Showing posts sorted by relevance for query dca. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query dca. Sort by date Show all posts

Tuesday, May 10, 2011

1000 Friends of Florida offers its analysis of the Frankenstein Environmental Destruction Bill ... by gimleteye

The land speculators who wrecked Miami Dade County and county politics through their obsession with rezoning wetlands and farmland for suburban sprawl have been hoisting the Crystal and Moet since the close of the legislative session: they got what they wanted -- the chance to drive a stake through the heart of environmental protections in Florida but especially here, where the Urban Development Boundary prevented them from recouping losses suffered through massive purchases of land outside the UDB at the height of the housing bubble. Here is an interesting post from the blog, Homestead Is Home: that the crime rate in the most scavenged areas of the county, where ghost suburbs are the rule thanks to the influence of builders and developers who influenced the city and county commissions to get what they wanted, is off the charts in comparison to other similarly sized and located cities. 
Although there is no demand for housing or construction, the builders and developers in the Florida legislature used the economic crisis to undo decades of efforts to restrain unwise growth. It seems Florida's motto is, "Fail and Fail Again."


Preliminary Outline of the Growth Management Bill 7207.   SB 2156 includes the “restructuring”  of the Dept. of Community Affairs.  (1000 Friends of Florida prepared the following outline. Explanatory comments in blue for those not familiar with some of the terms used were provided by Sierra Club.)

Monday, March 23, 2009

Orlando Sentinel: Florida's Next House Speaker is behind evisceration of Growth Management in Florida

You know, the frequent and excellent editorials from the Orlando Sentinel, whose corporate parent is operating out of bankruptcy, makes me wonder why the Miami Herald can't also print hard hitting editorials on the disaster-that-calls-itself-The Florida Legislature. I'm getting close to giving up my subscription to the Herald ...

OrlandoSentinel.com

We think: Rep. Cannon and his allies should abandon nonsensical attack on DCA

March 23, 2009

It's the greatest work of fiction to come out of the Legislature this session. It goes like this: Florida needs the bills that would abolish or dismantle the agency regulating growth, the bills' proponents say, because they'd save the state tons of money, remove a lot of bureaucratic clutter while preserving regulatory principles and help rejuvenate the state's moribund economy.

We'd sooner believe what we read in Tolkien or Grimms' fairy tales.

Florida does have 300,000 vacant homes, a glut spurred by the global credit crunch that also has slowed construction of new homes. But blaming the Department of Community Affairs for that state of affairs is sheer nonsense.

Particularly so because even in this economy, even with DCA, developers and governments keep pitching grandiose and oftentimes grotesque plans that they say are necessary for Florida's future.

Behemoths like Destiny, a new city of 100,000 people at Yeehaw Junction in a desolate stretch of Osceola County.

And embarrassments like Innovation Way East, which would deposit another 10,000 homes on almost 4,600 acres four miles east of Orlando. That's on top of 20,000 homes Orange County commissioners already approved in the area.

In fact, DCA's as active as ever. It reviews 8,000 to 10,000 amendments to local growth plans a year. Since 2008, amendments have involved 410,000 acres and 630,000 residential units.

Far from being a cumbersome, redundant bureaucracy, DCA often is the only backstop to local governments running roughshod over those growth plans and other laws intended to guard the state's imperiled wildlife, watersheds and environmental jewels.

Just last year, it pushed back outrageous plans from a developer to build an oversized marina in an aquatic preserve on the St. Johns River in Volusia County, home to manatees. DeBary officials appeared ready to swallow it whole.

DCA stood ready to rein in Orange County's plans for Innovation Way East, which the county wanted to grease by bypassing local land-use, employment and environmental rules.

And DCA recently helped shape rules preserving eagle habitat and wildlife corridors for large developments near Lake Tohopekaliga in Osceola County. It also continues to steer development from the Green Swamp, more than 500,000 environmentally sensitive acres in Lake and Polk counties.

Heathrow Rep. Chris Dorworth says the bill he voted for in a House committee, which would transfer DCA's responsibilities for reviewing local growth plans to the Department of State, wouldn't strip away growth management principles. Please.

It would have a department that oversees elections — no great track record there — watch over the state's growth. We fear — and expect — it wouldn't do much more than that: Watch.

Lawmakers also are seeking to hack funding for growth management so that staff reviewing amendments to local plans — whether as part of DCA or the Department of State — would drop by half. That might save the state a couple of million dollars — hardly patching the hole in the state's $6 billion budget deficit.

It would, however, let loose developers to do most anything they want to millions of acres Floridians say they don't want transformed.

The bills "provide a healthy re-examination" of DCA's role, says Winter Park's Dean Cannon, the House's next speaker and the de facto force behind a makeover or rollover of DCA.

But there's nothing healthy, Mr. Cannon, about doing away with DCA.

Thursday, January 27, 2011

"History tells different story on growth woes" ... by gimleteye

The weekend editorial from the Key West Citizen is well worth reading in Miami-Dade. Although we are the sprawl capital of the Americas, the limited terrain of the Florida Keys provided the state with its first taste of growth management conflicts. It was my experience fighting land use battles in the Keys in the late 1980's that prepared me for twenty years of scrapping here. You didn't need to be clairvoyant to predict that land speculators and the assorted interests of the Growth Machine would run the economy off the rails. This view may gain traction with the release of the Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission that blames-- as I have written both here on Eyeonmiami and Counterpunch-- that "the ownership society" and its hucksters bear full responsibility for the housing market crash and subsequent carnage. Writ small in the Florida Keys, the damage from the housing boom and bust is astounding. But instead of a fair reckoning, what the Florida legislature and Gov. Rick Scott are preparing to do is to eviscerate the one management agency that is charged with supervising growth management, the Florida Department of Community Affairs. In their bankrupt world view, "regulations" are responsible for the economic crisis. This is the point to pick up and read in the Key West Citizen, "Before the new kids on the block get a chance to rewrite history, we want to defend Florida's Department of Community Affairs (DCA)." (click, 'read more')

This week, in an appearance before Associated Press editors and reporters, Gov. Rick Scott said he hasn't yet decided about merging the DCA with the Department of Transportation (DOT) and Department of Environmental Protection (DEP).

The governor's transition team pitched that idea as a way to streamline the state regulatory process and speed up Florida's economic recovery.

Inherent in the argument for abolishing DCA is the belief that the agency has held back development, costing the state construction jobs.

Anyone who's spent any time living or even driving through Miami-Dade, Broward, and Palm Beach counties, or that interstate snarl that is the Orlando-Tampa-St. Pete axis would laugh out loud.

Held back? Who are they kidding?

In fact, before moving into the Governor's Mansion in Tallahassee, Scott lived in Naples. Naples, along with neighboring Fort Meyers, serves as a classic warning about the impact of uncontrolled over-development.

Acres of subdivided land sit idle, a few stray houses serve as testament to rampant greed. Banks and car dealerships went under, commercial office space sits empty and roads to nowhere dead-end at subdivisions that never broke ground beyond the fancy sales office out front.

Lee County has the highest rate of foreclosures in the eastern United States.

If the DCA was such an effective brake on Florida development, how does one explain all those foreclosed homes and empty commercial properties that pockmark the state?

Here's what the governor told the media in Tallahassee this week: "We clearly need growth management, but we've got to do growth management in a way that is not merely slowing things down and killing jobs."

There it is again - rewriting history to fit the story line.

It wasn't the DCA "slowing things down" that killed Florida's construction jobs, it was easy-money financing that allowed developers and builders to borrow obscene amounts of money and speculate on the premise of ever-increasing real estate riches.

Buyers were led down the garden path to no-down financing on loans they couldn't afford, especially after teaser rates morphed into serious money.

And everyone bet that real estate was an ever-upward spiral, a mistake that proved the downfall of the whole circus.

The fast money to finance this economic engine dried up - that's what killed all those jobs in construction, mortgage finance, real estate sales.

Don't blame the DCA. They were the folks holding the rope, trying to keep the elephants from stampeding through the Big Top.

Tom Pelham, the DCA's outgoing secretary, didn't stick around for Scott's swearing in to exit his threatened agency.

Before the new players rewrite Florida history, here's what Pelham said in defense of DCA: "The same basic growth-management system that is under attack now was in place during one of Florida's longest and biggest economic boom periods.

"DCA and the growth-management system did not prevent the real-estate bubble, they did not cause the bubble to burst and they will not prevent recovery."

Wednesday, October 08, 2008

SORENSON'S RESOLUTIONS: The shit will be hitting the fan at Vile Natacha Seijas' Committee Meeting. By Geniusofdespair

On October 14th Katy Sorenson has two items on the agenda that should have sparks flying (especially if Natacha has recovered from her surgery and attends). Both relate to the Department of Community Affairs rejection of the unreformable majority's vote moving the Urban Development Boundary for two applications. The DCA found them both "not in compliance." The ordinances basically recommend that the County Commission, to avoid costly legal fees, return the subject properties to their prior designations of “Open Land and “Agriculture” or at the very least, that the Mayor/County Manager negotiate with the State to reach a settlement.

