normal transit times.

The other evening, trying to find the fastest route downtown -- imagining to be on the far side of rush hour -- I looked at my Google map and every road and artery downtown was a solid red line. It was a representation of cardiac arrest.

Ferocious traffic is not destiny. It is what we chose at the ballot box. 

Friday, September 05, 2014

Why voting for Charlie Crist is good for Florida … by gimleteye


US Senator Marco Rubio really doesn't like Charlie Crist. That much is clear in a hostile letter mailed to Florida Republican voters.

Where's the sugar, Marco?

Remember when Charlie Crist was governor, he tried to fix Everglades restoration with a dramatic purchase of more than 150,000 crucial acres south of Lake Okeechobee to restore the dying River of Grass. The Fanjul billionaires were "outraged" (no one crosses the Fanjuls!) and were biggest supporters of Rubio in his campaign for US Senate against Crist.

Hating on Charlie Crist is what Big Sugar does.

Rick Scott fits squarely into Big Sugar's long plans for developing sugarcane lands into suburban sprawl.

Recently, US Sugar ratcheted up the stakes for taxpayers funding Everglades restoration, easily pushing past the Hendry County Commission a plan to develop 67 square miles of its sugarcane into more Florida sprawl.

That's land Charlie Crist wanted to purchase for the Everglades and was criticized by Republicans for saying it would cost too much. Well what, dear readers, what do you imagine the cost will be, now that industrial, commercial, and residential zoning is attached to it? And when US Sugar paid for Republican legislators to hunt in luxury at the King Ranch in Texas, Gov. Rick Scott was right there -- but he wasn't talking business, he says.

Florida's Republican leaders don't like Charlie Crist, but they are not telling you how they are lining their pockets by wrecking so much of what Floridians value. For instance, everything to do with restoration of America's Everglades is a work-around of Big Sugar.

Republican leaders believe that if government can put a monetary value for corporations on any action, then government can afford to pay for protecting what is harmed by that action. The problem with the formula is that it depends on mis-pricing. Put a higher value than a government regulation is worth and underspend what is necessary to protect the public.

That's exactly what Republicans lead by Gov. Rick Scott did by destroying the agency charged with growth management in Florida. They claimed that the Florida DCA was a "jobs killer" but that was vastly over-stating the case, and cost, against growth management. Instead, after years of under-cutting regulations -- "government-designed-to-fail" is the best description of what Florida Republican leadership believes in -- Gov. Rick Scott simply delivered the final blow, destroying what took decades of bipartisan consensus to build.

It's sweet for them and sour for us. Do once, and, repeat. It's gaming the system, and no governor has been better at gaming Florida than Gov. Rick Scott.

For Republicans, the problem with Charlie Crist is that he can never be one of their cronies, helping to mis-price government action in order to fatten their net worth. These days, that's a very low bar and a very good reason to vote for Charlie Crist.

Tuesday, February 25, 2014

The Michael Bennett legacy: Florida Fractured (Part III) … by gimleteye

On his Wikipedia website, former state senator Michael Bennett (R-Bradenton) stops in motion. The website isn't updated to reflect that he was term-limited out of the state legislature. It isn't updated to show that from a top position in the state legislature -- in 2010 he was the # 2 wingman for the radical right -- he then became the supervisor of elections in Manatee County. It doesn't show that recently, at former senator Bennett's urging, the board of county commissioners voted a strictly party line vote to drastically reduce the number of polling stations in prominently Democratic areas of  the county, attracting national condemnation. A search of the web provides no information about "Alladin Wand Electric", its ownership, or what he did exactly as president of the company. The Wikipedia record that is available for viewing, either created by Bennett himself or more likely by a staffer while in the state senate, is a bland, uninformative recitation -- disinformation, is the best way to put it --  by a Jeb Bush lieutenant. 

Bennett was a state Republican leader unafraid to walk point for Florida's aristocracy, The Great Destroyers, and walked their pinnacle achievement forward: destroying growth management in Florida. It took a long time to accomplish in a crucial decade that largely coincided with Jeb Bush's tenure as governor.


Here is one of the Wikipedia entries: "Bennett was the author of Senate Bill 360, a complex growth management bill that passed both houses and was signed by Gov. Charlie Crist on June 1, 2009. The bill essentially changed how local governments in some parts of the state could charge impact fees, eliminating developments of regional impact—where large-scale residential or commercial developments were responsible for upgrading transportation around the project—in high-density population areas. The bill passed the Senate 32-8 on April 2, 2009, and later passed the House 76-41. Tallahassee Circuit Judge Charles Francis, however, declared the law unconstitutional in August 2010, claiming it was an "unfunded mandate."[8] The Florida Constitution generally prohibits lawmakers from forcing municipalities to spend more than 10 cents per Floridian."

