Wednesday, March 16, 2011

We did it! Natacha Seijas recalled by 88 percent of voters !!! by gimleteye

Eyeonmiami takes a measure of credit for that 88 percent. If our blog helped to inspire some of the volunteers who are substantially responsible for organizing for the recall of Natacha Seijas, all I can say is: at last. Where to begin? Perhaps 1993, when I began to have an inkling of the political order in Hialeah precincts that hold so much influence in state-wide elections. From that time-- as a citizen activist and environmentalist-- wherever there was a roadblock, Natacha Seijas was manning the barrier. No more.

I am certain commissioners who once quaked in fear of her power can't quite believe it. She is gone. Some will step forward to take the scepter from the builders, bankers, lobbyists and rock miners. They have a contingency plan (although none imagined this economic crisis would be such a lasting, deep fact. Not the board members of US Century Bank, or the South Florida Builders Assocation, or the Chamber of Commerce.) We'll get to that, soon enough. But first, a review of what happened yesterday.

Yesterday, the most powerful politician in Miami-Dade County, Natacha Seijas, was thrown from office in a special recall election by an astounding 88 percent majority. Certainly the outcome shows voters are furious. But do they know what Seijas really represented, never mind the issue of taxes?

We have 341 posts on Eyeonmiami, on Seijas. No other source of information is as complete and thorough, and that includes the mainstream media that shied away from telling how the political order kept Miami a speculator's dream, ending in the worst real estate bust in its history.

Seijas adapted, quickly, to her role as enforcer on the 13 member, single district county commission. When Art Teele left the county commission in 1996, she didn't need to be pushed to the role. Where Teele played commissioner against commissioner and lobbyist against lobbyist, in the school of Machiavelli, Seijas preferred direct, brute force. She had the unions and the real estate developers/lobbyists who understood that the way to a gated estate in Coral Gables was through precinct politics in Hialeah. What counted was that key lobbyists got their piece of ka-ching at the airport and the seaport. Chris Korge. Rodney Barreto. Sergio Pino. Miguel De Grandy. It was at the airport where fortunes were made. Seijas played the key role for many years, until the lobbyists became developers and suburban sprawl took off like a bottle rocket on the Fourth of July. Seijas, then, used the airport to enforce the majority on the county commission, but even as the plan to convert Homestead Air Force Base to a money pit collapsed under its own weight, the real money had migrated to the conversion of farmland and wetlands to suburban sprawl. In Florida, political power blossomed under the fertilizer of insta-grow suburbs and strip malls. Today Seijas' political fortunes now mirror her chief supporter, Pino, who built wealth first at the airport then in platted subdivisions in the western suburbs pushing up against Miami Lakes and the real estate fortune of the Graham family. It has all turned to shit, now.

As lead organizer against the hijacking of the Homestead Air Force Base to be a private commercial airport, I learned their playbook and game plan. Art Teele helped me understand it. It didn't change over the years and involved, at its most simple level, commandeering billions of tax dollars to support infrastructure projects to benefit insiders, all of whom were either lobbyists or developers or some combination of the two. Seijas was their all-utility fullback; she could block and tackle and could scare the daylights out of anyone in her path, especially staff at the county terrorized by internal meddling. Where Carlos Alvarez took his job as a largely ceremonial function, with the county manager balancing in between, Seijas lorded it over the county with a mean streak a mile long.

Seijas faced a first attempt to recall her in 2006. Supporters from the Growth Machine raced to her defense. Those in favor of her recall were a small group of civic activists including Pat Wade from the Redland, Michael Pizzi, and Millie Herrera who had enough of Seijas' reign. The fumes of the housing boom were still getting most people, high. Voters gave Seijas, thumbs up.

Yesterday's thumbs down could not have happened without the support of Norman Braman, whose multi-million dollar investment brought the recall to voters. The result depended, too, on a dismal economy in Miami-Dade where the real rate of unemployment is close to 20 percent. Last but not least an intrepid group of recall activists, led by Vanessa Brito, took the campaign into the heart of Hialeah where Seijas believed she was invincible.

It is hard to say what happens, next, in Hialeah. The sharks are circling for a chance to influence both Seijas' district and Miami-Dade County. Will they allow Seijas to have a role in choosing the new political order, to include Julio Robaina? What would be more astounding than yesterday's result would be if a grass roots movement took hold in Hialeah and re-arranged the dysfunctional political order organized around land use zoning changes and airport contracts to deliver state and national elections. Perchance, to dream.