Here are the two proposed ordinances in their entirety:

082376
TITLE
RESOLUTION DIRECTING COUNTY MAYOR OR DESIGNEE TO NEGOTIATE SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT TO RESOLVE PENDING DISPUTE OVER APRIL 2007-08 CYCLE APPLICATIONS TO AMEND THE COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT MASTER PLAN (CDMP) AND TO PRESENT SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT TO BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS FOR APPROVAL ACCORDING TO PROCEDURES SET FORTH IN SECTION 163.3184, FLORIDA STATUTES

BODY
WHEREAS, Applications No. 5 and No. 8 of the April 2007-08 Cycle applications to amend the Miami-Dade County Comprehensive Development Master Plan (CDMP) proposed expanding the Urban Development Boundary (UDB) to add the properties that were the subjects of those applications to the urbanized area and to redesignate the subject properties as follows: for Application No. 5, from “Open Land” to “Business and Office” and “Institutions, Utilities, and Communications”; and, for Application No. 8, from “Agriculture” to “Business and “Office”; and
WHEREAS, on April 24, 2008, this Board adopted Ordinances No. 08-44 and No. 08-45, taking final action to adopt Applications No. 5 and No. 8, respectively, to approve the expansion of the UDB and the redesignation of the subject properties, and to accept restrictive covenants in connection therewith; and
WHEREAS, the Florida Department of Community Affairs (DCA) has issued a Statement of Intent (SOI) and Notice of Intent (NOI) to find the adopted Applications No. 5 and No. 8 “not in compliance” with the applicable laws; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 163.3184(10), Fla. Stat., DCA has commenced an administrative proceeding styled Department of Community Affairs v. Miami-Dade County, Case No. 08-3614GM, before an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) of the Florida Division of Administrative Hearings, at the conclusion of which the ALJ will issue a recommended order to the Administration Commission addressing whether the adopted Applications No. 5 and No. 8 are “in compliance” with the applicable laws; and
WHEREAS, various third parties have intervened in the administrative proceeding, both for and against the adopted Applications No. 5 and No. 8, and some of the intervenors have not only adopted DCA’s objections but have also lodged additional objections; and
WHEREAS, in prior matters, such litigation has proved to be complex, costly, and time-consuming, requiring substantial commitment of staff resources and out-of-pocket expenses; and
WHEREAS, in the SOI, DCA recommended, to remedy the alleged lack of compliance, that the County “rescind the Future Land Use Map amendments associated with Ordinance Numbers 08-44 and 08-45”; and
WHEREAS, in a difficult budget year, this Board must make difficult decisions about how to best allocate limited resources; and
WHEREAS, extended litigation in this matter is not in the current best interests of the County, and the Board wishes to avoid the expense, delay, and uncertainty of lengthy litigation and instead desires to proceed through a Settlement Agreement process; and
WHEREAS, section 163.3184(16) of the Florida Statutes sets forth a process for DCA and a local government to enter into a settlement agreement to resolve a dispute concerning whether a CDMP amendment is “in compliance,”
NOW, THERFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA, that this Board hereby directs the County Mayor or designee to negotiate a proposed settlement agreement that would return the subject properties of Applications No. 5 and No. 8 of the April 2007 Cycle applications to amend the Miami-Dade County Comprehensive Development Master Plan (CDMP) to their prior designations of “Open Land and “Agriculture,” respectively, with the Florida Department of Community Affairs and all other parties necessary for a full and final resolution of the administrative proceeding styled Department of Community Affairs v. Miami-Dade County, Case No. 08-3614GM. This Board further directs the Mayor or designee to present the proposed negotiated agreement to this Board for approval in accordance with the procedures set forth in Section 163.3184, Fla. Stat.

082731
TITLE
RESOLUTION URGING THE FLORIDA DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY AFFAIRS TO NEGOTIATE WITH MIAMI-DADE COUNTY IN AN EFFORT TO RESOLVE THE PENDING DISPUTE OVER THE APRIL 2007-08 CYCLE APPLICATIONS TO AMEND THE COMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT MASTER PLAN (CDMP) INCLUDING THE OPTION OF RETURNING THESE TWO PARCELS TO THEIR ORIGINAL DESIGNATIONS

BODY
WHEREAS, Applications No. 5 and No. 8 of the April 2007-08 Cycle applications to amend the Miami-Dade County Comprehensive Development Master Plan (CDMP) proposed expanding the Urban Development Boundary (UDB) to add the properties that were the subjects of those applications to the urbanized area and to redesignate the subject properties as follows: for Application No. 5, from “Open Land” to “Business and Office” and “Institutions, Utilities, and Communications”; and, for Application No. 8, from “Agriculture” to “Business and “Office”; and
WHEREAS, on April 24, 2008, this Board adopted Ordinances No. 08-44 and No. 0845, taking final action to adopt Applications No. 5 and No. 8, respectively, to approve the expansion of the UDB and the redesignation of the subject properties, and to accept restrictive covenants in connection therewith; and
WHEREAS, the Florida Department of Community Affairs (DCA) has issued a Statement of Intent (SOI) and Notice of Intent (NOI) to find the adopted Applications No. 5 and No. 8 “not in compliance” with the applicable laws; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 163.3184(10), Fla. Stat., DCA has commenced an administrative proceeding styled Department of Community Affairs v. Miami-Dade County, Case No. 08-3614GM, before an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) of the Florida Division of Administrative Hearings, at the conclusion of which the ALJ will issue a recommended order to the Administration Commission addressing whether the adopted Applications No. 5 and No. 8 are “in compliance” with the applicable laws; and
WHEREAS, various third parties have intervened in the administrative proceeding, both for and against the adopted Applications No. 5 and No. 8, and some of the intervenors have not only adopted DCA’s objections but have also lodged additional objections; and
WHEREAS, in a difficult budget year, this Board must make difficult decisions about how to best allocate limited resources; and
WHEREAS, extended litigation in this matter is not in the current best interests of the County, and the Board wishes to avoid the expense, delay, and uncertainty of litigation by pursuing settlement negotiations with DCA; and
WHEREAS, section 163.3184(16) of the Florida Statutes sets forth a process for DCA and a local government to enter into a settlement agreement to resolve a dispute concerning whether a CDMP amendment is “in compliance”,
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS OF MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA, that this Board:
Section 1. Urges the Florida Department of Community Affairs to negotiate with Miami-Dade County through the Mayor or designee in an effort to resolve the pending dispute over the April 2007-08 cycle applications to amend the Comprehensive Development Master Plan (CDMP) including the option of returning these two parcels to their original designations.
Section 2. Directs the Clerk of the Board to transmit a certified copy of this resolution to the Secretary of the Florida Department of Community Affairs.

Wednesday, June 27, 2012

All the world in a grain of sand: how the Growth Machine ate the Florida Department of Community Affairs. By Gimleteye

All the world in a grain of sand: How the Growth Machine Ate The Florida Department of Community Affairs
... the following appeared yesterday, on the website Counterpunch. It is a long essay: take your time.


John DeGrove was the father of land use planning in Florida and the principal architect of the state land use agency, the Florida Department of Community Affairs. The agency was established in 1985 to oversee compliance with the Growth Management Act. Most Floridians are unlikely to know either what the Department of Community Affairs did or what its disappearance means. Fewer still understand the challenges to design and implement a regulatory framework for rationale growth and development in one of the nation’s fastest growing states, or, how DCA and DeGrove’s mission was a target of anti-government, pro-property rights zealots from the first.

Why this matters is simple. Presupposing the failure of government regulatory authority virtually guarantees it will happen. The notion that government cannot do anything that private industry can do better, cheaper, and faster including protecting public safety, health and welfare has spread its toxic roots far and wide. Florida provides more than its share of examples of government-designed-to-fail.

These didn’t happen overnight. DCA was caught up in a thirty year war against governmental regulation of land use and the environment. Initially, the agency’s work enjoyed broad bipartisan support. By the time the agency was frog-marched to the platform and guillotined by the Florida legislature and an indifferent governor, it had already mostly surrendered to “regulatory capture” by special interests. When the final blow was delivered, no one was quite so surprised as the insiders to watch decades of history simply wash away.

Friday, January 30, 2009

More on The Lowe's Big Box Hearing. By Geniusofdespair

This was submitted to me and I am posting it as requested:

The hearing before an administrative law judge of The State Of Florida Department of Community Affairs (DCA) versus Miami-Dade County (MDC) concluded Thursday in Miami. The DCA challenged the approval of two projects beyond the Urban Development Boundary (UDB). In this hearing, several people and organizations were part of the the case as intervenors (supporters) for each side.

Mrs. Karen Esty and Mr. Barry J. White were intervenors of behalf of the DCA. Mayor Michael Pizzi, Mayor of Miami Lakes, represented them pro bono in this case and the entire community should be grateful for his time and effort. 

The community should also be grateful to the DCA for pursuing and prosecuting this case aggressively and competently on its behalf; we do have friends in Tallahassee. Mr. Mike McDaniel of the DCA must be specially recognized for his informed and vigorous pleadings and his understanding of the problems we are facing and his work to bring rational growth to our County.

Summation arguments were not permitted at the end of the hearing but Mr. White had prepared a statement in case they were allowed. Here is that statement:

DOAH Case No. 08-003614GM   Judge B.D.E. Canter
DCA vs MDC Hearing January 28-29, 2009  Miami, FL
Summation Statement of DCA Intervenor Barry J. White
 
Judge Canter, Karen Esty and I are speaking on behalf of the two and a half million residents of Miami-Dade County. Our quality of life and the viability of our water supply are at stake in these matters. We are living in a fragile ecosystem on a limited spit land stuck between the Atlantic Ocean and the Everglades, land which is becoming as stressed as its residents. This pivotal hearing is one of the most important and critical in the history of growth in this county.
 
The two projects under review represent more than just zoning issues. If either one is approved it will permit the camel to get its nose under the tent, to start an avalanche of building requests beyond the current UDB.  The proposed projects do not represent or fulfill any urgent or transcending need and certainly do not merit ignoring existing planning guidelines. Currently, there are major efforts to have the existing UDB permanently fixed so the movement to the next proposed limit of the boundary will not be unchallenged  and is not assured.
 
We have limited land. We are encroaching on the unique Everglades and its survival is not certain. We have limited water. We are on permanent water rationing. In January 2007 the Director of the South Florida Water Management District said, “If Miami-Dade keeps pulling (water) from the Biscayne Aquifer, salt water will gradually seep into the Everglades, destroying the environment and the drinking supply”.  He threatened a building moratorium. A movement to zero or limited growth is possible.
 