In fact, the bill signed into law in 2009 was hardly a failure. It was a signal accomplishment. The efforts to dismantle community planning at the state level had started nearly as soon as the landmark state legislation was passed with a strong bipartisan consensus in 1985. As the regulatory structure began forming, to ensure that Florida's growth would take place in a sensible way and not harm irreplaceable natural assets, a core of opponents from homebuilders to real estate and construction interests began forming. They put continuous pressure on the executive branch -- the Governor's office -- and legislators to reign in the bureaucrats who made their lives more difficult by requiring expensive studies and applications for large scale developments to meet standards like protecting wetlands or ensuring that highway capacity or schools existed to serve new residents. They wanted to build as cheaply and as quickly as possible. When Jeb Bush was elected to Governor in 1998, after a surprise defeat to Democrat Lawton Chiles in an earlier election, they had their man. 

But Jeb needed lieutenants, and Michael Bennett was his man. The 2009 "defeat" of Bennett's plan by a Florida circuit court judge is 100 percent inaccurate. In fact, Bennett is quoted saying so. “Looks like we’re going to court,” Bennett said. “But I’ll get the last laugh because [the Legislature] will be back in session before they get a court date. Now that I know what their objections are, we’ll fix it. And I still contend we’ll get growth going again in this state.”   (GROWTH MANAGEMENT: Weston leads challenge to new law that favors developers, July 2, 2009, South Florida Daily Business Review)

There are several parts to this quote that bear comment, more than four years after the fact. First of all, "getting the last laugh" is exactly how Bennett and his co-horts, including some of the most secretive and wealthy campaign financiers in Florida and the United States, thought about their job of dismantling growth management: it was a game of checkers and because of the GOP's lock grip on the legislature, they won out of the box. It was a matter of formalities. By 2012, growth management in Florida was dead. The 2009 effort was simply another step along the way; another hill taken, another target identified. There is nothing illegal about using the legislature to circumvent the judiciary, but it is misleading and inaccurate to characterize -- as Bennett does in his historical record -- the 2009 setback as a "defeat". Moreover, what was to come had already been planned: that is how things are done in Florida.

Bennett's Wikipedia entry makes an interesting note of Charlie Crist, who "signed" his bill into law in 2009. A year earlier, Crist had taken a severe political beating -- with Bennett leading the charge -- for trying to set the stage for real Everglades restoration through the purchase of 180,000 acres of land in the Everglades Agricultural Area  owned by US Sugar Corporation. Bennett lead the campaign to push back against the Crist plan. By 2009, Crist had committed to run for US Senate and had his reasons for making peace with Bennett and the wealthy forces he (Bennett) represented. Of course, Marco Rubio would defeat Crist in the 2010 election -- counting Big Sugar among his strongest backers. In 2010, Michael Bennett was promoted to the number two slot in the state senate, president pro-tem.

On his Wikipedia website, Bennett lists his occupation as president of the Aladdin Wand Electric  Company. Although there is no information on the internet about the electric company, there is something magical about the way that Bennett represented a movement to do away with Growth Management; first hobbling the beast, then spiking its knees, and finally decapitating the state agency that reflected nearly forty years of bipartisan consensus.

The attack led by Bennett was entirely partisan, emerging out of a Republican stranglehold on the state legislature with an ineffective Democratic minority hamstrung in the chase for the same campaign money from developers and development interests who gave primarily to GOP candidates. The irony is that 40 years of growth management policies -- that Bennett did his level best to destroy as part of a strike team -- was a signature bipartisan achievement, featuring a generation of GOP leadership who both mourned the loss of natural habitats and the unique attributes of the state and knew that sprawl, construction and Big Agriculture could turn the state into a chaotic mess. Some of those Republicans, like the late Congressmen Porter Goss and Clay Shaw, would emerge in 2003 to rebuke the Jeb Bush administration and the key players in the legislature, like Bennett, for tampering with the federal state agreement to rescue the Everglades that was also decades in the making through bipartisan consensus. Had they still been alive and in office, the old guard who forged agreement in the Florida legislature to create growth management policies that were the most forward-looking in the nation would have taken Bennett to the wood shed. But there was no one to do it, although the state's newspaper editorial boards tried their best with one broadside after another.