Today it is enough to say, Seijas is gone. As for Carlos Alvarez, the best that can be said is that he was not Alex Penelas, his predecessor who badly tarnished the office of mayor in Miami-Dade. Perhaps it is a harsh judgment of Alvarez; but he never grew into the job. Alvarez was static. Invisible. Alvarez was strong on the Urban Development Boundary, but that left the work to the unreformable majority to override his veto, throwing cost and trouble back onto poorly funded environmental groups. Alvarez did not build constituencies so much as avoid them. He did not surround himself with leaders or thinkers or advocates so much as to insulate himself with friends and associates he was comfortable with. He made less of the job and some historic blunders as a result-- like leading on the Marlins Stadium-- or flinching from ethical standards in the police department when it looted environmental funds collected and dispersed by the US Department of Justice.

Alvarez' recall will make national news, but the more interesting event is Hialeah rejecting Seijas. The devastating avalanche-- 88 percent in favor of recall-- speaks volumes to those on the county commissioner who would be the next mayor, or, imagine that they can fill Seijas' double wide shoes. I doubt there is a single one who could survive a recall election. And if Joe Martinez or Pepe Diaz or Bruno Barreiro get it in their heads that they can commandeer the Urban Development Boundary arbitrage like Seijas did, think again.

Seijas once threatened a fellow commissioner, that she would be taken out of the commission chamber in a body bag. Citizens who testify at public hearings are now free from the receiving end of her rude comments and asides. (I was accustomed, when testifying, to her rising from her seat and disappearing from the dais to do something more important in the back hallway.) Yes, Seijas reserved special scorn for environmentalists, reminding them on behalf of her benefactors that she didn't represent the birds and the bees. Former Commissioner Katy Sorenson who Seijas spent years teasing and insulting should derive a measure of satisfaction from last night's result. To the citizens who mobilized two recall efforts, who were threatened, sued and intimidated by Seijas and the Hialeah police, thank you. If you listen very closely, you can hear the muffled applause of manatees floating beneath the calm waters of Biscayne Bay. Seijas didn't like manatees or their protections and never stopped enjoying, saying so. Don't think of what the manatees do, as squirting and farting. For now think of those watery noises, as the last word.

32 comments:

Plato said...

Alvarez was a gullible empty-suit who simply turned over the reins of government to County Manager George Burgess. Burgess and his cronies then ran Alvarez's political career into the ground. They convinced Alvarez that he was "doing the right thing" each time he followed their bad management advice. Alvarez's recent comments suggest he still doesn't know what hit him.

Anonymous said...

No rest for the weary gimleteye. In case it slipped your notice, there are new bad plans to use HARB for an international aerospace show. This has garnered some discussion at hearings, but you know now-a-days the mantra is jobs jobs jobs. Is anyone enforcing the agreement the county made when land at the base was conveyed to it? Someone should be asking some difficult questions or before you know it your worst fears for the base will have snuck up on you.

Anonymous said...

Great post.

Anonymous said...

Bringing Miami-Dade back one recall at a time!!!
Great day for the citizens of South Florida.
Thanks Gimlet, for keeping the hope alive!

Anonymous said...

What was that prediction of Seijas' wannabe attorney Cody? Seijas would win the recall election? He is only a slightly worse election prognosticator than he is attorney. Get that man on FOX!

Must have been the same prediction he gave Seijas about the court case he (mis)handled for her. "Don't worry Natasha-baby, I got the lawsuit under control."

I guess he needs to add more law books to the office which is located in the garage of his wife's Palmetto Bay home, or at least start reading the law books.

Joke around the courthouse:
Q: How do you know when you are going to win your lawsuit?
A: When Stephen Cody files his notice of appearance as attorney for the opposing party.

Stephen Cody, the only attorney who doesn't have a key to his own office: he uses a garage door opener.

Anonymous said...

Genius… you may not want to take too much credit, no pun intended. Because you will also have to take credit for having Steve Bovo from Hialeah replace VNS. (Rivera’s and Marco’s sidekick and the developers sweetheart) in addition to having Julio Robaina also from Hialeah (don’t need to elaborate there, I think) or little Joe Martinez become our next mayor. A real upgrade Genius. At the end of the day it is about money… Liked to have seen Britto or you do this without Braham pumping 2,000.0000 dollars into this mess. Thank you for posting this comment…

Geniusofdespair said...