The Lowes Project, in addition to introducing construction into an environmentally sensitive virgin area, will pave over more of our land undermining and challenging our water supply and our ecosystem. Current research is showing that flora absorbs contaminants from an underlying aquifer. Lowes is putting profit before human and natural concerns.
 
Our roads are beyond capacity and we cannot commit any more land to roadways which urban expansion would require.
 
No developmental impact fees EVER cover the full long range costs of bringing new infrastructure to a project. Miami-Dade County has not increased its impact fees in fourteen years. If we build in new areas funds will have to be drawn from projects and services in other parts of the county.  We do not oppose rational growth. However, the proper course is urban infill such as we have seen along Coral Way east of SW 37 Avenue and along U.S. 1 in south county where responsible developers have creatively re-fashioned older areas which already have the necessary infrastructure, are close to transportation, shopping and services and where water, sewage, drainage, roads and schools are already concurrent.
 
There is a new economic reality in the nation and especially here in South Florida, We must shepherd the use of our limited financial resources as carefully as we protect our limited natural resources.
 
We cannot take any more land out of agriculture in Miami-Dade County, as the Brown project would do, without causing the demise of the industry. We are at the absolute minimum of the 55,000 acres of critical mass of contiguous land in agriculture required to maintain the supporting functional  infrastructure for the industry. In addition, degradation of the ecosystem is threatening the existence of an economic mainstay, sport fishing, in South Florida and the Keys.
 
We must learn to make do with the water we can count on and to live on the land which has already been designated for habitation and commerce. We cannot support or survive unbridled population growth and the paving over of paradise. Re-development, re-design, rational growth, and urban infill must take the place of urban expansion or we will kill our Golden Goose.
 
To preserve the quality of life in Miami Dade County, on behalf of its 2 ½ million residents, we ask that the considered recommendations of the Department of Community Affairs of the State of Florida, the Department of Planning and Zoning of Miami-Dade County, and the Mayor of Miami-Dade County be followed and that the Brown and Lowes building projects be denied.  

Wednesday, May 04, 2011

Assault on environment led by the ill-informed, shortsighted ... by gimleteye

In the Orlando Sentinel, Scott Maxwell has it exactly right: legislators in Tallahassee are caught in a tidal wave of ignorance. While he suggests "taking names", he won't name, names. Carpet baggers like Barney Bishop of Associated Industries and the hoi polloi of Florida's business community who won't stand up for reason, even though their predecessors and, yes, even Republican leaders in the past had the good sense not to throw Florida's environmental protections under the bus. But on this important point, we can definitely agree: Miami-Dade state legislators are simply not held to account by voters for taking positions that are so antithetical to the public interest: Exhibit A, the destruction of the state planning agency, the Florida Department of Community Affairs. Who can argue that the Urban Development Boundary is a bad thing? Land speculators. Period. Who can argue that the Miami-Dade County Commission isn't fully committed to weaseling out of requirements to protect the UDB according to state law? No one. Unfortunately, none of our local mass market media pays attention to what our state legislators do, during session. They can't afford to. And are we ever paying the price.

Scott Maxwell TAKING NAMES

In a moment, I'm going to tell you about plans to gut one of Florida's key environmental programs — one meant to safeguard everything from manatees to the seafood you eat.

The program is cheap. Its effectiveness has been touted by politicians on both sides of the aisle. Yet, Florida politicians are trying to degrade it as we speak.
But first, I want to offer you a window into the mind of your typical state legislator.

It's a scary place. But if we're going to deal with those who are trying to take Florida back to the Dark Ages, we must understand how they think.

Our subject is state Rep. Chris Dorworth.

Six months ago, the Lake Mary Republican met with the Orlando Sentinel's editorial board to try to score a campaign endorsement.

During the meeting, the ed board was trying to understand why Dorworth wanted to dismantle the Department of Community Affairs, the agency charged with ensuring sensible land planning.

The agency had thrived under governors ranging from Bob Graham to Jeb Bush, with all of them touting DCA as a guard for both residents and the land.

But Dorworth thought DCA was a problem. He claimed the agency constantly blocked wonderful and sensible projects.

Really? The ed board asked for an example.

"There have been numerous examples," he replied.

OK. So how about you name one of them?

"I think every single time they work on anything," Dorworth continued. "They kick back plans all the time."

Then it should be easy for you to cite one.

"Listen, I'm not going to tell you whether a project has merit or not," Dorworth responded (right after saying DCA was constantly blocking projects with merit). "I'm going to tell you that DCA has shut down several projects."

So DCA was busy killing projects "all the time." There were "numerous examples." Yet the man wanting to undermine DCA couldn't cite a single one.

This, my friends, is what passes for leadership in your state.

Facts, logic and our natural resources are becoming casualties of an ideological war.

Thursday, April 23, 2009

Florida Real Estate News: The End is Near / The End Probably isn't Near ... by gimleteye

When Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner spoke to the Economic Club in Washington yesterday and said the United States bears a substantial share of responsibility for a global economic crisis and its multi-trillion dollar costs, he might have pointedly singled out the epicenter of the housing market crash-- the state of Florida-- where the absence of regulations governing financial derivatives matched laws designed to fail: in particular, regulations protecting the public from the excesses of suburban sprawl.

Official pronouncements from White House officials are still far from informative. Geithner said, "Never before in modern times has so much of the world been simultaneously hit by a confluence of economic and financial turmoil such as we are now living through." Yes, well. Neither Geithner, nor President Obama, seem interested to explain how much turmoil and loss originates from the culture of deception expressed through this formula: that increase in tax base through construction and housing in new, low density "communities" is the primary purpose of government. Never mind the end result whether measured by foreclosures, a declining quality of life, degraded environment, standard of living, and a permanent, immoveable incumbency welded to the interests of production home builders, cement manufacturers, their lobbyists, engineering firms, and trade associations.

This culture is not humbled or bowed by hubris. Far from it, it has states like Florida in a vise grip. These interests are also joined by the state's other big industry: agriculture and land speculation. Here is an contrast from recent news in Florida that helps illustrate these points. In the St. Augustine Record, the preturnaturally sunny Gov. Charlie Crist pumps up the state's economy: "Florida has seen home sales grow by 20 percent over the past year... "Home sales nationwide are up 5.1 percent... and in Lee County in Southwest Florida, once Ground Zero for foreclosures, sales are up 90 percent. If I had money, I'd put it into Florida real estate." (St. Augustine Record, April 17, 2009) Crist is ready to declare the recession over and the race he plans to join to be the next US senator from Florida, complete.

In the New York Times David Leonhardt has another perspective, grounded in another reality. He reports on a Miami foreclosure auction recently where homes" ... sold for just a fraction of what they would have even a year ago. The rate of decline in Miami hasn’t even slowed noticeably in recent months, according to data kept by Real Estate Disposition Corporation, known as R.E.D.C., which runs the auctions." A recently transplanted New Yorker named Michael Houtkin won the bidding on a one-bedroom condominium on the outskirts of Boca Raton, a few blocks from three golf courses, for the incredible price of $30,000. “Things were almost being given away,” he said later.

Out with the old, in with the new.

The St. Pete Times reports, rising from the rubble that is still falling: "A development boom is brewing under the radar of Floridians distracted by deteriorating real estate values and record foreclosures. The state is processing an unprecedented number of proposals for new homes and commercial development. If approved, these projects could pump more than 600,000 rooftops onto a market suffering from a surplus of product and slowdown in population growth." (Florida Builders poised to pounce, April 17, 2009) Crist "said increases in real estate sales have come at the same time property taxes are going down, sweetening the market. Property insurance rates have also dropped by 18 percent in the past two years. "There are bright days ahead," Crist said. It is not clear if those bright days include the forecast for US banks that are being pressured to write down "toxic" derivative debt tied to mortgages, ten cents to the dollar, while being forced to make loans for new housing at one hundred cents to the dollar, and at the same time private equity is redeeming credit default swaps-- bets against the market--at par.

Again, the New York Times: "... Fannie Mae, like many banks, is inundated with foreclosed properties. In recent weeks, banks have begun accelerating foreclosures again, after having held off while waiting to find out which homeowners would be eligible for the Obama administration’s assistance program. The glut of foreclosed homes creates a self-reinforcing cycle. Falling prices lead to more foreclosures. Foreclosures lead to an excess supply of homes for sale. The excess supply then leads to further price declines."

Today, the Florida legislature is speeding a new bill toward Gov. Crist's desk to eliminate the pesky business of growth management, by eliminating the Florida Department of Community Affairs, the state agency that regulates growth. In last year's legislative session, the DCA budget was slashed to the bone. The remaining officials are literally like the last soldiers at the Alamo. The St. Pete Times reports, "When the department recently pulled together data on all major developments pending and approved since 2007, the totals were staggering: projects covering 410,126 acres, with a potential for 630,965 new homes and 479.5 million square feet of non-residential space. "This really catches me by surprise," said Denslow, who is with the University of Florida's Bureau of Economic and Business Research. "I'll have to revise my thinking." As to the market, the Palm Beach Post notes today, "... the state's official people-counters expect that Palm Beach County will follow up its first negative-growth year in decades - a loss of 4,379 people - with further declines through 2010." That is just one Florida county. "The county's 2010 population projection is expected to be 70,000 fewer residents than predicted just two years ago. The updated projection for 2025 is down 16 percent in Palm Beach County, 13.5 percent in Martin and 8 percent in St. Lucie. The figures from the University of Florida's Bureau of Economic and Business Research are the official state population projections, used to divvy up state revenue. Declines like this haven't been seen since the 1940s." ('The Population Battle", Palm Beach Post, April 23, 2009)

Speaking of revised thinking, The Augustine Record reports, "In his real estate percentages, Crist was actually conservative. Realtor Ed Paucek cited figures from the Florida Association of Realtors that indicate the state's increase is really 27 percent, not 20. And Lee County's sales were up 97 percent, not 90 as Crist said. "Sales in the Greater Jacksonville area, which includes St. Augustine, are up 6 percent," Paucek said. "Fort Myers' sales, though higher, are down 50 percent in dollar value. Here, sales are down 11 percent in dollar value. But that's a good indicator of stability. We're obviously not rising as quick as some (counties), but also not losing as much value."