A Republican who had been involved in the struggle to tame the worst impulses of the development industries, Former DCA secretary Tom Pelham also tried to push back against the presumption that Republican legislators were following the sober, conservative principles of accountability or job creation.

Florida's right wing radicals wrap themselves in the American flag and virtues of the "free market". Free from the interference of regulatory authority, the law of supply and demand will better protect the public interest. Industries and shareholders would use self-interest to price the appropriate costs -- from roadways, to schools, and quality of life concerns like the environment -- because otherwise their business portfolios would suffer. It is an easy sell to Republican voters but masks the damage done to the public interest.

"As a result of these statutory changes," Pelham wrote of the 2009 law, "local (growth) plans are no longer required to financially feasible (even though the Legislature strengthened this critical requirement as recently as 2005). Now local governments can adopt plans without regard for their ability to pay for them. Although Florida is plagued by ovelr development and huge unoccupied housing inventory of more than one million units, need has been effectively abolished as a state mandatory planning factor. Now local governments can plan for greed and excess rather than need."

“Sometimes it just takes years for an idea to come to fruition," state senator Michael Bennett told the Sarasota Herald Tribune in June 2013 ("Move over law gives Bennett belated victory", Herald Tribune, June 13, 2013) http://politics.heraldtribune.com/2013/06/13/forcing-slow-pokes-out-of-the-left-lane-bennett-scores-belated-legislative-victory/

And that is exactly the way to read the 2014 plan to sharply reduce polling places in Manatee County, Florida, where the supervisor of elections is a term-limited state senator, Michael Bennett. (to be continued)

Wednesday, November 20, 2013

UDB Hearing Today and Does Incorporation Breed Corruption? By Geniusofdespair

Kerri Barsh
There is a hearing about the mall in our wellfield that would move the Urban Development Boundary.  The wellfield part is particularly offensive. It is our water supply. Reelection time is approaching, it won't pass. Although I suppose this is the hearing about whether or not to forward it to the DCA. "I just want their professional opinion" the commissioners will say. That gives Commissioners cover. Expect an impassioned speech by Lynda Bell trying to redeem herself of the Don't Fence Me In scandal. Since Carlos Gimenez said he would not support it and the rock miners are against it, I think it is dead. But, it gives them all a chance to make speeches. I am surprised Turnberry hasn't pulled it. They might still, if they are smart.

You will have the opportunity to get me very good pictures at this event.  I would love photos of lobbyists huddled together or talking on their cell phones in the ante-chamber. It is fun to take them. As they see you approach they will start moving away, you can get them to circle the room a few times. Lots of fun.  Please get me some photos attendees. I will post them tomorrow.  Also need a photo of what rock mining lawyer queen Kerri Barsh is wearing. That photo is just because it amuses me. She will be there.  Lobbyists, you can take them of your enemy lobbyists.  I need photos!! Send them to geniusofdespair@yahoo.com

UPDATE ON UDB HEARING 10:30: IT WAS PULLED AS I PREDICTED AND LYNDA BELL WAS ABSENT. PEPE DIAZ OBJECTED TO IT (PROBABLY BECAUSE OF ROCK MINERS) AND JEFFREY BERCOW  AGREED TO PULL IT.

In other news, lets looks at City mayors.  
Aventura: Susan Gottlieb is just a total idiot and rude and dismissive to constituents and a Soroka puppet (her city manager).
Miami Beach: Phillip Levine banned the press from some events and does Slapp Suits.
North Miami Beach Former Mayor Myron Rosner: Arrested.
North Miami Mayor Lucie Tondreau: Office was raided in absentee ballot probe.
Doral Mayor: Out of his mind.
Sweetwater Former Mayor: Plead guilty.
Miami Lakes Former Mayor: Arrested
Homestead Former Mayor: Arrested.
Florida City Mayor: No one is talking.
Medley Mayor: Doesn't have a clue.

To me, this could possibly be a case AGAINST incorporation. Although, maybe Katherine Fernandez Rundle and the Ethics Commission only have the balls to go after mayors, sparing commissioners.  I know a lot of ethics decisions that give commissioners cover for bad behavior.

Saturday, September 07, 2013

St. Pete Times: How Growth Management Works Now? ... by gimleteye

Florida is a different state, depending on one's experiences. In Miami-Dade, the loss of growth management -- thanks to the most clueless governor in Florida history, Rick Scott -- threw planning and zoning decisions to the level of government least likely to represent the public: the county commission and mayor. For history, read our blog archives.  I've attended our version of 13 hour county commission hearings. Too exhausted by these issues to revisit them now.

