Monday, October 30, 2017

South Miami: Is Sunset Place Failing (Again)? ... by gimleteye

This is my neighborhood. I've followed the development of South Miami since the early days of the Bakery Center, in the late 1980s. One of the most important reasons used by developers to approve Sunset Place, and later, the design charrette approving the zoning plan for South Miami, was the prohibition against large-scale development. Put another way, the incentive for taxpayers/voters/citizens is now being dissolved twenty years later. This is how it goes in Florida: no measure to build sustainable growth into the landscape is ever secure. It's a constant battle against shifting baselines, moving goal posts, and greed. Decision makers and elected officials count on the public losing track, inattention and apathy. Judged by current results who can argue their success? The following, from a concerned citizen:
The City of South Miami is fast-tracking a 16 story development where the Shops at Sunset are located on the corners of Red Road (57th Avenue) and Sunset (72 Street) and South Dixie Highway (U.S. 1). A develop company owns the land and has already taken the plan before the South Miami City Planning Board. Forty people from the company were there in force with their “Yes”� buttons, their slicked down regalia, power point presentations, etc., etc.....the color of money was everywhere. The complex will be the usual: shops, a hotel, condos and office space. It is obvious what such a complex will do to traffic at Red and Sunset, not to mention Red and Dixie, a choke point, as it is now. In Coral Gables I observed two buildings--one looming behind the other. Now the 9 story building (I counted) was high enough, but to see the 16 story building towering over it was like looking at some dark image of Gotham. 16 stories really is high. In South Miami's 2 and 3 story environment, it will appear even higher, like some priapic shaft reaching towards the heavens. In short, it will look ridiculous.

There will be a few more hearings before the South Miami Commission votes. But one has only to look at Coral Gables, Brickell, the Condo Canyons in Sunrise or inch down any road during rush hour to know that things have a way of happening in South Florida. I don't know what the solution is. There is a gathering for Mayor Stoddard in Pinecrest this coming Wednesday (see below), a good venue to let him know that not every one agrees with this vision of South Miami. I will eventually be in New Zealand where the traffic runs at a sane pace and the word “zoning”� still means something. But being someone who is not of a sadistic nature, I still wish the best for South Miami.

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

This train has left the station. It is a failure.

Anonymous said...

DEVELOPMENT US 1= GRIDLOCK

Anonymous said...

Yes let's have businesses die and our community suffer because there might be additional traffic, which according to the traffic specialist at the meeting (you obviously weren't there) and South Miami staff there will not be negative impacts. Anti-development people need to find a new argument because you can't keep stopping progress in South Miami because you scare people with traffic. On a similar note, a hotel, residences and office space brings foot traffic without car traffic. I live in South Miami and it is awful to see what is happening to our downtown and business owners. So sorry if I am willing to have some height to help these people and I imagine driving by it once a day won't kill you either. Give me a break.

Anonymous said...

I also am a "concerned citizen". I live .29 miles from this development, on the south side of S. Dixie. Unlike the "concerned citizen" who penned the above, I am not moving to New Zealand. I am not on the payroll of the developers or anyone else associated with the project.

I'm dumbfounded by most of the opposition. I can understand tweaking some of the details of this project. I can't understand blanket condemnation of almost anything being proposed for the Bakery Center and downtown South Miami.

This seems to be exactly the kind of redevelopment we need. It is across from Metrorail and abuts S Dixie which is where the 16-story buildings are planned.

This place is on life support. It is dragging down a lot of downtown with it. The Coral Gables business district to the east of Red Road also is looking pretty shabby.

Don't we want a vibrant downtown area? Or we want a ghost town so people yearning for the good ole days can find on-street parking instead of having to go to a garage or valet?

Remember, this serves as "downtown" for not just South Miami, but also South Coral Gables, Pinecrest, Palmetto Bay and the unincorporated areas to the southeast and southwest.

What do opponents suggest be built there instead? Nothing?

I eagerly await your suggestions.

Anonymous said...

Hey there, I've been following the development too. Traffic studies have been conducted and it has been determined that no add'l traffic will be added during peak hours, is there any information you have that I should know? Also, I was at that meeting you mentioned, neither I nor anybody I went with are associated with the developers, not an attack, just wanted to point that out. In terms of sustainable growth, what alternative to this project would you suggest? It seems to me that this is actually a great way to achieve sustainable growth. I look forward to your response, have a great day!

Anonymous said...

Are you screening comments so you can propel a false narrative? That is sad, you should want to discuss these things publicly.

Anonymous said...

"According to the traffic specialist at the meeting (you obviously weren't there) and South Miami staff there will not be negative impacts." Hilarious. The same can be, and has been, said for every development. So where is all the traffic coming from?

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

Can I tell you what I envision for South Miami? Cobblestone street from Sunset and US 1 to 57th Avenue - no car traffic, only foot and bicycle traffic. Convert the Sunset Place architecture into that of a cottage, or multiple cottages. Change the entire facade of the stores and restaurants in that area into a street full of cottage fronts. Let's fill the streets with art stores, quaint restaurants, antique stores. Make that block in South Miami be "Main Street USA"... you know, like the feel of what one gets when visiting Mt. Dora, Disney, European cities. It would be the city where people want to come to "get away" from the rest of Miami. Anyhow, thanks for letting me share my dream of the city of pleasant living...it would be very pleasant...people would be very nice and smile and be courteous.

Anonymous said...

Oh...and there would not be a hotel...but an inn...a lovely B&B. Thanks