The end is near. The end probably isn't near. For Jennifer Seney, an environmental activist who lives in Wesley Chapel, overdevelopment is not an abstract threat. "In her Pasco neighborhood, about one-third of the houses are for sale. Home prices are down 27 percent from a year ago. The Cypress Creek well field, on which Seney's home depends for water, is bordered on all but one side by residential development. Now the county wants to put more than 4,000 homes on the untapped portion. "It's like we can't win against this force of money and greed," Seney said. "I'm just sitting here waiting for my well to go dry." (St. Pete Times, cited above.)

Moreover, the fiscal stimulus trillions are being used by the status quo to build hardened bunkers against reality's bunker-busting bombs. Today, at the very same time the Florida legislature is humping for the Growth Machine, another new bill aimed at suppressing Florida voters --hand delivered to the legislature by Miami state senator Alex Diaz de la Portilla and Growth Machine lobbyists-- is moving at lightning speed. The bill was allowed six minutes debate in committee. It would: expand the "no-solicitation zone" at polling places creating an area, constantly shifting and impossible to enforce; restrict voters' ability to receive important non-partisan information about voting at the polling place; limit acceptable IDs for voter registration without proposing acceptable alternatives, preventing eligible citizens from registering to vote, and preventing properly registered voters from exercising their right to vote; increase the frequency of "list maintenance programs" causing more validly registered voters to be removed from the voter rolls; and discourage voter registration drives by authorizing fines up to $250 if completed registrations aren’t turned in within 48 hours.

An economy built on foundations of sand cannot stand. The longer that fictions are maintained in the service of a status quo that controls local and state legislatures, the risk increases of an economic collapse different from anything the United States has experienced in its short history. Whether the end comes in five minutes, five hours, or five months; count on the ratings for Florida's general obligation bonds first be downgraded. The rating agencies are on the case. The frikkin chickens are coming home to roost.


Florida builders poised to pounce

By Kris Hundley, Times Staff Writer

Published Friday, April 17, 2009

TALLAHASSEE — A development boom is brewing under the radar of Floridians distracted by deteriorating real estate values and record foreclosures.

The state is processing an unprecedented number of proposals for new homes and commercial development. If approved, these projects could pump more than 600,000 rooftops onto a market suffering from a surplus of product and slowdown in population growth.

Also on developers' wish lists: the right to build a half-billion square feet of non-residential space.

Such pipe dreams might seem laughable in today's depressed economy and moribund housing market. But property owners with an eye on the future are spinning plans that have the potential to unlock hundreds of thousands of agricultural and environmentally sensitive acres to residential and retail development over the coming decades.

Mike McDaniel, a planner at the state's Department of Community Affairs for 22 years, finds the surge stunning.

"Instinctively, most people would think there would be a slowdown,'' he said. "And it may be true at the other end, where the developers apply for the permit (to build). But there's been no letup here. It's a gold rush."

McDaniel said land owners, eager to turn dirt into money, are behind the push for a record number of new planned communities. Regardless of whether these mega projects become reality, the owners stand to win.

"They want to get the land-use change, strike it rich, then move off to where there are not a lot of people,'' he said.

But where will that leave Florida?

• • •

McDaniel's office at DCA is in a cluster of state office buildings on the southeast edge of Tallahassee. Down the road, a sprawling apartment complex offers a month's free rent. For sale signs dot lawns nearby. Inside DCA's offices, regulators are poring over developers' plans to put more inventory in the pipeline.

McDaniel came to DCA more than two decades ago. Now the 57-year-old chief of comprehensive planning is on the front line, riding herd over the hundreds of projects submitted for state review. His staff of about 30 must analyze huge planning proposals and report back to cities and counties within 60 days. It has been working out to an average of about two rulings a day.

"My nose is so close to grindstone, I don't look up," he said. "We used to see plans calling for 400 and 500 homes and think, 'Woo-woo, big deal!' Now those numbers have quadrupled."

Among the proposals on deck for review at DCA on just a single recent morning:

• Plans for the town of Edgewater, south of New Smyrna Beach, to double in size by jumping I-95 and annexing 5,181 acres. The project, "Restoration," would put 8,500 housing units and 3.3-million square feet of non-residential space on land that includes wetlands, agriculture and bear habitat.

• Fellsmere, a crossroads of about 4,000 in Indian River County and home of the Fellsmere Frog Leg Festival, has annexed about 22,000 acres of farmland for 42,000 homes.

• Wildwood, known for the clogged junction of I-75 and the Florida Turnpike, has stretched its north-south boundaries 15 miles, snapping up empty parcels with plans for up to about 87,000 new homes.

• Bunnell, a burg of 2,000 in Flagler County, has annexed about 80,000 acres.

McDaniel points to a satellite map of Flagler and St. Johns counties that shows plans for four projects totaling more than 20,000 homes and 7-million square feet of non-residential space. "My jaw dropped when I saw this,'' he said.

"Can there possibly be this much need? And is this area really suitable for this intensity of development?"

• • •

The planners at DCA see themselves as gatekeepers of the state's growth management laws. Now there's a sense inside the department that the sentries are being stormed at the gate.

Florida's legislators, eager to jump-start the economy, have proposed everything from eliminating the oversight agency to carving out exemptions for bigger and bigger sections of the state.

Landowners and developers, meanwhile, are taking advantage of the lull to push ahead with approvals so they'll be ready to move at the slightest sign of an uptick. It's not cheap to change an orange grove's potential use from agricultural to residential, but it's a great investment.

"Your property value goes way up,'' said Charles Gauthier, DCA's director of community planning. "Land with an urban designation is going to sell for a higher amount than land with a rural designation."

Another factor behind the deluge of requests for land use changes? Developers' fear that the Florida Hometown Democracy amendment will pass in 2010. It would give local residents, not just municipal or county officials, the right to vote on land-use changes in their neighborhoods.

"We hear from large land owners all the time that they just want to get their property entitled before Hometown Democracy goes into effect," McDaniel said. "They say, 'We might not do anything with this land for 50 years, but we want these entitlements now!' "

While the rest of his staff enjoyed the Easter weekend, McDaniel was preparing DCA's response to the mother of all development dreams, a plan to transform tiny Yeehaw Junction in Osceola County into Destiny, a city of 100,000 homes.

"I keep asking, 'Why me? Why now?' " McDaniel said. "It's daunting."

• • •

In Gainesville, veteran economist David Denslow analyzes what has happened to Florida's real estate market in the past and tries to predict what's coming in the future. Figuring into his projections are the impacts of everything from rising property taxes to falling timber prices.

Denslow said he never considered the possibility that, in light of the current downturn, a glut of new projects would be under review at the DCA. When the department recently pulled together data on all major developments pending and approved since 2007, the totals were staggering: projects covering 410,126 acres, with a potential for 630,965 new homes and 479.5 million square feet of non-residential space.

"This really catches me by surprise," said Denslow, who is with the University of Florida's Bureau of Economic and Business Research. "I'll have to revise my thinking."

He understands developers reacting to a perceived threat like Hometown Democracy. "We saw a little bit of the same phenomenon before the growth management laws first went into effect in 1985, when there was a huge surge in permits," he said.

Also, what local public official would reject a developer who dangles promises of new tax revenues? "It's hard to find a city or county that's antigrowth these days," he said.

Denslow fears that the behind-the-scenes gold rush will doom Florida to relive its past. His assessment: When migration to Florida picks up again, newcomers will find affordable housing aplenty. Existing Florida homeowners, on the other hand, can kiss goodbye any dreams of cashing out big on their homes.

"In the 1980s, Florida had a huge increase in population but house prices, adjusted for inflation, didn't rise at all because the state and counties had been very friendly to development," Denslow said.

"Now nobody in their right mind, even an amateur flipper, could look and say that (housing) prices are going to double in the next 10 years. Prices just won't go up all that much when you've got that number of projects in the pipeline."

• • •

The spigot on that pipeline is controlled by the DCA, which can send plans back to the local authorities for revisions or reject the project outright. Most often the two sides hammer out an agreement.

"I always think the truth will out. That's nice to think, but money can buy a lot of expertise," said McDaniel, who often finds himself the only one in khakis in a roomful of suits.

One such showdown took place this month, when Haines City officials flew up to DCA's offices, two lawyers in tow. The city, well known as one of the last restroom breaks off I-4 before Disney, had proposed big changes for property just outside municipal limits.

Sitting in on the meeting was DCA Secretary Tom Pelham. A lawyer and certified planner, Pelham rejoined the agency in 2007 after having led it from 1987-91 under Gov. Bob Martinez. As one of Haines City's lawyers argued, Pelham rocked back, eyes closing, waiting for an opening. Then he pounced.

"Your plan is meaningless until you annex the land," Pelham said, citing chapter and verse in the law. "This is not something you can casually ignore or it will become a precedent that will spread across the state. And there's a lot of interest in avoiding the land-use process."

Karen Brodeen, a lawyer for the city, cut to the chase: State approval would allow development to start the minute annexation is complete. "If we have to reapply, that will add another 10 months," she pleaded.

Pelham wouldn't budge.

State planners also are holding the line on plans for more houses in Pasco County. Recently the DCA sent back a project for revision that could put 4,500 homes on cattle land south of State Road 52. Regulators point out that Pasco already is drowning in an oversupply of housing units approved but not built: 277,983 units to be exact.