This is not my post commenter above. This is Gimleteye's post. I did not even vote for his recall.

Anonymous said...

They are gone but their damage to the environment and the financial well being of the county and the general public at large will be everlasting. While VNS was the poster girl for everything wrong with county governemnt, Alvarez personified the detached arrogance and entitlement mentality of those on the inside and on the county payroll. For example, when one makes the kind of money Alvarez was being paid, they can afford their own vehicle and do not need car stipends and sure as heck sent the wrong message to strapped taxpayers by leasing that BMW at our expense. Yes, a strong messge was sent last night and I am encouraged by the margin of defeat suffered by Seijas but the wizards behind the curtain at County Hall who have already dumped Seijas'contact info from their Blackberrys and Iphones, have read the tea leaves and groomed other cardboard cutouts to place in office to continue their dirty work. Until the basic structure and culture of county government is up ended, the faces may change but the script and agenda will remain the same. Only history will tell us whether the recall results were one small victory in the never ending was on corruption or are a modern version of the shots heard 'round the world signaling a true revolution. Certainly, it is my hope that the people will feel energized and empowered to force real change and demand responsiveness from those we place in office.

Gimleteye said...

To address the commenter, that what comes next could very well be worse; was Alvarez better, relying on George Burgess to manage the county according to Natacha's playlist? Could what comes after Burgess be worse than having Shiver or the cast of characters before him, who now have comfortable pensions working for large engineering companies, as county manager?

Anonymous said...

A lot of high five's at county hall this morning. Thank you Harvey Ruvin.

Anonymous said...

"BEWARE THE IDES OF MARCH", Caesar!

On a lighter note, I was hysterically laughing when the BCC set the March 15th date! (I guess most of them forgot their world history, or Shakespeare).

I think this date should be the permanent recall election date for the BCC/County Mayor whenever it falls on a Tuesday.

Gimlete, I've never seen you and Pizzi happier. Too bad Pat Wade couldn't be here.

What the future holds will be interesting.

As Braman said, and I absolutely believe him, this is not over. Charter Reform is next because the BCC won't do it - we the voters will have to. That in itself, is an absolute travesty to the BCC who don't have the will of the people first, not last.

Genius - Yes, whoever hires Murphy should be on the next BCC recall list!

As to Burgess, if the BCC continues to kiss his butt, and rubber stamp his agenda, they should be on that recall list too.

Throw 'em all out said...

In a mood for more recalls? Dissatisfied voters in Miami Lakes are gearing up to recall Micheal Pizzi and Nick Perdomo. Let the blood letting continue.

Anonymous said...

A couple words here.

First, not all the public employee unions supported VNS. The firefighters did not.

Second, with regards to charter reform, Braman better start paying attention to what is happening in Tallahassee real freaking quick. The Repubs are considering several pieces of legislation that will hamstring home rule. If the state legislature keeps it up, a home rule charter could soon mean nothing at all. This concept seems counter to the fundamentals of the R party. But I don't think any of them care.

Anonymous said...

Beware the DIP. George Burgess resigned today. Now, look for him to receive the golden parachute called the Departure Incentive Program, which bestows health insurance to him and his family FOR LIFE. I hope someone is minding the store.

dan renzi said...

My first thought was, "Eye on Miami must be soooooo excited about this."

Anonymous said...

Well, all this is for not if we have the same type of folks in those positions. We can go from bad to worst in a hurry, based on the candidate list I have seen so far.

Anonymous said...

We already have Bell whose apprenticeship under Seijas was cut short but I am sure she is up to the task of being the new Queen of Mean.

Anonymous said...

Sorry, but Bell is no Seijas. She is going to cower now, as her god-mommy just got smacked by the voters... She already started yesterday, voting against Seijas dumping her entire budget.

Anonymous said...

Thank you EOM, Michael Pizzi and Vanessa Brito, and thanks to those intelligent voters who decided that enough was enough! Hopefully, we will be able to continue on this cleaning course. By the way, it doesn't cease to amaze me how the people believe that Alvarez was an empty suit, who thought he was doing an ok job. You should all realize that he is far more sinister than his chum, Alex Penelas, an individual whose "temperament" made him far more transparent. Nah! Alvarez came, and now he'll be gone and no one has even noticed that he has been far greedier and much more calculating than Penelas ever was; the great difference is that he knows how to do things in a most reserved manner. That's why Penelas and the "bank boy" were happy to have him in office!

