Monday, August 03, 2009

EYE REPORT: Planned Road Improvements Lead to More Taxpayer Subsidized Sprawl. By Geniusofdespair & Gimleteye.

When you are trying to figure out development trends that benefit land speculators who crashed the economy, look no further than planned road improvements. Large scale development projects must solve the problem of "transportation concurrency". Endless games are played by lobbyists and so-called transportation planners to create rationale and formulas showing how the expansion of roadways at the fringe of suburbia solves the problem of moving prospective, new as well as old residents through new and existing communities. County commissioners (like Joe Martinez and Pepe Diaz and Natacha Seijas) beholden to their campaign contributors involve themselves in the minute details to transportation and roadway issues in order to lay the rails for majority approval of new developments outside the UDB. This like jig happens all over the county (like Lowe's or Beacon Lakes, to cite just two).

We get to see the jig at public hearings as part of the zoning process by local government. Lawyers making $750 an hour and planners and economists and other consultants get up in the speaker's pit with charts and Powerpoint presentations that overwhelm the few members of the public who purposefully offer counter-arguments to more suburban sprawl. Often, the speculators pay for rent-a-crowds to pack the commission chamber. They have no clue what they are doing there, beyond the box lunch and bus ride downtown. When Joe Martinez asks: "would all supporters of this project rise"; they dutifully stand up from their movie quality armchairs and sit down again once this irrefutable evidence of community support is demonstrated for the cameras.

There are two roadway projects that are in different stages of approval at County Boards who serve at the behest of the County Commissioners. These projects were conceived well before the housing market crash: putting down infrastructure to move hundreds of thousands of commuters around Miami-Dade takes years of planning and land buying. Both activities put developers, speculators, and government officials in virtual 24 hour Love Motels for Growth.

Both of these roadway "improvements" will give wind to Lennar's 1,000 acre mixed-use mega-development, Parkland, and to the Krome Gold partners who own hundreds of acres nearby. We've written a lot about Parkland and Krome Gold: check our archive. Their owners are the same big-time lobbyists and developers whose domination of local zoning councils and elected officials helped grease the gears of the Growth Machine that caused the housing bubble and, now, collapse.

It was reasonable to expect that many of these project would have drowned of their own weight and costs with the implosion of the nation's banking industry. But the Federal Reserve and US Department of Treasury have created "rescue" interventions that allow banks (and investors) the time to tread water with their speculative investments while the rest of taxpayers are gradually waking up to their liabilities-- in the form of rising taxes-- to fund the same government operations that allowed these manipulators to drive our quality of life and the economy into the ditch in the first place.

The tens of millions in speculative investments in Krome Gold and Parkland are now assets buried amidst trillions of dollars committed by US taxpayers that will make sure bad projects never die. Now that the "stimulus" funds are flowing, they are flowing as Eyeonmiami suspected they would in ways that will benefit the speculators. Far from being cleaned out, as they should have been, the speculators are lurking in the shadows for their return. In no small respect, this is also what is behind the effort to erase the Florida Department of Community Affairs: let local governments, ie. the Miami-Dade County Commission, "determine" concurrency requirements. It is the final realization of the Bush Doctrine: that local elected representatives are the best place to center regulatory power and authority. In fact, it is about using the current economic emergency to feather the nests of the land speculators. As the bumper sticker goes: if you are not outraged, you are not paying attention.

First, they need the roads. Hit on the the two aerials at left and you can see that both of these new planned roadways end at Parkland; thousands of new housing units planned in a region that is now surrounded by ghost town suburbs, many of which were also built by Lennar.

The MDX says about the 836 Expansion: "…the project is envisioned as a limited access expressway that will represent a physical barrier to discourage urban sprawl farther into the Everglades." What a crock of shit. It will do the exact opposite. From time to time, the South Florida builders have mumbled about using Krome Avenue as an "inviolable" border for growth that could only be breached for instance by the unanimous vote of the County Commission. It is a card that is lazily played when it seems that maybe the Growth Machine won't get its way, and the retracted when it does. The public has every right to be furious. When the widening of Krome Avenue was under mediation, authorized by the state and supervised by a mediator sympathetic to the Growth Machine, the County Commission rejected an agreement forged by its own planners with environmentalists that Krome widening would never be used to justify new population growth.

MDX is in the process of preparing a concept report to evaluate the feasibility of the 836 extension. The extension is known as MDX Project No. 83618. MDX wants to include this in the 2025 Master Transportation Plan. Cost? Who knows.

For the 157 Avenue expansion the County has to purchase 16 parcels from 152 Street to SW 184 Street as a "Public Necessity." The purchase was approved by the CITT on May 28th. The MDX website reports that the agency "Will complete a Concept Report in early 2009 to evaluate the potential of a new transportation corridor extending SR 836 to SW 136th Street in West Kendall with provision for an urban buffer". According to Tere Garcia of MDX: This potential project was identified when a needs assessment was done as we started to update MDX's Long Range Plan in 2007. We follow the same cycle as the MPO. The Concept Report being prepared is a very preliminary planning document being prepared to assess need. This document is still in draft form and in review. As soon as its completed we will post in our website as we do all our studies.

Here is the truth. The Miami-Dade land speculators care about only one thing: rescuing their net worth from investments that are now worth ten cents on the dollar or seventy cents. The difference will be worked out depending on getting their friggin roads.

17 comments:

Anonymous said...

Why couldn't the 836 extension act as the same physical barrier that the Sawgrass expressway does in Sunrise and Tamarac?

m

Anonymous said...