About 8,400 of those lots are in the stillborn community of Connerton, immediately adjacent to the rejected development.

Started in the boom but stalled by the bust, Connerton promises a work/play environment, according to its Web site, with a shiny new clubhouse, playground and retail space. What's missing are the people. The lights are on, but only about 230 families call Connerton home.

"We're facing the same challenges everyone else is," said Stewart Gibbons, president of Connerton. "But I can't disagree that there's an awful lot of residential approved and planned for Pasco."

At the DCA, McDaniel is considerably more blunt. He said that if Pasco stopped approving new housing today, the county could accommodate new residents through 2035 — and still have more than 90,000 empty homes.

But McDaniel has learned that open spaces in Florida, whether they're in cattle or crops, are often treated as little more than a placeholder.

"Many people seem to believe that agriculture is temporary; that someday the land will be developed for housing," he said, saying that kind of thinking led to the quick-flip behavior fueling the last real estate boom. "A lot of that is the bubble mentality."

For Jennifer Seney, an environmental activist who lives in Wesley Chapel, overdevelopment is not an abstract threat. In her Pasco neighborhood, about one-third of the houses are for sale. Home prices are down 27 percent from a year ago. The Cypress Creek well field, on which Seney's home depends for water, is bordered on all but one side by residential development. Now the county wants to put more than 4,000 homes on the untapped portion.

"It's like we can't win against this force of money and greed," Seney said. "I'm just sitting here waiting for my well to go dry."

• • •

If DCA accepts a land use change, that doesn't mean it becomes a reality. Financing, local site planning and market forces determine whether a project comes to fruition.

Dan Molloy, a land-use attorney and developer in Tampa, said people shouldn't be too worried about grandiose plans.

"I could go around the state and pick out lots of different areas and you'd almost laugh about the densities (of development) proposed that are never going to happen," he said. "They'll never be marketable for practical purposes."

But having witnessed the last real estate boom, regulators and environmentalists are reluctant to hand planners a big blank check, assuming it will never be cashed. Once the state approves a land use, only local authorities can initiate a change.

"If there was ever a time for the state to catch its breath, look into the future and decide what's in the best public interest, now is the time,'' said David Guest, managing attorney of Earthjustice's Tallahassee office.

"Instead what's happening is the same syndrome that brought us to financial panic: More money for me, regardless of the future consequences. That leads long term to an unworkable community. It's about as crazy as you can get."

McDaniel fears that if Florida green-lights the huge develop ments pending, the state will repeat the mistakes of the 1960s and '70s,when places like Lehigh Acres and Cape Coral were platted with subdivisions that stood vacant for decades.

He's stumped when people say Florida's economy has suffered because growth management laws restrained development. Said he: "I thought just the opposite."

Times staffer writers Craig Pittman, James Thorner and Lisa Buie contributed to this report. Kris Hundley can be reached at hundley@sptimes.com or (727) 892-2996.


Booms in waiting

Megaprojects either approved, pending or proposed before the Department of Community Affairs would allow the development of 410,126 acres across Florida, with potentially 630,965 new homes and 479.5-million square feet of non-residential space. Here is a partial list of the proposed projects:

1. Escambia County

16,000 acres

15,000 residential units

10 million square feet non-residential

2. Washington County

55,000 acres

30,000 housing units (estimate)

12 million square feet non-residential

3. Bay County

2,045 acres

6,100 housing units

390,000 square feet non-residential

4. Old Kings Park, St. Johns County

6,149 acres

3,630 housing units

2.2 million square feet non-residential

5. Southwood Preserve, St. Johns County

2,800 acres

3,600 housing units

250,000 square feet non-residential

6. Old Brick Township, Flagler County

5,216 acres

5,000 housing units

1.15 million square feet non-residential

7. Edgewater, Volusia County

5,181 acres

8,500 housing units

3.3 million square feet non-residential

8. Farmton, Brevard/Volusia counties

47,000 acres

28,000 housing units

4 million square feet non-residential

9. Fellsmere, Indian River County

21,568 acres

42,084 housing units

6 million square feet non-residential

10. Wildwood, Sumter County

20,409 acres

86,932 housing units

109.6 million square feet non-residential

11. Central Pasco Employment Village, Pasco County

2,384 acres

4,500 housing units

4.65 million square feet non-residential

12. Bartow, Polk County

17,696 acres

11,016 housing units

28.6 million square feet non-residential

13. Yeehaw Junction, Osceola County

20,000 acres

100,000 housing units

(non-residential not yet specified)

14. North Port, Sarasota County

5,771 acres

13,000 housing units

4.2 million square feet non-residential

15. DeSoto County

3,840 acres

12,518 housing units

614,000 square feet non-residential

16. Blue Head Ranch, Highlands County

65,000 acres

54,600 housing units

3.4 million square feet non-residential

17. Okeechobee County

5,683 acres

14,000 housing units

2 million square feet non-residential

18. Miami-Dade County

960 acres

6,941 housing units

900,000 square feet non-residential

Source: Florida Department of Community Affairs

By the numbers

Since 2007, projects approved or requested would allow the development of:

410,126 acres

630,965 homes

479.5m square feet of non-residential space

Build or bust

Why do legislators seem to think we can develop our way out of the state's economic crisis? In Perspective, 1P

© 2009 • All Rights Reserved • St. Petersburg Times
490 First Avenue South • St. Petersburg, FL 33701 • 727-893-8111
Contact Us | Join Us | Advertise with Us | Subscribe to the St. Petersburg Times
Privacy Policy | Standard of Accuracy | Terms, Conditions & Copyright


Tuesday, April 14, 2009

On growth and the miserable performance of the Florida Legislature ... by gimleteye

From the St. Pete Times, here's a lovely interview contrasting the points of view on the development mess and the Florida legislature, featuring the former CEO of St. Joe, Pete Rummell, and Lesley Blackner, a Palm Beach attorney and co-founder of Florida Hometown Democracy. This is a dialogue, by the way, that has had zero coverage in The Miami Herald.


St. Pete Times, Sunday, April 12, 2009
Kindness

Peter Rummell rode Florida's real estate boom for 11 years as chief executive of St. Joe Co., the state's biggest landholder. Rummell, who left in May, made his mark by transforming St. Joe from a papermaker into a "placemaker" of upscale vacation homes in the Panhandle. He's now president of Nicklaus Companies, building golf courses worldwide.

Lesley Blackner, a lawyer in Palm Beach, tapped into the average Floridian's anxiety about runaway development by promoting the Hometown Democracy initiative. The proposed amendment, which Blackner hopes will be on the ballot in 2010, would allow residents to vote on land-use changes, rather than leaving approval in the hands of elected officials. The call to give citizens a voice in local development triggered massive opposition from a coalition of business forces, which is pushing a counterproposal for "smarter growth."

Diametrically opposed on most issues, Rummell and Blackner found one slice of common ground during recent separate interviews on Florida's economic crisis. The two longtime Floridians see a state where real estate prices are in free fall, 300,000 homes stand vacant and reservoirs are running dry. But in Tallahassee, they see legislators trying to dramatically loosen restrictions on development in an effort to restart the economy. Neither Blackner nor Rummell thinks that makes much sense.

"Doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results is the definition of insanity," Blackner said.

Said Rummell, "The alternative is not just to keep doing what we always did." Here is what they had to say on a variety of questions related to development.



When did you sense Florida's real estate market was headed for a fall?

Rummell: In February 2008 I said Florida's real estate market was the worst I'd seen in 37 years. I was right. I just didn't expect it to keep going down.

Blackner: I remember reading a story in 2004 about a commercial window washer buying a half-million-dollar home in Palm Beach County and I thought, "The system has gone insane." Florida just went nuts.

What responsibility do developers have for this downturn?

Rummell: There's no question developers played a role. But unlike some of the other times when developers were clearly guilty of overbuilding, we had real partners in this one, primarily the lenders. There was the availability of credit and stupid mortgages. So it's not fair to say that if the state had had tougher (development) regulations, everything would have been fine.

I would acknowledge that in the euphoria of everything that was happening, we were all guilty. Projects got built that shouldn't have. Loans were made that should not have. Now we have to pay the price. The big question is, how do we methodically dig ourselves out of the hole and learn from it so we don't do it again?

Blackner: There seems to be widespread agreement that the real estate bubble started this financial crisis. For the last 20 or 30 years, the U.S. hasn't really produced much except for sprawl and financial products. Those have been the leading engines of our economy. People who said all that was unsustainable were called party-poopers. Well, the financialization of our economy and sprawl saw their climax in Florida.

What do you see as the biggest danger at this point?

Rummell: Total overreaction. You have Obama throwing everything at the problem. There's the fear that regulators will screw everything down so nothing can move. And that every agency at the state level will make sure not so much as an acre is getting developed. How do you acknowledge what went wrong and fix it without being stupid about it? That's hard to legislate, particularly in the environment we find ourselves in now.

Blackner: One of the principle positions of Hometown Democracy is that, due to developer control of local politics, we really haven't had much growth management in Florida. We have comprehensive plans that are supposed to control growth so there are adequate services, a semblance of a middle-class lifestyle and so local governments don't bankrupt themselves. But those growth management plans don't mean anything if they're constantly being changed, as they have been.

What do you think of the effort by Florida's lawmakers to loosen state oversight of development?

Rummell: Some of that could easily be part of an overreaction in the other direction. I've always said that if you're a good, responsible developer, a difficult but reasonable regulatory environment is your friend. For somebody who does it right, they're not afraid of reasonable wetland rules or (environmental) mitigation rules. I'm the last guy to say we need to take the barriers down. That's a recipe for disaster. You've got to have a responsible regulatory environment.

