NO on Amendment 8:This column was referred to me by a reader. Amendment 8 is an important issue that I don't know that much about so I thought I would share a second view on the subject, this one is against Amendment 8 (I printed a guest blog in favor of the Amendment on Tuesday):
By Representative Bill Heller (D-St. Petersburg, he has a doctorate in Education)
It is time to end the days of packing 30 or more students into a classroom with one teacher.
Florida is a step away from permanently fulfilling the constitutional mandate voters approved in 2002 guaranteeing that students learn in smaller classes. Unfortunately, the mandate is under siege by Amendment 8 on the 2010 General Election ballot. Voters should reject this misguided attempt to cut money needed to keep class sizes small in
Florida's already underfunded public schools.
Amendment 8 comes at the worst possible time for our public schools. Per-student funding is at its lowest level since the 2005-2006 school year. The Legislature has forced school districts to finance public education by increasing local property taxes rather than complying with the constitutional mandate to properly fund schools with state resources. (Hit read more...)
The Class Size Amendment has saved public education from massive cuts during these difficult times. While Florida's overall budget declined by about $6 billion in the last five years, public education received almost $19 billion since 2002 thanks to the Class Size Amendment. Of that, $16 billion went to hiring new teachers, buying classroom supplies, upgrading classroom technology and other things needed to
teach students in a more individualized and supportive environment.
Some advocates for weakening the amendment say there is no evidence that smaller classes help students learn. They are wrong. In 2009, University of London psychology and education professor Peter Blatchford found "a clear case" for the benefits of smaller class sizes. He found student performance in math and reading improved in smaller classes, especially in the earliest grades, and that children were more engaged and less disruptive in smaller classes. Minorities did especially well in smaller classes. His findings were published last year in the Psychology of Classroom Learning: An Encyclopedia.
Research released earlier this year suggests the benefits of smaller classes follow students into adulthood and their careers. Raj Chetty, a Harvard economist, and others found that students who participated in Tennessee's Project Star experiment with smaller class sizes in the 1980s had higher incomes, were healthier, and had significant social gains than those who were taught in larger classes.
Researchers and teachers will confirm without equivocation that small class size in the early grades is critical to success in middle school and high school. Still, Amendment 8 dismisses the value of small class sizes in all grades. I believe the greatest investment Florida could make is to sustain small class sizes, especially in the early grades.
Instead of listening to politicians who want to weaken the Class Size Amendment, I urge you to listen to the teachers who recognize the importance of giving each child more individualized attention. Keep the guarantee in the Florida Constitution that public school students will be taught in smaller classes, and demand that the Legislature meet its responsibility to fund smaller classes by voting NO on Amendment 8. It's the right thing to do.
1 comment:
Thank you for posting this article. As a teacher, I can tell you that providing personal attention to all is impossible when you pack students into classrooms like sardines. When this occurs, as it does in a can of sardines, individuality is lost. I mean, can you identify singularities in a can of sardines?
Besides that - classrooms. schools, and science labs built recently, have been designed to accommodate 26 students maximum. Have fun doing a science lab in a lab room built for 26, now occupying 32 students and 2 teachers. Oh yes, high school students are at least twice as large as elementary school students. Tiny chairs and tiny tables just don't cut it.
Here is an anecdotal story for you. At the beginning of the school year, science teachers discuss lab safety rules and procedures; one of these is fire safety. If a child catches on fire (God forbid), they are supposed to "stop, drop, and roll" in order to extinguish the flames (unless they are right next to the safety shower). So I took my class of 29 students to the tiny lab room (made for 24 to fit cozily) where we proceeded to go through lab safety protocol. Students then asked "Stop, drop, and roll, Miss? But where?"
Post a Comment