Controversy over Manatee County development shows how growth management works now
Craig Pittman, Times Staff Writer
Friday, September 6, 2013 6:10pm

Carlos Beruff is one of Florida's most powerful people. He has run a major development firm for 30 years, donated heavily to Gov. Rick Scott and other politicians, and is chairman of the Southwest Florida Water Management District, which controls the region's water supply.

Thursday, June 27, 2013

David Guest slams legislature and Gov. Rick Scott... By gimleteye

There are a few points that environmental warrior David Guest does not make in his OPED, below.

First, that voters who elected Gov. Rick Scott and a GOP majority in the state legislature are directly implicated in the unfolding tragedy of the commons in Florida. Second, that voters are the only avenue of appeal.

Voters could claim they are uninformed how badly Gov. Scott and the legislature have performed. They could look to the corporations -- like Big Sugar -- that fund political candidates and campaigns, for reasons that radical conservatives have hijacked public forums and legislative bodies.

A final point: recovering ground in the state legislature is immensely difficult. For example, real estate, builders, developers and farmer/ land speculators who succeeded in destroying the state land use planning agency, DCA, blew up decades of hard fought compromises. To be sure, environmentalists found plenty to dislike about the performance of DCA, but DCA provided at least a platform for dissent.

Where does dissent find expression in Florida, today? 6PM News? MDX public meetings? The US Army Corps of Engineers hearings? The Miami Herald? Voltaire: “It is dangerous to be right in matters on which the established authorities are wrong.”


By David Guest, Florida Managing Attorney for Earthjustice, a national public interest law firm.

A few miles from Florida's state Capitol, a lake has broken out with toxic algae that causes skin rashes and liver damage in humans and kills wildlife. I wish I could tell you this was an isolated case.

The fact is, hundreds of manatees, dolphins, birds, and fish have been washing up dead on both the east and west coasts. Those waters are fouled by sewage, manure, fertilizer, and sewage — pollution that fuels algae outbreaks.

How bad is it? Take a look:

Thursday, March 28, 2013

The Christian Family Coalition's Attack on Congresswoman Ilena Ros-Lehtinen. By Geniusofdespair

You have to hit on this press release to read it. It really should be read by every friggin' politican in Miami Dade County who goes to this group for an endorsement. You should be ashamed, Democrats and Republicans alike. This press release is a travesty.
Yeah, I really don't have much use for Congresswoman Ilena Ros-Lehtinen but I would never call her corrupt like the Christian Family Coaltion did in this press release. Corrupt is a very harsh word. I never called Natacha Seijas corrupt, I don't even think I ever called David Rivera corrupt. Hell, this is a blog and if I am not using that word I'm damn sure that a group that calls itself 'Christian' should NOT be calling a Congresswoman corrupt. Lets look at the meaning: Having or showing a willingness to act dishonestly in return for money.

Why is the Christian Family Coalition calling the Congresswoman corrupt? Because of a vote Ileana Ros-Lehtinen cast that they didn't like. If I used the same barometer, every single politician whoever served anywhere in Miami Dade County would be corrupt, including Katy Sorenson. Katy cast a few votes I didn't like.  I am just not that extreme.
 
There are always going to be some votes I won't like that is life. Granted the Christian Family Coalition are pretty much a two trick pony, their issues are Anti-gay and Anti-choice and their mouth piece is Anthony Verdugo (If he disappeared so would the group). I do recognize that with only 2 issues, the group would put great importance on a vote they didn't like. But there is a way to phrase displeasure that is not hateful and vengeful.  Especially if you want to act like a real Christian.

I,  of course, am following a lot more issues. Some votes I get madder at than others. I just put the politician on my shit list. But I still don't call them corrupt.

Frankly, I am shocked that any politician or judge would want to be endorsed by a group that releases threatening, nasty press releases against fellow politicians and sitting judges. Be strong public figures: stand firm and boycott this group when they reach out to you. You owe it to U.S. Congresswoman Ilena Ros-Lehtinen and to County Commissioner Dennis Moss. I wrote about the CFC's nasty press release on Dennis Moss on Saturday.   Also, do it for the judges. In a Press Release from the CFC dated 9/22/2010 (in response to the 3rd DCA opinion upholding Judge Lederman in the Gil adoption case) Anthony Verdugo said:
"Corrupt Appeals Judges VIOLATE Oath of Office, Irrationally Attack Law Protectng Children! Florida Voters: Lawless Judges Must Be Impeached!"
Whoa! I implore every reader to send an email or call their county commissioner, their city officials and their State officials: Tell them "Don't go for a Christian Family Coalition endorsement." If a politician comes to your door, ask them if they have the CFC endorsement or if they have gone to a Christian Family Coalition meeting to speak. If they have, say thank you and close the door.

