Tuesday, February 12, 2008

In Miami the fraud goes on, by gimleteye

Recent examples of apparent mortgage fraud (dredged up by our blog, eyeonmiami.blogspot.com, through an analysis of publicly available data) show that gaming big lending institutions is still a victimless crime so long as everyone gets a slice of the vig.

We're not sure who gets paid off or how the fraud is tolerated by banks: those aren't phantom losses that are being reported, in the hundreds of billions.

Today's credit crisis started in subprime mortgages and is spreading to other forms of consumer debt: it was tripped by a chain of fraud stretching from the top/ down and bottom/ up: from sleazy land use lobbyists to appraisers on the take, from mortgage brokers to zoning councils in the back pocket of developers, from local county commissioners taking Bahamian poker chips, to bankers on Wall Street taking down millions in bonuses, straight through to Congress and the Bush White House.

President Bush, the decider, isn't solely to blame for steering the US economy into a long-delayed recession. The essential feature of the credit crisis--the explosion of toxic financial derivatives that no one, not even financial institutions appear to fully understand--was the decadal shift in the structure of the US economy from a nation that produced what it consumed, to a nation increasingly in debt to producers and energy suppliers.

In those years when the future president was trying to be an oil man or baseball executive, Wall Street was practicing how to sell junk as AAA rated investments. That wasn't George's fault.

It was Wall Street, itself, that prevailed during two terms of President Clinton to reduce, eliminate, and eviscerate the capacity of regulation and regulators to track exactly what risks were being undertaken, in the pursuit of "free markets".

But it was Dubya who ascended to the presidency through the enthusiasm of big campaign contributors from the Growth Machine that understood--in the example of Florida's hands-off approach to growth that pushed Jeb Bush into Florida's Governor Mansion in 1998--how victory resided in limited government.

Of course, the size of government hasn't been reduced at all. To the contrary, as trenchantly noted by Floyd Norris in the New York Times, "... seven years into his presidency, George W. Bush is in line to be the first president since World War II to preside over an economy in which federal government employment rose more rapidly than employment in the private sector." (Job Growth Where Bush Didn't Want It, February 9, 2008)

It's the collateral price of homeland security: the proverbial bank vaults were left unattended while law enforcement stretched to the point of breaking, spying on and hunting down purported enemies of the state.

If you are startled by news that Miami courts dealing with foreclosures are clogged, imagine if all the cases of Miami mortgage fraud were prosecuted.

This is what disaster capitalism looks like and it is why investor confidence in the good faith and credit of the United States has been badly shaken.

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

The thing is that they don't need to prosecute all the fraud...just some of it so that other crooks will at least consider the fact that there might be some risk involved. That alone should reduce the amount of fraud.

Anonymous said...

Right anonymous, we need some high profile examples to shove under the bus. Maybe some bank execs...

Anonymous said...

No, remember it starts with the brokers. Take their licenses away.

Anonymous said...

Who to blame? The blame game. You never win.

Anonymous said...

This is a well established mafia -elected officials, lobbyists, developers, mortgage brokers, bankers, appraisers, and ordinary citizens, who have found another way to "milk" taxpayers. Our government is rushing to save their skins at our expense. The mafia never loses -they are above us all!

Anonymous said...

As a real estate broker it amazes me that something is not done.
Even if you don't want to prosecute, but the lender should protect itself.
For the lender it is very easy to spot a property with a dubious appreciation. Then, either you want to prosecute right away, or just let know the mortgage broker, the appraiser, the buyer, the buyer's real estate agent and maybe the seller's real estate agent that they are doing something illegal and share this information with the other lenders.
The simple fact that they don't do it shows me that they don't WANT to do it.
If so many people can spot mortgage fraud so easily, why don't they spot it right away. Then you blacklist the mortgage broker as well as the appraiser and that's it. They aren't so many appraisers you know. We don't even need to prosecute. Just weed out the bad people.
There is something I don't understand there.
Best regards.
FD @ Condo Hotel South Beach

Anonymous said...

It is no coincidence that big developer Armando Codina (isn't he better known as "let me fill in some more wetlands Armando?") was Jeb Bush's partner before Jeb became Governor. Jeb was always a booster for the big developers that caused the unbridled growth that has now swamped Florida.

Anonymous said...

Take brokers licenses away, what good will that do in this market?