Blackner: What you see are the sprawl cheerleaders in the Legislature who are desperate to do something to crank up the big development machine even though it's been our undoing. For the past five years, we gave them everything they wanted and they crashed the economy. They don't have another plan for Florida. Building is all they know, all they care about.

What's your reaction to proposals to eliminate the state's Department of Community Affairs, which oversees changes to communities' comprehensive development plans?

Rummell: I don't want to see us dismantle DCA because you think you need to clear the runway for everyone. That leads to bad planning, bad products and bad inventory.

There has to be something beyond the county and city level that acknowledges a lot of growth issues are regional. It's hard to figure out how to deal with that without somehow bringing in the state at some level.

To wipe out DCA feels like an overreaction. On the other hand, you always want to figure out a way to streamline or coordinate efforts. The problem's when you've got redundancy and duplication.

Blackner: During Jeb Bush's administration, DCA was a paper tiger. Under (Tom) Pelham, he's trying to restore some teeth to the DCA, but it's a difficult job. Now the Legislature is trying to gut their funding. If DCA is quiet and rubber-stamps everything, it's fine. When DCA stands up, developers don't like it. We need a strong DCA, and we also need Hometown Democracy because local governments can't be counted upon to protect the public interest. Changes to communities' growth management plans should go to the voters and such changes should be few and far between.

What's our future now that population growth has stalled?

Rummell: The low-hanging fruit, in terms of development, may be gone. The alternative is not no growth. If you want to understand what no growth does, go to Michigan. Florida's got to figure out how to grow more responsibly. It's got to figure out how to make more Scripps (Research Institutes) happen — selective, rifle-shot efforts that worked. It's got to start thinking about being more proactive versus being an automatic receiver (of new residents). The alternative is not just to keep doing what we always did.

The classic second-home business is stalled. So at St. Joe we targeted economic development with a viable new airport (Panama City/Bay County airport under construction) with the ability to be smart about the entitling around there. That will be attractive to somebody. It's a good example of a future which is pre-planned. You're not just assuming you're going to get 1,000 retirees moving down here every day.

Blackner: I'm sure the legislators want to jump-start population growth again, but they ought to focus on the people here instead of having our economy depend on the next 100,000 people to move in. That's why Florida is a Ponzi scheme: The state's economic model depends on destroying the state with endless growth. We don't have the water for it, and we can't provide decent services. It's not a sustainable model.

And "smart growth" is whatever a developer says it is. What St. Joe got with that boondoggle airport was a gift from the taxpayers to pay for sprawl in the middle of wetlands. People who live in that area cannot afford what St. Joe wants to build and nobody was using the existing airport. It's an act of economic hubris by St. Joe and the state of Florida.

Aren't legislative efforts to remove obstacles to development just a return to business as usual?

Rummell: I'm not as close to the inside baseball in Tallahassee as I once was, so I'm hesitant to say. But philosophically it has me worried.

Blackner: The Legislature is controlled by the development industry. Scratch a politician and there's a developer underneath. They're in deep denial about reality but you can't pound nails to prosperity. It's just more of the stupidity that got us into this mess.

Kris Hundley can be reached at hundley@sptimes.com or (727) 892-2996.

Thursday, June 28, 2007

Right Under our noses: House Bill 7203 covers City of Miami, Hialeah and all of Broward. By Geniusofdespair

I went to a Downtown Bay Forum meeting yesterday and heard Carolyn Dekle, Executive Director of the South Florida Regional Planning Council (you all must remember that Katy Sorenson was taken off the Council by Commissioner Chair Martinez last year).

I have an uncanny ability to zone out most of the time but still pick up what is important. I almost hit the floor when Dekle referred to a new law that has truncated review of (State Growth/Planning Reviewing Agencies) DCA and SFRPC. Deckle said the State agencies are moving towards letting local communities take more of a role in their growth management.

I am a pretty regular reader of the Miami Herald and not much slips by me...although I am on overload, but somehow this became a law right under my nose, never saw it in the Herald.

When I got home I quickly called Charles Pattison of 1000 Friends of Florida, a former staff member of the Department of Community Affairs. He said I should have looked on their website 1000 Friends of Florida . The Bill was there. (This is boring stuff but you have to know it so please read on).

In short, the bill is a pilot project. The process affects the City of Miami (not the county YET!) and is basically a modified “small scale” amendment process for all amendments – one hearing, DCA , RPC and state agencies, and any local government that asks, get copies of the proposed amendments, and they can comment if they want but they don’t have to. Individual comments are then sent back to the city, and then a 2nd adoption hearing is held. Any amendments that pass are sent back to the agencies, and the agencies can appeal if they chose. Standing by citizens affected to challenge any amendment remains the same. 1000 Friends wrote:

OVERALL IMPRESSION - not moving in the right direction as many more issues included:
1. makes it easier for development to occur regardless of transportation concurrency issues
2. dangerous extension of local government/developer agreements from 10 to 20 years when revenue forecasting less certain than ever
3. establishes a pilot program in several communities (Broward, Pinellas, Jacksonville, Miami, Hialeah, Tampa) that allows all amendments to be reviewed through small scale amendment process
4. citizens get little from this bill - developers and local governments get relaxed concurrency standards with limited requirement for consistency with the local comprehensive plan

It seems like we need - Florida Hometown Democracy Petition more than ever.

In short order — if the State keeps moving in that direction -- the Vile Natacha Seijas and other County Commissioners will not have the State scrutinizing land use changes they make for their developer pals.

If you hit “Read More” you can see what 1000 Friends of Florida wrote about this bill before it became law:

HB 7203, 2nd engrossed version, with amendments as of May 1, 2007

Our goal this year - only minor changes necessary to fix glitches from SB 360 regarding concurrency and financial feasibility this year, with more substantial and comprehensive revisions in 2008 session.

OVERALL IMPRESSION - not moving in the right direction as many more issues included:

1. makes it easier for development to occur regardless of transportation concurrency issues

2. dangerous extension of local government/developer agreements from 10 to 20 years when revenue forecasting less certain than ever

3. establishes a pilot program in several communities (Broward, Pinellas, Jacksonville, Miami, Hialeah, Tampa) that allows all amendments to be reviewed through small scale amendment process

4. citizens get little from this bill - developers and local governments get relaxed concurrency standards with limited requirement for consistency with the local comprehensive plan

HIGHLIGHTS as we see them on 5/5/07 (subject to update):

1. community redevelopment areas now included in Chapter 163 definition of "urban redevelopment"

2. comp plans deemed "financially feasible" when the capital improvements schedule shows that concurrency standards (for transportation and schools) will be achieved/maintained by the end of the 5 year schedule (means you don't have to meet concurrency in any one year IF you can demonstrate you will meet it by year 5)

3. allows plan amendments to be deemed "financially feasible" as well as meeting the "achieve and maintain" standard with respect to transportation facilities IF

(a) is a condition of development order of a DRI with proportionate share mitigation
(b) is part of a binding agreement with fair share mitigation where the amendment to the future land use map is within designated urban infill, urban redevelopment or urban service area - binding agreement must be based on maximum allowable amount of development on the map and/or in plan policy if less than the maximum
4. adds airport passenger terminals, concourses, air cargo facilities, hangars, aircraft maintenance/storage areas to existing transportation concurrency exemption for public transit facilities

5. clarifies that where urban service areas are to be considered for transportation concurrency, they can only be as large as the area covering a 10 year planning period (means that existing very large urban service areas that allow for more than 10 years of growth will not qualify)

6. allows existing Transportation Concurrency Areas to meet the tighter requirements established in 2005 at the time of the next EAR instead of 2006

7. clarification that DRIs using proportionate share not required to reduce or eliminate existing backlogs on roads and schools - extends this provision as well to Florida Quality Developments and optional sector plans

8. where a school board agrees to include a new facility in its next scheduled work program, developers can accelerate building of one or more schools

9. proportionate fair share mitigation specifically allowed to be focused on one or more transportation improvements - clarification that where such funding "significantly benefits" the overall transportation system as determined by the local government, development is allowed to occur even if concurrency not met

10. Transportation Concurrency Backlog Areas authorized:

a. allows creation of an authority (meaning the appropriate local government) that designates an area where one or more traffic deficiencies exist such that traffic volume(s) exceed the level of service standard (LOS) as found in the local plan
b. provides tax increment financing to raise funds needed to demonstrate that deficiencies will be addressed in 10 years or less - allows for bonds and related financing mechanisms
c. allows development to proceed once the improvement schedule is made part of the comprehensive plan - will be deemed "financially feasible" and meeting the "achieve and maintain" standard now required
d. also requires an overall plan showing deficient roadways, priority improvement list and financing schedule as part of the comprehensive plan
11. allows Jacksonville-Duval to have 720 acres (instead of 120) of small scale amendments/year - no more than 120 acres of such amendments allowed outside designated urban infill, urban redevelopment areas

12. Plan Amendment Review Pilot Progam:

a. designates Broward, Pinellas, Jacksonville, Miami, Tampa, Hialeah to have all amendments reviewed under a modified small scale process
b. local government has transmittal hearing and DCA,FDOT, DEP, Education Commissioner, DACS, DOS, and Game Commission and any requesting local government may or may not comment within 30 days - Regional Planning Council comments limited to regional issues - use Chapter 125 or 166 notice requirements - DCA encouraged to focus on state and regional issues
c. local government has adoption hearing to consider any comments using Chapter 125 or 166
d. amendments go into effect if not challenged within 30 days
e. citizen standing allowed as before, with "preponderance of the evidence" test; state agencies may also challenge
f. any rural land stewardship, optional sector plan, EAR update amendment, implementation of any new statutory requirements, and new plans for newly incorporated areas required to use current system
g. Administration Commission takes final action within 45 days if administrative law judge recommends "not in" finding; DCA receives recommendations if "in compliance"
h. Where DCA finds amendment "not in", sends on to Administration Commission; if it finds "not in", may apply sanctions; if finding is "in", enters final order
i. OPPAGA to present evaluation report by December 1, 2008, to Governor, Speaker and President on pilot program
13. DCA gets 4 new positions for technical assistance

14. DRI buildout dates extended by 3 years without becoming substantial deviations

15. Community Workforce Housing Innovation Pilot Program (CHWIP) for building affordable housing renamed "Representative Mike Davis Community Workforce Housing Innovation Pilot Program

16. Conservation easement revisions which also appear in a DEP sponsored bill appear here regarding "Tax Increment Financing for Conservation Lands"

17. When Port Master Plans are integrated into a local comprehensive plan as part of an EAR, and the EAR is found not sufficient, the port master plan may still be adopted

18. DCA authorized to use rulemaking to implement Local Update Census Addresses (LUCA) tech assistance grants

Thursday, December 11, 2008

Mike McDaniel Testified Yesterday. By Geniusofdespair

This hearing is historic, because during Jeb Bush's Governorship, there was little support given to the DCA. The next step was rarely taken (if ever)...the needed step of enforcement.