There is a way to behave and even I behave better than this...hard to believe. Read the damn press release! and hit on the link.

To see an older list from 2010 who supported/was supported by the CFC, hit read more:

Monday, February 18, 2013

Larry Hawkins, really? ... by gimleteye

Once upon a time on the upper west side of Manhattan (this is real and true!) I regularly had breakfasts at Tom's Restaurant; that is to say, the same place at the same time that the future president, Barack Obama, also frequented Tom's. Hear me out. This isn't another six degrees of separation story.

This weekend, nursing a severe case of jet lag, I contemplated how to write about the return to quasi public life of a disgraced former county commissioner, Larry Hawkins, now chosen by the unions to be its representative on the Jackson Health System board. What was in that coffee I was drinking, staring into the future? Did I imagine I would be writing about the horrendous error the unions are making in reviving a public role for a disgraced Miami politician whose notoriety chases him like a string of tin cans tied to a car bumper, while my former counter mate, now president of the United States, was golfing with Tiger Woods? Hell, back then Barack Obama didn't even know the right way to hold a golf club!

We know where Larry Hawkins went wrong. It is detailed in CASE NO. 94-4715EC, in Florida state administrative court.

Wednesday, January 30, 2013

People Get Ready for Battle 2: Target Store. By Geniusofdespair

Environmental land battles are never over. Target Stores purchased a property on SW 8th Street from Lowe's Store 11/19/2012 for $9,800,000. As you can see they wasted no time hiring lobbyists, the ink was hardly dry on the deed. To be fair to Target, they could build the store on approximately 12 acres they have within the Urban Development Boundary. However, do you really need a gaggle of lobbyists to do what you are allowed to do? Yes, I do know that they are Holland & Knight attorneys. To me, the lobbyists are a bad sign. I hope this doesn't turn into another land use battle, Oscar Musibay of the South Florida Business Journal reflected on just that in a recent article. Musibay contacted Target and they said:

"Target is committed to being a great neighbor..."

Let's hope so, but, Juan Mayol is the lobbyist of choice for land battles outside the UDB line.

Lobbyists hired by Target Corp.

Target land, previous owned by Lowe's Big Box Store. Half the property is outside the UDB line.

The legal battle against the Lowe's store went way beyond the County Commission, that approved the store outside the UDB.  After an extended fight, in 2009 the State Cabinet finally sided with the Dept. of Community Affairs and environmentalists.  Things are different now. The DCA is a shell of what it once was, folded into another department. I don't think it has the will to mount a fight a second time. We don't have a State Cabinet that would take a stand against our County Commission either. With T Party politicians like Rick Scott and Pam Bondi as members of the Cabinet it looks bad for the environment. We don't know yet what Target is planning, it is just the stench of lobbyists in the air that has me worried this morning.

Wednesday, August 01, 2012

Wayne Rosen and Homestead City Councilman Jimmie Williams ... by gimleteye

Wayne Rosen
The investigation by the Miami-Dade Ethics and Public Trust Commission took an entire year: to decide whether Homestead City Commissioner Jimmie Williams was unduly influenced and "engaged in conflicted or exploitative behavior relating to his business partnership with Wayne Rosen, a real estate developer with extensive land holdings and other economic interests in the Homestead area."

The conclusion (K# 11-090) was, no.

Rosen has a long history of business before the local city government in Homestead and also Miami-Dade County. With various partners, including major developers, he is/was a large land owner of property outside the Urban Development Boundary, including wetlands.

It is curious that Rosen tried to set up Williams in a fast food franchise far from Homestead.


The ethics commission does not explore the notion that a wealthy, savvy business investor like Wayne Rosen would need to diversify his real estate empire by investing in a low-end restaurant serving urban tastes.
Nor did the commission inquire how a sophisticated investor would be "misled" by a third partner, the so-called operator with experience. Rosen, in his deposition to the ethics commission, offered his recollection that the third partner said he owned 17 restaurants but the chain's website only claims to operate 10 restaurants. So this sophisticated investor, Wayne Rosen, was a victim of fraud or simply failed to due diligence? If you believe that, I have a bridge in Brooklyn to sell you.