Spoken like a lobbyist for former Senator Bob Graham.

Tony Garcia said...

Why spend a few hundred million on a highway to stop development when all we have to do accomplish the same goal is to simply enforce our own growth management laws - for FREE!!!!
This project is a huge misallocation of money, and a symbol of bad sprawl planning and plain ignorance. Building new highways and expanding existing ones to 'alleviate' traffic is like loosening your belt to 'alleviate' weight gain. We need to understand that congestion is a fact of urban living (even in suburbia), and focus our attention - and dollars - on expanding the choices available for to people to get around. We cannot build our way out of traffic problems, nor should we even try. Manage congestion - yes, reduce - no.

Wake up and smell the ghg's people.

Anonymous said...

Excellent, thanks. All roads lead to Lennar!

Anonymous said...

Four laning Krome? FDOT, MPO, SFRPC, let's get all the players on the roster.

Anonymous said...

I think the same money that FDOT and MDX could be using to simply build more roads should be re allocated to improving our public transportation system. The only thing that can lead Miami to solve its mobility problems are taking cars off the road and increasing density where this potential is a possiblity, at the core or the east.

How does spedning more on road construction even become part of the stimulus money anyway? It should all go to Public Transportation and GREEN initiatives...instead it has fallen into the hands of agencies with buisness as usual attitues? How do we change the thinking of FDOT?

Anonymous said...

Rooftops follow roads; every idiot knows this. Between Rodney Baretto and his cronies and Barry White pretending to represent the people, extension of 836 is a killer of farmland and quality of life. These projects are disasters.

Anonymous said...

To the anonymous poster 2 posts above me:

I agree, "The only thing that can lead Miami to solve its mobility problems are taking cars off the road..."

So when are you giving up your car? Come on, lead by example. Go without a car for 1 year.

m

Mapquest said...

Not-a-Moderate: I like the challenge. I drive a short spot to the busway for a job downtown.

How about you?

You also know that the Sawgrass Expressway does not "act as a physical barrier" to westward development. The State owns everything west of the roadway. It is called a Water Conservation Area.

Are you advocating the purchase of all lands west of Krome? What a Commie you've turned into. That's a fast transition from right to left. Do you consider yourself a moderate because you're both leftist and right-winger?

Anonymous said...

I have never lived west of 57th avenue. I have been lucky enough to avail myself of the free trolley service to the metrorail station which deposits me downtown.

m

Mapquest - you should know better than anyone (given your moniker) that my political views are "all over the map". I try not to pigeon-hole myself.

Anonymous said...

4 laning Krome Avenue is a necessity. Too many people have died needlessly on that road. Our community needs Krome to function as an additional escape route during hurricane season, too. Please think this one through before you blindly follow the naysayers.

Anonymous said...

Last anon;Sounds like you bought into the lies. The fatalities on Krome are no worse than other state roads in Miami-Dade. In addition, Krome has suffered from poor design, no police enforcement and terrible maintenance. The fatalities have dropped like a rock from their all-time high in 2002.
Krome is not designated a hurricane evacuation route and the prevailing FEMA doctrine is to discourage evacuations so people are not trapped on the road. Krome does serve a manadatory evacuation area except 8.5 sq mile which is now 4 sq miles since the feds bought out half the area and the Americana Village mobile home park. These people either go to relatives/friends or a designated shelter.
The 4-laning was nothing but political and perpetuated sprawl.
The Krome Avenue Action Plan, which did not call for 4-lanes has never been completed but the safety impact of the partially completed plan has been remarkable.

Anonymous said...

The Krome Avenue IN-Action Plan is not sufficient. We need full funding and 4 laning of Krome to stop the deaths. Please post the source of your statistic.

Anonymous said...

Testimony of Richard Grosso at Watershed meeting:

The agenda for tomorrow’s meeting includes an item on Krome Avenue. By way of full disclosure, I represent clients who oppose a Miami-Dade County comprehensive plan amendment to plan for 4-laning Krome Avenue even prior to
the completion of the FDOT planning process that will determine if 4 lanes are actually needed over some or all of the road’s 33 – mile length. That case is the
subject of pending litigation. Also, there are two ongoing FDOT studies of the 2
separate segments of Krome Avenue (north and south), which are designed to
answer the question of how best to accomplish the improvements needed on the various segments of that road. Both the South Florida Regional Planning Council
and the Florida Department of Community Affairs have recommended making the minimal improvements needed to address the safety and other issues, so as not to
provide traffic capacity that would encourage development that is otherwise
discouraged by the County’s comprehensive plan. A few years ago, the state,
Monroe County, and community interests in the Keys resolved a decades-old controversy over a proposal to 4-lane the “18 mile stretch” from Florida City into
the Keys. The result was an “improved two-lane” project which responds to all
community, environmental, safety and evacuation issues. It is currently under construction. We think an “18 mile stretch” type of solution should strongly be
considered for Krome Avenue.

Anonymous said...

Rodney Barreto wants Krome 4 laned. Isn't that enough?

Anonymous said...

Barry White is a good guy....just a bit naive. I feel badly that he was slammed here. I think he means well. The problem is that good people tend to think that everyone else tells the truth. It ain't so. We are the United States of Greed. Sorry, Barry.

Anonymous said...

Anonymous asking for the Source:
It comes from being an author on the Krome Avenue Action Plan, from attending and presenting at all the county and Homestead Krome hearings,  from 2 years on the Krome CAC, research for the CAC, and from being a party to the lawsuit and the appeal over the 4-lane issue. I dare say no one has been more involved than me; over 20 years! The sources are voluminous.