I have often explained the role of the (DCA) Department of Community Affairs in Growth Management in Florida. Mike McDaniel, Chief of the Office of Comprehensive Planning at DCA, put a face on that Department for me at yesterday's Administrative Hearing in downtown Miami.

McDaniel is passionate about what he does, committed to do the right thing for us citizens. I liked him immediately. He rattled off numbers of goals, objectives and policies of the County's Comprehensive Plan (WHICH THE COUNTY WROTE AND THE COMMISSIONERS APPROVED) and how the County Commission violated the Plan's goals, objectives and policies in voting to move the Urban Development Boundary for the Lowe Big Box Store near the Everglades and the Brown application for some office park (even closer to the Everglades) in an agricultural zone. (Hit read more)

Mike believed everything he said, that the contents of each and every Comprehensive Plan serves as a roadmap to help Florida grow rationally. If Cities and Counties don't follow their plans (they do so badly for the most part), trust me, it could even get worse in Florida with growth gone wild. This hearing is historic, because during Jeb Bush's Governorship, there was little support given to the DCA. The next step was rarely taken (if ever)...the needed step of enforcement.

I believed McDaniel and I believe his motives are genuine and pure and I can't stress how important I believe these Comprehensive Plans are (if enforced).

McDaniel was the most credible witness for the future of a sustainable Florida and I trust him with our future, as a watchdog for us. I was surprised the opposing attorneys didn't throw up their hands yesterday and say: "You're right, Mike. We give up." I guess my optimism is why the State Legislature has it in for the DCA and would like to dismantle the Department.

Monday, January 07, 2008

South Florida Regional Planning Council: What the hell is it and why did they vote on our UDB? By Geniusofdespair

Believe it or not, we do have growth management guidelines in place in Forida. Really, I am not kidding. I am not calling them laws, because they have no teeth but there is this shitload of rules that exist.

Quick civic lesson: The Dept. of Community Affairs (DCA) is the State Department in charge of growth management. There is this part of the DCA, which I don't quite understand, called the South Florida Regional Planning Council (SFRPC) which votes on regional issues. Regional issues are those that impact more than one county. The SFRPC offices are in Hollywood. Government elected officials from Broward, Miami-Dade and Monroe County sit on the SFRPC board. The 3 Miami County Commissioners on the SFRPC are Moss, Heyman and icky Pepe Diaz. Katy Sorenson was removed by that snit Joe Martinez when he was Commission Chair. It was ugly.

Anyway, The SFRPC met this morning to evaluate, among other things, the 3 applications to move the UDB line that the County Commission moved forward (remember the Mayor's veto and the override?).

The outcome of the vote on the 3 applications to move the Urban Development Boundary at the SFRPC:

Applications 5 and 9 - SFRPC Transmitted the applications to DCA as inconsistent with the Regional Comprehensive Plan. This is a good thing. Pepe must not have been a happy camper on the Lowe's application. The "school property" that Lowe's was going to sell cheap did not entice Broward and Monroe County members of the board.

Application 8 - (The one way West on Kendall Drive) went through with small caveats...Moss, the Mayor's appointee and a Commissioner from Monroe voted no. Everyone else transmitted it. Sally Heyman supported it and spoke in favor of it — she was the cheerleader for some dumb road right-of-way the developer was dangling in front of Miami-Dade County and the developer proposed removing any residential element from the application.

Now the 3 applications are officially transmitted to the Department of Community Affairs for review and we can send our personal comments to them: Paul.Darst@dca.state.fl.us and Charles.Gauthier@dca.state.fl.us.

Boring, huh?

Here are the members of the SFRPC:
ASSEFF, Patricia B. (Chair)
Wimbish-Riteway Realtors
950 South Southlake Drive
Hollywood, FL 33019
PHONE - 305-931-8266
FAX - 305-933-1141

BLYNN, Michael (Immediate Past Chair)
Councilman, North Miami
15516 Biscayne Boulevard
North Miami Beach, FL 33160
PHONE - 305-947-8882
FAX - 305-947-9420

BROOK, Scott J.
Mayor, Coral Springs
9551 W. Sample Road
Coral Springs, FL 33065
PHONE - 954-344-1142
FAX - 954-757-1770

CHERNOFF, Jay R.
Commissioner, North Miami Beach
17011 NE 19th Avenue
North Miami Beach, FL 33162
PHONE - 305-948-2986
FAX - 305-787-6036

DIAZ, Jose "Pepe"
Miami-Dade County Commissioner
Miami-Dade Center
8345 N.W. 12th Street
Miami, FL 33126
PHONE - 305-599-1200
FAX - 305-470-1791

GUNZBURGER, Suzanne
Broward County Commissioner
Governmental Center
115 S. Andrews Avenue
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301
PHONE - 954-357-7006
FAX - 954-357-7129

HEYMAN, Sally
Miami-Dade County Commissioner
Miami-Dade Center
111 N.W. 1st Street, Suite 220
Miami, FL 33128
PHONE - 305- 375-5128
FAX - 305- 372-6179

LIEBERMAN, Ilene
Broward County Commissioner
Governmental Center
115 South Andrews Avenue
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301
PHONE - 954- 357-7001
FAX - 954- 357-7295

McPHERSON, Morgan
Mayor, City of Key West
P. O. Box 1409
Key West, FL 33041
PHONE - (305) 809-3840
FAX – (305) 809-3847

MOORE, Carlton
Vice-Mayor, Fort Lauderdale
Fort Lauderdale City Hall
100 N. Andrews Avenue
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301
PHONE - 954- 828-5011
FAX - 954- 828-5667
MOSS, Dennis C.
Miami-Dade County Commissioner
Stephen P. Clark Center
111 NW 1st Street, Suite 320
Miami, FL 33128
PHONE - 305-375-4832
FAX - 305-372-6011

NEUGENT, George
Monroe County Commissioner
Stephen P. Clark Center
25 Ships Way
Big Pine Key, FL 33043
PHONE - 305-872-1678
FAX - 305-872-9195


PEREZ, Marta (Vice-Chair)
Miami-Dade County School Board
1450 NE 2nd Avenue, Suite 700
Miami, FL 33132
PHONE - (305) 995-2794
FAX - (305) 995-2786


RIESCO, José A.
Certified Public Accountant
Jose A. Riesco, PA
2801 Ponce de Leon Boulevard, Suite 1000
Coral Gables, FL 33134
PHONE - (305) 445-0777
FAX - (305) 446-8576

SCUOTTO, Joseph (Secretary)
Commissioner
City of Sunrise
10770 West Oakland Park Blvd.
Sunrise, FL 33351
PHONE - (954) 746-3250
FAX - (954) 746-3243

SPEHAR, Dixie M.
Monroe County Commissioner
500 Whitehead Street, Suite 102
Key West, FL 33040
PHONE - (305) 292-3440
FAX - (305) 292-3466


WALTERS, Sandra
Sandra Walters Consultants, Inc.
6410 5th Street, Suite 3
Key West, FL 33040
PHONE - 305-294-1238
FAX - 305-294-2164

WEXLER, Lois
Vice-Mayor, Broward County
Governmental Center
115 South Andrews Avenue
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301
PHONE - 954- 357-7005
FAX - 954- 357-7044

DONN, Gary L.
Director of Planning and Programs, Dist. 6
Florida Department of Transportation
602 South Miami Avenue
Miami, FL 33130
PHONE - (305) 377-5900
FAX - (305) 377-5967
KENNEDY, Chad
Watershed Management & Planning
Program Manager
Department of Environmental Protection
400 N. Congress Avenue, Suite 200
West Palm Beach , FL 33401
PHONE - (561) 681-6661
FAX - (561) 681-6755

WATERS, Elbert (Bert)
South Florida Water Management District
Broward County Service Center
8211 W. Broward Boulevard, PH3
Plantation, FL 33324
PHONE - 954-713-3200, ext. 4981
FAX - 954-475-4169

Sunday, December 23, 2007

What you can do about the Urban Development Boundary Now. by Geniusofdespair

Don't discount the Dept. of Community Affairs. The County Commission vote was to pass the Comp Plan ammendments to the DCA for review. The DCA need to get comments from the public. Send these two men an email with your comments:
charles.gauthier@dca.state.fl.us
and copy to
Paul.Darst@dca.state.fl.us

Comments should talk about the UDB line and why you think it is important for Miami Dade County.

You might talk about how the DCA is suppose to be the growth management agency, and ask them -- politely -- to manage our growth by listening to the opinions expressed by our professional Miami Dade County Planning Dept. and not the opinions of the majority of our political hacks who are puppets of developers and lobbyists.

A pefect sample letter is in the Miami Herald yesterday scroll down "County commissioners' priorities are misguided" to a letter by Alex Calderone. Thank you Alex for a very good letter! That is County Commission Chair Bruno Barreiro as the puppet on a string.