The ethics commission was not inquiring after Rosen's business practices. It is well known that land speculators in the suburbs are "on the same team". It is all part and parcel of what EOM calls the Growth Machine. After all the mortgage fraud and foreclosures ripping through Homestead -- turning the area into the poster child for ghost suburbs -- one would think that political practices and skating in the gray areas of the law would have taken a breather.

There is a broader context to this disturbing report that exonerates Wiliams. Florida Hometown Democracy -- the state-wide referendum effort by citizens to take land use decisions away from local corruption -- was slapped down by Florida land speculators. As the Miami-Dade ethics investigation shows, any assumption that cooler heads would prevail in its aftermath, and the aftermath of the destruction of the Florida Department of Community Affairs, the state's growth management authority killed off by Gov. Rick Scott in early 2012, would be wrong, wrong, wrong.

It is always about testing the edges, by the Growth Machine, and the edges always can change depending on the political weather. It was a big change in weather when the Growth Machine destroyed the chance of accountability with Florida Hometown Democracy. It was an even bigger change of weather when Florida DCA went the way of the dodo bird, leaving the Growth Machine to have direct access to major changes through local elected officials to land use at the municipal and county level. Wayne Rosen was testing the edges. That's all.

Tuesday, July 31, 2012

A Word to Misguided Judges Endorsed by the Christian Family Coalition. By Geniusofdespair

Anthony Verdugo
The Christian Family Coalition endorsement is a REAL problem for ALL JUDGES AND ALL JUDGE CANDIDATES unless they agree that trashing OTHER judges is acceptable rhetoric.  I really think judges/judge candidates with the Christian Family Coalition Endorsement are misguided and that they should renounce their CFC endorsement and here is why:

In a Press Release from the CFC dated 9/22/2010 (in response to the 3rd DCA opinion upholding Judge Lederman in the Gil adoption case) Anthony Verdugo said:
Corrupt Appeals Judges VIOLATE Oath of Office, Irrationally Attack Law Protectng Children! Florida Voters: Lawless Judges Must Be Impeached!
CFC Verdugo said further in the same press release - as if the above wasn't bad enough:
However, today, corrupt judges on a Third District Court of Appeals panel, Gerald B. Cope Jr., Frank A. Shepherd and Vance E. Salter, intentionally usurped the authority of the Florida State legislature and Florida voters by behaving as if they were "gods" and undemocratically imposing their warped prejudices and personal whims on 18 million Floridians.
How on earth could ANY judge/judge candidate be associated with a group that would say such inflammatory and untrue words against judges over their ruling? The subject of the case is irrelevant. The fact is, the 3 judges were doing their job. How could any judge who claims to be impartial, accept baseless charges against another judge over a ruling they made? The judges being endorsed didn't hear the testimony in the case so how could they put their good name with the CFC that makes baseless claims about other judges' conduct because they make rulings that disagree with CFC? Why would those endorsed ever allow another judge to be maligned - in the context of a ruling - by a group that endorsed them?  How could any judge or judge candidate bear witness to another judge being called 'corrupt' and 'lawless' for their opinion on a case? How could any judge or judge candidate take an endorsement from a group calling for the impeachment of a judge over his or her opinion on a case?

A Note to stupid judges/judge candidates with the CFC endorsement: Let me define corrupt for you --- it means "Having or showing a willingness to act dishonestly in return for money or personal gain."

Do you think Judges Gerald B. Cope Jr., Frank A. Shepherd and Vance E. Salter acted dishonestly and took money or gained anything by their opinion? No?  Do you think they should be impeached? Then how can you take an endorsement by a group that says that they have and they should be? You must stand up for those in your profession that have to make those hard decisions every day, the men and women charged with following the rules of law.

I am calling ON ALL JUDGES and JUDGE CANDIDATES to renounce your CFC endorsement. Don't let this hate group co-opt your reputation and make you appear as hateful as they are. The Christian Family Coalition doesn't  just hate and attack Gay Groups...they hate and attack judges that don't side with their positions too.

I endorse Greer Wallace!

Wednesday, June 27, 2012

All the world in a grain of sand: how the Growth Machine ate the Florida Department of Community Affairs. By Gimleteye

All the world in a grain of sand: How the Growth Machine Ate The Florida Department of Community Affairs
... the following appeared yesterday, on the website Counterpunch. It is a long essay: take your time.