Anonymous said...

I am very unhappy about Natacha Seijas recall. She has done so many good things for the residents of Miami Lakes I am very appreciate to her.

Anonymous said...

No, Ma Bell will not cower. She was astute at picking up the pieces after her asswooping in Homestead and look at her now, a County Commissioner. Flinn made the mistake even after being warned. DO NOT UNDERESTIMATE Lynda Bell.

Anonymous said...

The masses wanted change and they got it. I too was pleased with Seijas getting booted. She is bad for Miami Dade County. One must feel bad for Alvarez. He was used by George Burgess. He counted on Mr. Burgess making the right choices, and he didn't. I cost Mr. Alvarez his job.
Let's focus on building our government back and lets focus on putting in safeguards that prevent a repeat of history.

Mr. Karpoor, Mr. Loftus, Mr. Lorenzo, do us all a favor and resign. Your committment to a system that was flawed is evident that you are not fit to be department directors.

Anonymous said...

Carlos Espinosa, go.

Anonymous said...

I am curious to know what anonymous above has against Carlos Espinosa? He is a big improvement over his predecessor, John Renfrow current head of WASD.

milly herrera, hialeah said...

The PEOPLE have SPOKEN loud and clear. March 15 is surely a day of Jubilation.

This should also be sending an even louder "voice" to all the other commissioners who we should not forget also voted to raise taxes, have attempted to pass local legislation in favor of the red light cameras, voted for the tunnel and Marlin stadium, and favor special interest groups.

Remember them the next time they are up for election and get them out of there!

Anonymous said...

Kapoor, the head of Transit has modernized MDT and done good things like train to airport , easy card, realtime notification for train location - buses coming soon, and more. All this even when he gets little financial and adminstrative support. The Commissioners hate him because he figured out a way to save money by cutting the inefficient bus routes that they had requested to serve their 1 constituent on a certain street. The County Manager therefore did not like him because he tried to make decisions with integrity instead of caving to the commissioners. Kapoor also is saddled with a supervisor (Yort) who cares more about maintaining tight relationship with DOT and MDX - more about building more roads and putting in more tolls than about providing public transportation. No, he is not perfect. No, he inherited a big mess from prior Director Bradley, who saddled the department with his relatives and friends and making decisions to keep the commissioners happy. (Bradley is still trying to be part of the game by joining on a consulting firm that is trying to make the busway into a toll road.) Yes, I agree Kapoor could have done a better job of keeping on top of staff and addressing the issues with FTA. But he was not lying cheating or stealing or hiring his relatives or kissing Commissioners butts.

Carlos Espinoza does always think he is right about everything, and doesn't have a clue about the internal politics going on in his own department but he has integrity and a spine and he is at least smart and understands environmental issues, unlike Renfro, who wouldn't have a clue how to run his department without his deputy directors.

Anonymous said...

Watch for the cracks in the foundation of County government, significant revelations bubbling to the surface, and I advise all honest politicians to stand clear of the blowback from County Hall.

Revolutions of this magnitude are rarely clean, short-lived affairs. The status quo has been broken.

Anonymous said...

Karpoor clean? Then how come he approved transit workers to get paid by us taxpayers and had them working on the campaign for Alvarez.
The next mayor needs resignation letters from all of the department heads and then pick the ones worth keeping.
Get rid of these over priced cronies

Anonymous said...

Was that post praising Harpal Kapoor meant to be a joke? Kapoor is an incompetent boob whose ineptitude caused $182 million in federal money to be frozen at transit. He should have been fired yesterday.

Anonymous said...

08/31/2004
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
DISTRICT 13
Natacha Seijas MILLAN 12989
Alan W. RIGERMAN 1825
Jorge ROQUE 5492

03/15/2011
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
DISTRICT 13
Yes To Recall
Natacha Seijas MILLAN 16999

Anonymous said...

Wait, which citizens did Seijas sue?

Anonymous said...

Correction:

08/31/2004
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
DISTRICT 13
Natacha Seijas MILLAN 12989
Alan W. RIGERMAN 1825
Jorge ROQUE 5492

03/15/2011
BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS
DISTRICT 13
Yes To Recall
Natacha Seijas MILLAN 17677