Thursday, February 28, 2008

State of Florida says: Don't Move the Urban Development Boundary. By Geniusofdespair

The Miami Herald reported yesterday online that the word from the State of Florida is: Don't move Dade development line. (Hit on image above to enlarge it)

The Miami Herald said:
"The 13-page opinion -- firmly worded within the constraints of legal and bureaucratic language -- is a setback for developers hoping to bring new homes and stores to the county's western reaches. The most visible proposal, a Lowe's at Southwest 138th Avenue and Eighth Street, has drawn jeers from expansion foes but some support from nearby residents who want convenient shopping."

Regarding this "Support" the Herald spoke of: Most of the support presented at the Commission Meeting for this Lowe's application was because the Lowe's store dangled a carrot to the community - besides the store. They were offering to SELL land for a school West of the store. The people wanted the school. The promise of land for a school has as much to do with "Good Planning" as Natacha Seijas has to do with "Good Government." Some neighbors did indeed want only the store. However, Lowes owns at least 11 acres WITHIN the urban development boundary, enough room for a store (Home Depot built a store on 10 acres in North Miami, and isn't one on 8 acres in Coconut Grove?). See my previous post: Greedy Bastards.

More from the DCA opinion:

I. CONSISTENCY WITH CHAPTER 163, F.S., AND RULE 9J-5, F.A.C.
The Department has completed its review of the proposed City of Miami Amendment 08PEFE-1 and has the following objections and comments.

OBJECTION NO. 1: INADEQUATE PLANNING FOR POTABLE WATER SUPPLY
Proposed Amendments 5, 8, and 9 are not supported by adequate planning for potable water supply.
The proposed future land use changes in Amendments/Applications 5, 8, and 9 all increase the potential demand for potable water from the properties involved. All three applications also require that the County’s Urban Development Boundary (UDB) be moved to accommodate the proposed urban uses. According to information provided by the South Florida Water Management District (District) in its report to the Department on Amendment 08-1, the 20-year Consumptive Water Use Permit (CUP) issued by the District to Miami-Dade County in November 2007 was based solely on population projections within the current UDB. The same population projections underlie DCA Table 1 in the settlement agreement between the Department and Miami-Dade County to bring Amendment 06-1 into compliance. DCA Table 1 demonstrates that the County Water and Sewer Department (WASD) will have a sufficient potable water supply to meet the expected demand in its service area out to 2030. The demand estimates were based on population projections for WASD’s service area. The information contained in DCA Table 1 was instrumental in the compliance agreement between the Department and County, because it demonstrated that the potable water demands of ordinary growth would be accommodated by the water to be produced from WASD’s proposed new alternative water supply sources, which were included in the capital facilities schedule in the Miami-Dade County Capital Improvements Element.

The three proposed UDB amendments, however, are located outside the delineated WASD service area, which was the basis of the water demand projections agreed upon between the District and WASD for the CUP and for DCA Table 1. If this potable water service area is expanded to include the three UDB amendments, it would be expected to have a greater potential population and a greater potential water demand than the existing delineated service area used to provide the basis for the CUP. This greater potential water demand must be matched by an additional planned supply of water. The three UDB amendments fail to identify the new water supply source, nor are the amendments supported by adequate data and analysis to demonstrate they can be provided an adequate water supply based upon current water sources.

The District, in its report to the Department, also points out that until the new Hialeah Floridan Aquifer reverse osmosis facility goes on-line (4.72 million gallons a day scheduled for 2012), the County has limited “new” water to meet its anticipated growth within the UDB and must rely heavily on water conservation and system savings to avoid a deficit. A portion of the water from this plant is already committed to the City of Hialeah as part of the 2006 settlement agreement between the Department and Miami-Dade County (Case No. 06-2395GM). Therefore, data and analysis to document the availability of water to meet the anticipated municipal growth for the next 5 years is essential to ensure adequate water supply before approving land uses outside the UDB that might compete for the same supply. The District also notes—(1) that the requirements of the limiting conditions within the CUP would need to be met prior to providing water supply to any development(s) outside of the current service area; and (2) that any delays in completing the County’s $1.6 billion worth of new water and sewer infrastructure projects will cause a shortfall of water supply with respect to projected growth within the existing UDB.

Recommendations
The County should not adopt the proposed land use changes until it can demonstrate the necessary coordination of land use approvals with an assured supply of potable water. Revise the amendments to demonstrate coordination of the proposed land use changes with the planning and provision of potable water supplies. Identify any needed facility improvements for the 5- and 10-year planning time frame. These improvements should be coordinated with the Water, Sewer, and Solid Waste Element and the Capital Improvements Element, including implementation through the 6-year schedule of capital improvements of any facilities needed during that time frame.

OBJECTION NO. 2: 10-YEAR WATER SUPPLY FACILITIES WORK PLAN
The Department objects to Application 13 because the proposed Water Supply Facilities Work Plan (Work Plan) does not identify and evaluate the potable water utilities serving the unincorporated areas of the County, other than the Miami-Dade County Water and Sewer Department (WASD).

In addition, according to the comments received from the South Florida Water Management District, the County’s 10-year water supply facilities work plan and the associated water supply facility improvements listed in the Capital Improvements Element are not consistent with the projects, programs, and other requirements of the County’s Consumptive Use Permit.
The County has not adopted potable water level of service standards for nonresidential uses such as office, industrial, and mixed-use. Such standards would be helpful in assessing future water supply needs for site-specific non-residential land use amendments.

See the attached report from the South Florida Water Management District for additional information concerning these objections.

Recommendations
Miami-Dade County should revise the Work Plan to include a plan for building water supply facilities, including development and use of alternative and traditional water supply projects and conservation and reuse programs necessary to serve existing and new development for a minimum 10-year period for each potable water utility serving the unincorporated area of the County.

The Work Plan and the CIE should be revised to be consistent with the projects, programs and other requirements of the CUP, as noted in the District's comments.

The County should adopt potable water levels of service standards for non-residential land uses such as office, industrial, and mixed-use.

The County should coordinate with the South Florida Water Management District in preparing its revised Work Plan, in response to the above objections.

OBJECTION NO. 3: INTERNAL INCONSISTENCY WITH COMPREHENSIVE PLAN
Proposed Amendments 5, 8, and 9 are not consistent with the Miami-Dade County comprehensive plan. All three applications request a change of the future land use designation on the property to the Business and Office land use designation on the Miami-Dade County Future Land Use Map. Business and Office allows commercial use and residential use.

The Miami-Dade County comprehensive plan contains policy guidance for moving or expanding the UDB, particularly in Land Use Element Policy LU-8F. Policy LU-8F states that the UDB should contain developable land having capacity to sustain projected countywide residential demand for a period of 10 years after adoption of the most recent Evaluation and Appraisal Report (2003) plus a 5-year surplus (a total 15-year countywide supply beyond the date of EAR adoption, out to 2018). Policy LU-8F also addresses the adequacy of non-residential land supplies and states that this shall be determined on the basis of land supplies in subareas of the County appropriate to the type of use, as well as the countywide supply within the UDB.

According to the Miami-Dade County comprehensive plan, therefore, demonstrated or calculated need for additional land designated on the FLUM for residential (or commercial) use is a key criterion for expansion of the UDB. If the current supply of vacant land designated for residential inside the UDB is sufficient until 2018, there is no need to move the boundary line; and, in fact, to move the boundary line in order to allow more residential-designated land would be inconsistent with the comprehensive plan, barring a demonstration that the supply of residential land inside the UDB will be depleted before 2018.

The Amendment 08-1 package included analyses by the Miami-Dade County Department of Planning and Zoning (DPZ) of the projected demand for and supply of residential (single-family and multi-family) and commercial land out to 2025, the end of the planning period. In performing this calculation, DPZ projects total countywide population and estimates the rate at which the existing vacant residentially designated land within the UDB is being depleted. DPZ calculates the countywide housing depletion date to be 2019, which is more than 15 years from the date of the last Miami-Dade County EAR (2003). Therefore moving the UDB at the present time for a residential FLUM amendment, as represented by Applications 5, 8, and 9, is not consistent with the Miami-Dade County comprehensive plan.

According to DPZ’s supply and demand calculations, there is also no need to expand the UDB in order to add new commercial-designated land, as would be permitted in the proposed Business and Office land use designation for Applications 5, 8, and 9. Therefore, moving the UDB at the present time for a commercial FLUM amendment, as represented by Applications 5, 8, and 9, is also not consistent with the Miami-Dade County comprehensive plan.

Additional policy guidance on expanding the UDB is contained in Policy LU-8G in the Miami-Dade County comprehensive plan regarding what kind of lands should or should not be added to the UDB. Policy LU-8G states that the following areas (among others listed in the policy) shall be avoided: (a) future wetlands delineated in the Conservation and Land Use Elements, and (b) land designated Agriculture on the FLUM.

Regarding Application 5, this site contains wetlands delineated in the Conservation and Land Use Elements of the Miami-Dade County comprehensive plan and therefore should be avoided when considering lands to bring within the UDB, pursuant to Policy LU-8G. Regarding Applications 8 and 9, these sites are currently designated for agriculture on the FLUM and therefore should be avoided when considering lands to bring within the UDB, pursuant to Policy LU-8G.

The Department concludes that expanding the UDB to add the properties represented in Applications 5, 8, and 9 would be internally inconsistent with the Miami-Dade County comprehensive plan.

Recommendations
Retain the current land use designations and the current UDB location. Alternatively, provide data and analysis which demonstrates that the proposed land use and text amendments are consistent with Land Use Element Policies LU-8D, LU-8E, LU-8F, and LU-8G and with Chapter 163, F.S., and Rule Chapter 9J-5, F.A.C. - snip -