John DeGrove was the father of land use planning in Florida and the principal architect of the state land use agency, the Florida Department of Community Affairs. The agency was established in 1985 to oversee compliance with the Growth Management Act. Most Floridians are unlikely to know either what the Department of Community Affairs did or what its disappearance means. Fewer still understand the challenges to design and implement a regulatory framework for rationale growth and development in one of the nation’s fastest growing states, or, how DCA and DeGrove’s mission was a target of anti-government, pro-property rights zealots from the first.

Why this matters is simple. Presupposing the failure of government regulatory authority virtually guarantees it will happen. The notion that government cannot do anything that private industry can do better, cheaper, and faster including protecting public safety, health and welfare has spread its toxic roots far and wide. Florida provides more than its share of examples of government-designed-to-fail.

These didn’t happen overnight. DCA was caught up in a thirty year war against governmental regulation of land use and the environment. Initially, the agency’s work enjoyed broad bipartisan support. By the time the agency was frog-marched to the platform and guillotined by the Florida legislature and an indifferent governor, it had already mostly surrendered to “regulatory capture” by special interests. When the final blow was delivered, no one was quite so surprised as the insiders to watch decades of history simply wash away.

Thursday, May 17, 2012

The Urban Development Boundary: When is a legal covenant, a promise to be broken at will? by gimleteye

The promise of the Urban Development Boundary is that it would provide some friction slowing the spread of cancerous suburban sprawl to the edge of the beleaguered Everglades. I don't use the term "cancerous", lightly. Sprawl and the devastation of the worst economic crisis since the Great Depression go hand-in-hand. The one could not have occurred without the other.

Local land use policies incorporating the Urban Development Boundary at the fringe of Miami-Dade were created decades ago to protect farmland, open space and the Everglades. A generation of leaders, including then county commissioner Harvey Ruvin, embraced the notion that government can balance economic development with a sustainable environment. It was a high principle that was chipped away, year after year, by low politics and greed.

Until the Republican-led Florida legislature gutted the Growth Management Act this spring, approved by incurious, indifferent Gov. Rick Scott, the Florida Department of Community Affairs provided pressure against local county government from doing what powerful lobbyist/law firms and their speculator clients wanted: strip malls, commercial centers, and platted subdivisions wherever and whenever they could find bank financing.

Judging from the Florida landscape, they got what they wanted. But in Miami-Dade County, for civic activists the presence of the Urban Development Boundary and the fact of the friction against stupid growth it provided was like the tattered flag above Fort Sumter in 1814: "O say can you see, by the dawn's early light ..."

Yesterday's vote by the unreformable majority of the Miami Dade County Commission fulfilled what we predicted here at Eyeonmiami for years: that once state authority for land use policy was removed, the friction inhibiting cancerous sprawl would dissolve like a cube of sugar in a silver pot of hot coffee.

Yesterday's event was monumental. It sent a signal to the speculators that anything goes. Make a covenant, break a covenant.

Mark Woerner, planning chief for Miami Dade County, shrugged to The Miami Herald, "Things change." He meant that statistics used by staff showed a future deficit of housing stock in the specific area of Kendall that includes the Brown property. But everyone knows the county real estate market is a full bore disaster; if there was ever a moment to take a policy position on the the low density scatter sprawl that wrecked the quality of life of Miami Dade County and much of Florida, this was it.

The immediate result of yesterday's vote is "to transmit" the application by the developer to what remains of the DCA: an office in a broom closet at the end of some hallway in Tallahassee. The application will be returned with a stamp of approval: a big smiley face.

To say that things change is disingenuous. The county commission has always been about removing the friction that inhibits big campaign contributors from the speculator community. Nevertheless, things do change. Because the legislature and Gov. Rick Scott used "jobs" as a rationale, growth management is finished. And for county commissioners -- except for Dennis Moss -- the logic goes something like this: if you are going to be in a race to the bottom, you might as well win.


Wednesday, April 18, 2012

Governor Rick Scott and John DeGrove: gone ... by gimleteye

Most Floridians never heard of John DeGrove, who passed away recently at age 87. DeGrove was the father of land use planning in Florida and the principal architect of the state land use agency once called the Florida Department of Community Affairs. In 2011 the DCA, as it was known, vanished through the hand of the Florida legislature and Gov. Rick Scott. DCA provided a line of defense for Floridians against lobbyists and speculators who control local government permitting and zoning decisions. It was a porous line of defense and not at all the "bogeyman" claimed by Associated Industries and other lobbyists.

DeGrove was secretary of the Florida Department of Community Affairs when it was formed in 1985, a state agency created by the Florida legislature. At the time, there was broad recognition by both political parties that Florida's unique quality of life and environment was likely to vanish unless some restraint was imposed by common sense and good planning principles at the state level. From virtually Day One, the agency that John DeGrove led was targeted as an example of over-reaching state authority by developers and speculators.

Nationally, its underlying legislation -- The Growth Management Act -- was hailed as the most forward-thinking effort to responsibly manage and account for growth and development. In the late 1980's, I was an activist in the Florida Keys, learning about the capacity of state law through the Area of Critical State Concern designation application to Monroe County and the requirements of state land use planning that even then had wealthy and influential developers fuming. The Florida Keys were the test tube for land use policies and thresholds like hurricane evacuation time standards. As a result, DCA was set upon by the Great Destroyers from the first-- chipped away and eroded through the influence of special interests and lobbyists. It took an economic calamity to destroy it.

Back then, I believed that voters would come to their senses when overdevelopment in Florida blew up the economy. The storm clouds were on the horizon long before Lehman Brothers collapsed. After all, that was the case in the Great Depression whose children were very much the leaders of the environmental movement at the time: Dagny Johnson, George Kunst, and Grace Maniello in the Keys. In 2010, under the pressure of the withering economic crisis in construction and development-- a crisis largely spurred by over-development that the state agency could have but didn't dare to curtail-- the life accomplishments of John DeGrove were lost to the rage of the Tea Party and the clamor against "bogeymen" like DCA.

In fact, the reverse is true. In key respects, growth management in Florida was a paper tiger. That tiger was useful to the radical right, supported by the Wise Use Movement in the late 1980's, that used Florida as a proving ground for property rights. Their goal-- embraced by Big Sugar and Big Ag-- to push for development wherever and whenever the case could be made and financed that it was only providing "what the free market wants". It is the story of the Keys, of Wellington and Coral Springs, of Orlando and the suburbs of Doral, Sweetwater, West Miami Dade, and Tampa and formerly rural enclaves like Homestead-- where the crack cocaine of the housing boom left a trail of ghost suburbs, crime, and reeling voters who trusted elected officials and now see nothing but destruction in their wakes.

With the perspective of history, from the beginning of DeGrove's time of influence in policies regulating Florida sprawl, it was one step forward and two steps back. Under a Democrat, Governor Lawton Chiles, growth management had a small window of opportunity to regulate the loss of Everglades wetlands to sprawl in Broward County. Its failure set the stage for ascendency of growth-at-any-cost policies of Governor Jeb Bush and, eventually, the collapse of federal resolve too.

DeGrove was as powerful as the political will of legislatures to support laws and rules that had been carefully worked out by that earlier, wiser generation of Florida's leaders. The power of money, even after the worst economic collapse since the Great Depression, was too great. In a time of diminished capacity of the mainstream media to investigate and to report, what happened in the inner clock-springs of agencies fated to influence Florida's quality of life and environment were relegated to hotel conference rooms hosting planning events, the rubbing of shoulders and interests, the revolving door between regulated and regulators as though no one cared.

Today, Florida's voters are shell-shocked and misled by arguments that growth management is a "jobs killer". What would they know?

The erosion of federal and state authority to protect our quality of life and environment pushes permitting and zoning decisions straight onto the backs of local officials. It is at the level of local city and county commissions where the Great Destroyers always could use their advantages through a diseased campaign finance system to exert leverage.

All the structures to keep the public good in view were rickety and jerry-rigged and held together by the slimmest of legal thresholds requiring citizen activists to test again and again in lengthy, exhausting and costly administrative court challenges. Now they have been torn down to be replaced by something new, that already looks like what always has been. We see how this works out at the Miami-Dade Urban Development Boundary and the careful planning of the Great Destroyers to again test; searching for the new limits same way tiger sharks use the murk to probe the vulnerability of prey. The extension of the Dolphin Expressway into lands owned by politically influential local power brokers, the exchange of lands and speculation in the Bird Drive Basin and South Miami Dade: these are all concrete examples.

Still, gratitude is owed to DeGrove and to land use planners who attempt to maintain the highest standards of their profession against fraud above their pay grades. Had Governor Rick Scott ever heard of John DeGrove before he bought his way to the Governor's Mansion? Is he even aware of what growth management is, now? DeGrove could tell you if he were still alive: it's gone.